• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Are The Media Racist? Discuss using appropriate examples with particular reference to Pilger's concept of 'unpeople'.

Extracts from this document...


Are The Media Racist? Discuss using appropriate examples with particular reference to Pilger's concept of 'unpeople'. "It requires a certain contortion of intellect and morality to condone one set of atrocities as 'blunders' while humanising one set of victims and dehumanising another." John Pilger 2000, Hidden Agendas1 The aim of this essay is to discuss whether or not the media, specifically the British media, are racist. Using Miles' definition of racism as my standard as well as its symbolic and aversive incarnations, as discussed by Saeed, I will attempt to analyse the representation of ethnic minorities in broadcast media and the press, with reference to the work of Stokes and Van Dijk ('question of numbers'), Ferguson ('the problem within'), as well as Gilroy and Saeed ('question of identity'). To relate the discussion to current issues in the media I will draw on work by John Pilger and Michael Parentti as well as specific examples and issues such as Asylum seekers, the September 11th aftermath and the present Iraqi crisis. So, are the Media racist, and if so to what extent? The current international situation in Iraq and the recent events following the events of September the eleventh go a long way to answer this very question on an international level, but its the media's portrayal of ethnic minorities here at home that can deliver the most worrying truths. ...read more.


That's like all British people being represented by 'thugish' football hooligans: it just isn't justified. This is reiterated in 'A Question of Identity' (Saeed, Gilroy) where the media try and use extremism, fanaticism and other negative issues to cloud the representation of minorities. The British press went ballistic when the figures for asylum applications were published earlier this year. In 2002 there were around 50,0008 applications off people from war torn and politically unstable nations like Afghanistan, Zimbabwe, China and Iraq. At present it is estimated that there are currently 300,000 asylum seekers resident in the UK for one reason or another. A drop in the ocean when you consider the population of Great Britain is approximately 58,564,000. The above number looks big out of context but they were able to fuel a public outcry in doing so. Those taking up residency (and indirectly second and third generation minorities who were born here) were seen as being a burden on the state as well as being in competition for housing, jobs and schools. These social problems become redefined as race issues,9 which generates further ill feeling within the uninformed British public toward ethnic minorities on the whole. "They not only set the agenda for public discussion but more importantly they strongly suggest how the readers should think and talk about ethnic affairs." ...read more.


Within the field, there may well be media institutions that are racist but the majority of the main stream outlets fall in to the above category. That doesn't mean to say that it is right. A bias to the national cause is only natural, and shouldn't be discouraged but a serious investigation should be undertaken to look at how ethnic minorities and non-western countries are represented in the media and how they could be represented more accurately. Not only does it insult those represented unfavourably but it also insults the intelligence of those who read and believe these 'half-baked' stories. Word Count; 2,366 1 John Pilger; www.pilger.carlton.com/media/articles/19227 2 Data - Glasgow Media Group. See Appendix 3 Miles, 'Racism' 1989 4 Saeed, 'Media and New Racisms'; Media Education Journal, page 20, Issue 27, Dec 1999 5 Saeed, 'Media and New Racisms'; Media Education Journal, page 20, Issue 27, Dec 1999 6 Stuart Hall; 'Black Men, White Media'; Journal of the Caribbean Artists Movement, vol 9/10, 1974 7 Stuart Hall; 'Revealed: How UK Media fuelled race prejudices', www.chronicleworld.org 8 Marie Samson, The Guardian, February 28th 2003 9 Amir Saeed, 'A Question Of Numbers'; The Media and New Racisms, 1999 10 Daily Star, 'Up In Arms' February 27th 2003 11 Sgt Eric Schrumpf, US Marines; Guardian Newspaper, Apr 10th 2003 12 Stuart Hall; 'Revealed: How UK Media fuelled race prejudices', www.chronicleworld.org 4 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Paper-based media studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Paper-based media studies essays

  1. A critical review of newspaper articles published in October 2003, 'after' the war in ...

    108).' (Zelizer, 1997: 402) This is evident in the content of the articles printed in the three separate papers. The tabloid's main focus within the article is on sensationalising the events, promoting an anti-war attitude, whilst the broadsheets believe their readers to demand further 'factual' knowledge, which is given through statistics, details of reports, and quotes from government officials.

  2. Representation of Black Women in Vogue UK: Is Fashion Racist?

    The number of British Vogue magazine covers featuring a black model, or a black woman for that matter, is easily countable. The first black model to cover British Vogue was Donyale Luna, in March 1966. 'Blacks were finally awarded their first cover [...] when she became the first black model to feature on the front of Vogue.

  1. When Truth is the First Casualty of War

    (Gralnick cited in Wilson 2003). Journalists who attempted to report on controversial issues and events could risk ostracism and expulsion from the military unit. Also, embedded journalists may "find themselves rationalising away and stifling their journalistic instincts because of their increasing loyalty to the military (Miskin et al 2003)".

  2. To what extent does the print-media influence young people into smoking, in relation to ...

    Some people are influenced when they see advertising or images in magazines and on billboards. Many young people smoke simply because their parents smoke, it may be easier to justify the habit if a role model or someone in authority such as their parents, are smokers.

  1. 'Great historian or great liar' Which description best fits Herodotus?

    What the citizens of Athens were used to, understood and were entertained by were the epic stories of Homer, with regards to their digressive style and varying content between historical and mythological elements. Herodotus work is believed to have similarities to that of Homer and if the opinion that Herodotus

  2. In this critical analysis I aim to identify and examine how the Benetton Group ...

    I used semiotic analysis to establish what identity formations are mobilised in its representations of the product/company. One has long hair and appears to have a feminine nature about him as he has one arm loosely draped around one member of the group and a hand placed on the shoulder of another.

  1. My essay will analyse the heroes in the following four texts, The Epic of ...

    This is again shown through her androgynous disguise as a male soldier, suggesting that her gender prevents her from being a true "hero". She cuts her hair short and takes her father's armour in order to appear as a bulky masculine soldier.

  2. This paper examines the influence that media has on adolescent females feelings towards their ...

    Self Esteem and Body Image The media is an ever-pervasive influence, which helps to present, enforce, and maintain the perception that ultra-thin, non-average body forms should be the desired goal of all women. The portrayal of over-glamorized models presented in fashion magazines, television, and movies sends the message that in

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work