• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is journalism a profession? What arguments and evidence would you put forth to support or deny any claim that journalism has to being a profession?

Extracts from this document...


MA in Mass Communications Option 1 Is journalism a profession? What arguments and evidence would you put forth to support or deny any claim that journalism has to being a profession? Journalists play an intrinsic part of the media landscape, which in turn reflects and influences society. However, as a profession it is different to comparable occupations. Accountants, lawyers, teachers and doctors are expected to undergo unique, specific and vigorous training processes. The very nature of their occupations requires high levels of knowledge and skills, which their respective professional bodies ensure through high standards of entry qualifications and rigorous training and examinations attainments. Professional codes of practice regulate behaviour and determine continued membership, which has maintained high standards of professional integrity and historically given these groups a privileged position in the hierarchy of professions. Journalism has traditionally been viewed as a more vocational career. As such, until recently, there have been fewer opportunities to study it as a formal subject. Related associations are few and regulation is arguably more relaxed that in other professions. But do these fundamental differences make journalism any less a profession? Are indeed journalists themselves any less professional in their work? I would argue that whilst journalism isn't a profession in the most traditional sense, it does in fact qualify on most levels. In the last decade, in particular, the level of conventional 'professionalism' in the UK has increased, with the introduction of a more established and recognised association and professional qualification. In order to begin addressing some of these issues, it is important to investigate the internal mechanisms and structures of media organisations and the external forces that impact upon them. It is also relevant to consider different approaches to what we understand as an occupation. So what actually constitutes a profession? In a very simplified form, it refers to status and expertise. Being a professional in a particular field involves having a certain level of accomplishment, as opposed to amateurism. ...read more.


Whilst deemed by some as unethical, many employers view this as the cheapest means of filling vacancies that are already over subscribed. It also avoids the recruitment costs. Recruitment of journalists is very much subject to the particular and possibly idiosyncratic needs and practices of individual employers. These conditions mean that entry into journalism is haphazard and usually more difficult for ethnic groups. This is an issue the industry has addressed to some extent. The NUJ black group and the Commission for Racial Equality (CRE) began looking at the issue of black under-representation in white media in the early eighties. The study found that black and Asian people, whether they had recognised journalism training or not, experienced for prejudice when they tried to get jobs than when they tried getting training. The majority of respondents to the study wanted to see the implementation of equal opportunities policies backed by law. This remains an on-going problem for the industry and something that needs to be more rigorously monitored and addressed. A key pre-requisite of an established profession is a code of conduct. In the broadest sense, this should set lay out key rights and wrongs. Lawyers, doctors and teachers, all follow a set of ethics - moral principles or codes. In journalistic terms, this is sometimes seen as a contradiction in terms. Journalists are very often accused of being totally unethical and many accept the term 'never believe what you read in the paper'. Good journalism in essence should arguably be described as 'news that has been gathered in a morally justifiably manner, topical, truthful, factually based information which is of interest to the reader/viewer and that is published in a timely and accurate way to a mass audience'. However, in an ever-increasing capitalist media industry, this type of journalism could be argued to be in decline. There is a tension between ethics and market forces. ...read more.


Despite conforming to these principles in some way or other, journalism still remains quite different to more conventional professions such as law, medicine and education. It is still possible to become a journalist with very basic qualifications and simply learn when doing the job. Whilst journalism is an important, impactful and potentially powerful career, perhaps one of the key defining factors is accreditation. In the legal, medical and teaching professions, professional accreditation is necessary before you are able to practice within the specific sphere. Journalism remains an anomaly at this level. Despite being encouraged to gain professional accreditation, it is not obligatory. Bodies such as the Chartered Institute of Chartered Accountants in contrast ensure that individual members enjoy 'chartered' status. Never the less, I would still argue that journalism is a profession. Journalists are considered relative experts - with a certain level of written skill and accomplishment. The majority of journalists act in a professional manner, demonstrating ethical and moral commitment. This is an area where journalism often suffers, with many assuming all journalists follow the tabloid mould, scandalous, morally reprehensible and unethical. However, this type of journalist and indeed journalism is in the minority. If we consider power as an occupational differentiator, journalists exercise significant control over their own activities. Subjects maybe commissioned, but journalists are often given free reign on what they write on a certain subject (subject to editing). Such freedom isn't enjoyed within many other professions. Finally, it is important to point out, that journalism as an industry in the UK has changed significantly and will continue to do so. If we look to the USA, journalism is highly regarded as a profession and as such there are a huge selection of well-respected degree-level courses on offer. Perhaps public perception of journalism needs to change before it can become a more widely acknowledged and 'understood' profession. On an academic level, there remains friction between traditional journalists and respected academics, resulting in limited cohesion between the two. On a public level, journalists are often viewed negatively as a result of bad journalism and journalistic practices. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Paper-based media studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Paper-based media studies essays

  1. Can journalism be objective?

    In the 1990s, a number of foreign journalists reject the idea of objectivity. The BBC's Martin Bell rejected the dispassionate practices of the past and maintained that he was 'no longer sure what "objective" means. Objectivity meant having to stand neutrally between good and evil, right and wrong, the victim and the oppressor (Bell, 1998).

  2. My essay will analyse the heroes in the following four texts, The Epic of ...

    This is a different homecoming to that of Mulan. The concept of sacrifice is reflected on an even weakened form in Mulan. Her loyalty to her family and to China sparked her decision to replace her father in the army.

  1. In this critical analysis I aim to identify and examine how the Benetton Group ...

    The use of tall, thin, blemish free models appearing in media texts for example is not an accurate representation and provides a distorted image of society so by including flawed and diverse people within their campaigns as well as including social and political themes which are relevant and current, they

  2. The purpose of this paper is to illustrate that Chomskys claim that the mass-media ...

    By obtaining news using this method the costs in obtaining news is reduced as official sources are generally assumed to be credible and objective (p. 19), requiring minimal to no extra research. The official sources cater greatly to the mass-media through cost-reducing tactics including: providing facilities for media to gather

  1. According to research, women journalists battle both for jobs and to be taken seriously. ...

    It is a rare occasion that we see women telling us about the financial recession, or the war on terror, however, increasingly women have been making their way into these areas. Kate Adie is one female journalist who has certainly turned heads by 'doing the man's job'.

  2. Building Brands without Mass Media

    Germany's highest court eventually ruled against the controversial ads. Involve the Customer in Brand-Building Experiences Providing extensive information, especially using media advertising, cannot duplicate the impact of customers' personal experience with a brand. Consider the sampling program of Haagen-Dazs, the participation at Swatch events, the vicarious participation at Hugo Boss events, and the involvement of the Body Shop's customers in social activism.

  1. This paper examines the influence that media has on adolescent females feelings towards their ...

    And women were 40 times more likely than males to be shown as passive, dependant, and emotional. Seidemen also compared these results with United States Census data to find that: The workplace shown on MTV was still more gender stereotyped than really existed in some respects: For example, 28% of

  2. "Dreamland Japan" - The Manga and Anime Market - Book Review

    Likewise, Schodt gives an interesting account of how the Japanese society is resolving the problem of manga's pornographic and violent scenes, which have incrementally become a social problem in Japan. In ?Silent Services? and ?The Way of Manga?, the author talks about the quite well-known Kaiji Kawaguchi, including Fujiko F.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work