Part of The Student Room Group

  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Cultural and Technological Determinism Advantages and disadvantages as a tool for analysis of development of media.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Cultural and Technological Determinism Advantages and disadvantages as a tool for analysis of development of media Li, Xiaomei Social Science Department Loughborough University Introduction Technological determinism and cultural determinism are two main theories on media development. Brian Winston criticizes the technological determinism in his paper "How are Media Born and Developed" and develops his theory of cultural determinism. This paper focuses on discussing Brian Winston's cultural determinism, analyzing its advantages and disadvantages. It also supports of McLuhan's technological determinism. Believing that technological determinism is a useful theory and technology is a dominant force shapes and changes society. Section 1 A summary of Brian Winston's paper "How are media born and developed?" "Technologies are neutral." This stance is sometimes associated with critics of technological determinism, they say we shape technology and at the same time we decide which one to use and how to use it. Brian Winston is quite different; in the first sentence of his paper "How Are Media Born and Developed?" he notes that "Technologies are not neutral. They embody ideas, needs imagination, and the possibilities from specific periods and places." He admits the important influence of technology on the media development and further explores the notion of causality, that one phenomenon inevitably follows another, by comparing two broad approaches, technological determinism and cultural determinism. ...read more.

Middle

Section 2 Analysis of Brian Winston's cultural determinism 2.1 Advantages of cultural determinism In my point of view, Brian Winston manages to present us a solid history of "how are media born and developed" from a different angle. He shows us a broader view that not only technology but also economic, political, and social factors could influence the media development. His theory implicates that we could control the media and makes it work in a positive way. By comparison, McLuhan thinks that the modes of communication change and determine the society; he reduces human relations to media and ignores the people who control and use media. He also states no matter how technology is used, it has of itself a number of positive and negative consequences. From above, we could find that McLuhan's theory does a good job of analyzing what happened in the past and what is happening now, but not what might be the future communication because by his account, technology runs automatically. Human are impotence in front of it. Contrarily, Brian Winston's theory helps but not hinders us in coming to an understanding of the world. ...read more.

Conclusion

Nick Stevenson offers this historical summation of McLuhan as follow: In cultural and media studies, his ideas were at first warmly welcomed as making a major breaking through in articulating some of the dimensions of the emergent of electric culture. But the bubble of enthusiasm was soon to burst, and McLuhan's propositions were widely dismissed as exhibiting a form of technological determinism. Nowadays, with the development of electronic and digital communication, more and more scholars begin to rethink the rationality of McLuhan's theory. Just as Wasser,Frederick comments: In 1998, we need no longer consider whether his fame was deserved or not, the exposition in digital communications has confirmed his prophetic statement about global villages and media environments. Conclusion The debate continues over this topic between "technological determinism" and "cultural determinism" will continue to gain more attention as we are pushed into a world of telecommunication and advanced technology. It can be said true that "technological determinism" is a dominant force that shapes and changes society. Even if in Brian Winston's theory, technology is also seen as a very important factor. It can either be seen as a threat to our own free will, or it can be seen as a guiding tool that leads us to more effective ways of communicating. Either way, it is a force that cannot be overlooked. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Electronic Media Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

or


Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Electronic Media Studies essays

  1. facebook: communication

    The cause of her death is the dreadful injuries as she being hit by traffic before jump from the bridge which 30 feet high from land. According to her parents, Steve and Anita, her late 15 years old daughter being bullied by her school's friend and "the girls used to

  2. The Necessity of Technology in Sport

    Overall it would be a wise decision to use technology effectively in sports nevertheless it should be used at a limit and only used when necessary as technology should never outshine the human mind and exceed our intelligence over a limit as we are also capable of playing games and surviving without technology!

  1. Create a report that describes four or more ICT technologies open to all members ...

    Tabs could be kept on these young offenders so if they offend again they are dealt with correctly. Police are able to simply type in the number plate on a car and the database recalls any information known about the car, where it was bought, who owns it, whether it

  2. "Does Technology have an essence? Define what this might be and critically assess how ...

    Techne could also encompass the meaning of "a form of meaning in the widest sense", episteme. The essence of technology, techn�, is a matter of bringing-forth, poiesis; it is something poietic." "Thus what is decisive in techn� does not lie at all in making and manipulating, nor in using of means, but rather in the aforementioned revealing"(Heidegger ,1977, p13).

  1. The Future of Television

    The Top subscriber will have access to �television on demand.� They could choose to watch the Soup Nazi episode of Seinfeld at 2 am as I mentioned earlier. Now �Package Deals� are a group of related television programs that fit in specific categories and sub categories.

  2. What did McLuhan mean when he said 'the medium is the message'? Is this ...

    Before this his theories were wild and seemed unreleastic. Another one of his ideas was hot and cool media, such as the radio being a hot medium and the telephone a cool medium. ?Hot? media, he says, are filled with data,? while ?cool? media are sparse in data, (Finkelstein, 1968, p82).

  1. Evaluting My Media Detox

    I keep on downloading more and more books because it is really simple and easy, but putting the effort to reading them is getting more and more difficult. One of the main reasons for this, is that there is so much media to consume, that I?m not sure what to read and what not to.

  2. What in your view, are the main problems involved in attempting to produce policies ...

    According to Braman (2009), ??access to information is considered a fundamental right for freedom of expression [?] it is impossible to take part in public discourse [?] without knowing what is going on.? (Braman, 2009, pg37). Before the new media, this concept largely referred to information about the government and

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work