• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How is vaccination portrayed in the media?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How is vaccination portrayed in the media? The portrayal of vaccination in the media has always been a controversial issue. When a new vaccination program makes the news the mainstream media often find themselves accused of ignoring the evidence in favour of scaremongering reports or the distortion of facts and yet the media commonly counter with the argument that they are acting on respectable evidence and valid scientific studies. The matter is yet to, and may never be resolved. Many people will always believe newspaper reports containing scientific reports whilst others will remain sceptical. Within the subject of vaccination in the media new reports consistently emerge, often with controversial consequences, although some become a lot larger than others. This is not to say that alternative coverage does not exist. Certainly there are many purportedly more 'respectable' publications that would claim to show unbiased coverage and factual or statistical evidence but these are often incompatible with the more popular reporting from mainstream news and the tabloid press. When presented with this ongoing, contradictory reportage it might be difficult for someone to make a considered opinion, particularly if they have no prior knowledge of the science of vaccination or little understanding of media machinations. Whilst the public dialogue continues between tabloid journalists, television news reporters, medical professionals, government speakers, armchair pundits and media commentators there are clearly much more important issues at stake. If the scientists and medical professionals (and the media who support them) are to be believed then the gains to be had from proper vaccination coverage (or 'herd immunity') ...read more.

Middle

Measles is a disease which thrives in dense populations and in circumstances where malnutrition is common, can achieve a fatality rate of 20%. Measles can also lead to severe complications in the host and can develop into measles encephalitis, which in turn can lead to brain damage. More commonly the host can experience convulsions and aural infections. Mumps was first effectively vaccinated against in 1967 and carries with it less potential for public health risk than measles or rubella. The disease (whilst very unpleasant) is rarely serious although it can lead to orchitis in males, which in turn can lead to sterility. Rubella (or German Measles) was first described in 1619 and although not as serious as measles is considered to be an important virus to be immunised against. Whilst rubella differs from other childhood diseases in that it rarely has any direct consequence on the health of the host it is considered a serious disease due to its effect on unborn children and can pose severe problems to the development of a foetus in utero. The ethical problem posed by this situation requires that boys be immunised as well as girls in order to ensure that 'herd immunity' is maintained, i.e. to decrease the chances of passing the disease to a female who has herself not been immunised (Senn, 2003). Studies into a combined MMR vaccine began in Finland in the 1970s after common epidemics of all three viruses, leading to many deaths, cases of sterility and congenital birth defects. ...read more.

Conclusion

To put it another way, if none of the children had received MMR this would (accepting the other weaknesses of this form of study) be an indication that MMR had a protective effect against autism. (Senn, 2003:221) After the actual evidence and methodology behind the trials had been forced into the public eye and was sufficiently scrutinised, along with reports that Wakefield himself had been struck off over malpractice over charges of bringing his profession into disrepute, along with claims that his studies had also been affected by a conflict of interests which involved a �55,000 grant, it became difficult for the media to continue their supportive campaign for his efforts. The Telegraph, who in 2002 had described Wakefield as a 'handsome, glossy-haired charismatic hero' (Picardie, 2002) now called for greater scrutiny of medical practitioners. The Sun ended its 'give us a choice' campaign (which had called for the right to opt for multiple vaccines over the triple jab) whilst the Daily Mail disregarded all evidence and continued to publish stories which linked the MMR vaccine to autism for many years after (O'Neil, 2006). Private Eye was one publication who had sided with Wakefield against what it purported to be a controlling and pernicious health authority which had something to hide, in its special supplement published with its regular issue. In response the British Medical Journal affirmed in a press release that: The Eye report is dangerous in that it is likely to be read by people who are concerned about the safety of the vaccine. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Paper-based media studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Paper-based media studies essays

  1. Representation of Black Women in Vogue UK: Is Fashion Racist?

    The NEXT advert is featured in the December 2009 issue of British Vogue, along with the UNI QLO and the Adler adverts. Looking at the UNI QLO (Fig 8) advert, under the slogan 'The Heat Generation', it seems to have it all.

  2. Assess whether the Northcliffe Revolution is a useful way of understanding developments in the ...

    This practice had developed from the early 1800's, but during the 'Northcliffe Revolution' it was conceivable to believe that he 'blurred the division between the editorial and business aspects of the industry'. During this period, none more so telling than in Lord Northcliffe's case, came the domineering influence of the

  1. "UK national newspapers have adopted a racist attitude in their coverage of recent international ...

    When we compare both reports we find that the original OFSTED report draws attention in a passive manner to the fact that there are many factors which cause pupils to be rude and uncooperative at schools and it has been observed that this is the case in schools with high levels of children from parents who are asylum-seekers.

  2. According to research, women journalists battle both for jobs and to be taken seriously. ...

    For instance, if we were to take Afghanistan as an example: during the Taliban's regime, it was mandatory than Afghan women stayed at home and were not seen in public. After the United States led military intervention however, thousands of these girls and women took up jobs in the world of journalism.

  1. My essay will analyse the heroes in the following four texts, The Epic of ...

    This heavily influenced the writing style of my critical response. Although an analytical and interpretive essay, I have excluded a sizeable amount of external quotations and theories originally used to increase my personal engagement in my work. This adopted writing style, similar to that of Hourihan, enabled me to voice

  2. New media culture/ Cyberculture

    Increasingly, these new media cultures are integrated and absorbed in our lives as an indispensable part, thus yield lots of positive social/communication consequences. Thanks to advanced communication devices, doctor and nurses can collaborate more efficiently, especially in emergency situation. Also, the application of new media technologies introduced in educational sector clearly outshines the outdated teaching-mode.

  1. What are the strengths and weaknesses of the five main advertising media? Explain why ...

    Compare with print, another advantage of TV is it has sounds effect and also the moving images that can gather more audiences' attentions. Moreover, compare with words and images, sound, sight and motion can make the TV advertisements have higher prestige. However, compare with print, TV advertising also some disadvantages.

  2. This paper examines the influence that media has on adolescent females feelings towards their ...

    Adolescent females are particularly vulnerable to the thin-promoting messages of the media because they are at a time in their lives when they are seeking outside information to form their self-identity (Botta, 1999). The conflict between their changing body and the media?s message of acceptable body image can result in a lowering of self worth and acceptability.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work