• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What can be meant by: "Knowledge is the true organ of sight, not the eyes."

Extracts from this document...


TOK Graded Writing Assignment No. 2 5. What can be meant by: "Knowledge is the true organ of sight, not the eyes." (Panchatantra) Shirin Naz Bahrami 12/21/02 D-0943-008 I pledge that I have neither given nor received unauthorized aid on this work. -Shirin Bahrami 5. What can be meant by: "Knowledge is the true organ of sight, not the eyes." (Panchatantra) The Concise Oxford Dictionary defines sight as "n. faculty of perception through response of brain action of light on eye." Many, however, would agree that this definition is incomplete. It is incomplete because it fails to take into consideration the fact that without at least some previous knowledge, what one sees will not have much meaning; sight can be considered 30 percent as the biological or anatomical process of the treatment of observable data by the eyes, and as 70 percent analysis by the brain of the object relevant to its own archival knowledge. A new object that is merely glanced upon in passing will not be fully understood or may not even be seen, as it will not be analysed to the full extent that it should be. Hence, while the eyes are necessary in order to decode the message sent to our brains through light, without knowledge of what is being perceived, the object deflecting light-which may be as wondrous as an atomic bomb-may be perceived as no more than a three-dimensional metallic object. ...read more.


As also evident in the foregoing example, what the eyes and the brain see can be completely different. The Little Mermaid's eyes saw a fork, but her brain, unable to parallel the fork with any other archival data, translated the metal utensil into a comb. Same argument may be true for language: While one may see with their eyes, letters arranged in a particular order, without knowledge to make sense of the intent of the letters the letters would be meaningless. For example, a foreigner who comes to the United States from a country where they use the same type of alphabet but speak a different language may see important signs and, without knowledge of what they are saying, act in a manner that jeopardizes his health and the health of those around him. Even more likely is that the foreigner will automatically not notice many of the signs that he does not understand. Why? Because although the eyes received information that the signs are there, the brain is baffled and therefore chooses to ignore many of the unfamiliarities in order to comfort itself. As Reuben Abel stated, "What enters the eye is not really seen until it is organized by the brain." ...read more.


The archaeologist may uncover tools unparalleled in our society; since he has no knowledge of what the unknown object is, he analyses it carefully and justifies his conclusions based on his knowledge of his own society and emotions (knowledge by acquaintance) and what he has learned through his studies as an archaeologist (knowledge through study). Therefore, though it is essential that the object be observed carefully through the eyes, it is also very important that the observer has some sort of knowledge in order to be able to see what there is to see. While it is important to realize that our anatomical manifestation has designed the eyes as the organs of sight and has wired our brains to associate light activity with colours, dimensions, and emotions, knowledge is essential in the correct analysis of what is being observed. Therefore, although knowledge cannot literally be defined as an organ, to take the quote as literally referring to knowledge as a tangible entity would be inherently flawed. Knowledge, affected by belief, justification, and emotion, is the indispensable 'organ of sight,' as without it what one sees is no more than raw data. After all, one only sees what he wants it to be. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Classical Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Classical Studies essays

  1. AntigoneDiscuss and analyse the themes which arise in Sophocles' Antigone

    Another theme is the threat of tyranny. The audience at that time would have been sensitive to the idea of tyranny and the fine line between a strong leader and a brutal tyrant. Creon is in many ways a sympathetic character, but he often abuses his power.

  2. What were the roles, privileges and rights of women in both public and private ...

    Land owners are fortunate people, even though landownership in a conquered territory could not be the mark of privilege that it had been in a city-state like Athens. Under Roman rule, there was no differentiation between women and men in terms of political rights in the sense that both sexes were equally subject to the Romans.

  1. How would an Epicurean respond to Callicles argument (in Platos Gorgias) on pleasure?

    With an agreement that all men should not harm each other, an Epicurean may secure his own freedom to seek out pleasures without the risk of pain from others; it must also, therefore, be necessary to sacrifice certain pleasures if they put others at risk of pain.

  2. Shakespeare one word play in King Lear

    heath, he remarks that "The tyranny of the open night's too rough/For nature to endure" (?, iv, 2-3), his attention is directed mainly to the physical part of our nature, of course. When "nature" means our physical nature, it refers in effect to our body.

  1. Odyssey Commentaries (Books 2 & 6)

    'probably has deep roots in folktale'5 before being adapted for this poem, explaining the disparity between expected and actual outcomes. That, nevertheless, does not make any romantic motif that may exist irrelevant; it simply diminishes its status in the narrative.

  2. The analysis of pregnancy in Pietro the Fool and Peruonto

    In those times, the inexplicable pregnancy of a daughter was clearly a serious concern particularly for noble families, but also for commoners. At stake were the legacy and pride of a family - as in "Peruonto", when the king announces that "my daughter has provided me with the horns of

  1. Was the Roman Empire inherently aggressive towards its neighbours?

    more confidential authority, they robbed and ruined in every direction amid universal hatred and terror. Slaves were bribed to turn against their masters, and freedmen to betray their patrons; and those who had not an enemy were destroyed by friends."2 How were the Romans so successful in maintaining their empire?

  2. Odysseus(TM) Cretan Tales as the Homecoming Tales of Other Heroes

    to Eumaios.6 Besides evoking emotion from his listener, Odysseus wants Eumaios to find him a hero the way Athena did. Odysseus is a Trojan War hero, and his entire identity revolves around this herohood. Telling heroic stories lets Odysseus keep alive his most important attribute while he tells his lies.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work