Illustration of Muted Group Theory in Maria Full of Grace

Authors Avatar

Illustration of Muted Group Theory in Maria Full of Grace

        Muted group theory illustrates how a group can acquire power and use it to it to dominate culture. It specifically refers to the gender roles created by society and can also be used to examine cross-cultural case studies. Its name describes how a group in power can manipulate language and communication practices specific to its culture in order to silence the members not included in the dominant group. Maria Full of Grace is an exposé of the complexities surrounding women’s involvement in drug trafficking and becoming a woman in a male dominated society. In the movie there are many examples of communication that are impeded because of women’s current role in society.

        The movie opens with its title character, Maria Alvarez , a 17-year-old Colombian, making out her boyfriend, Juan. Juan is completely involved in the moment and hinting that he wants to further accelerate the situation, and he even doesn’t notice her indifference to his affection. He attempts to get her to agree to let them go back to her house, but she wants to climb on top of the roof. She “emasculates” Juan by teasing him and  he gets irritated and walks away. Instead of complying with Juan’s wish to go back to her house, Maria responded by taking control of the situation (especially notable because of its sexual nature) and said, “See how you treat me? You’re a drag.” Because she attempts to step outside of the expectation that she will fulfill the needs of her lover, she is “punished” by him walking off and leaving her on the roof by herself.

Join now!

In the next scene, Maria is being mistreated by her male supervisor. He refuses to let her go to the restroom even though she feels nauseated, and then proceeds to demand she clean the mess off  the roses after she vomits on them. It is implied Maria takes this kind of abuse on a regular basis. When she next sees her mother and sister, at the local pharmacy, she informs them she quit her job at the factory. They are alarmed and ask when and why this happened. This is sparked by argument over money. It is cultural practice for ...

This is a preview of the whole essay