• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Only a critical political economy approach can adequately explain how the media work today.

Extracts from this document...


Only a critical political economy approach can adequately explain how the media work today. Discuss this statement with reference to two of the following: advertising; news and current affairs; television; radio; newspapers; or magazines. To accept such a statement requires an absolute disregard for all other media studies theories and models. The word 'only' in the statement will play an essential part in the overall discussion of the statement, as it is the inclusion of this word which turns the question from objective to subjective. Without the 'only', the statement would seem quite feasible and approachable, but with it, seems unreasonable and quite unfair. While a critical political economy takes a comprehensive approach to understanding the media by linking various institutional aspects, it cannot account for our understanding of the entire media institution. This is where other approaches to understanding the media, such as textual analysis and content analysis help answer the questions that a critical political economy approach to media cannot. To effectively demonstrate this point, two popular media sources, news and current affairs along with newspapers will be referenced in this paper to show how wider structures influence society's choices and decisions as an audience, as customers and as citizens. ...read more.


To provide an example of the critical political economy approach in relation to news and current affairs and newspapers, the issue of centralisation of media ownership is a growing concern throughout our society, with "fewer and fewer corporations controlling more and more of our media" (Schudson, 2002: p.252). Kerry Packer's interest in Australian media is a major concern for those mainstream political economists who see the 'economy' as separate from other specialised domains, while from a critical political perspective, Packer's interest is seen as going beyond only a source of economic issues, and instead focuses on the interrelation between the economic, social and cultural issues surrounding a centralisation of ownership. "What marks critical political economy is that it always goes beyond situated action to show how particular micro contexts are shaped by general economic dynamics and the wider structures they sustain" (Golding and Murdock, 1991: p.18). When applying this to news and current affairs, in September last year, government funded broadcaster the ABC aired a story regarding Kerry Packer's Crown Casino, and the scrutiny surrounding the Casino's disregard for government gaming policy, after the Casino had been found to be "breaching numerous aspects" (ABC Stateline, 2003) of the Casino and Gaming Authority laws. ...read more.


Critical political economy helps to understand the implications of the media in a fuller sense and in doing so provides an approach to media that is holistic and encompassing. This paper compared the effectiveness of critical political economy compared to textual analysis and content analysis, and while the two alternatives were not critically evaluated, it is clear that they can be useful in providing answers where a critical political economy approach to media studies cannot. Critical political economy is not the 'only' adequate way of making sense of the media today, but essentially provides more answers than questions and serves as a basis for all other approaches. Reference List: ABC Stateline Victoria, (2003), ABC broadcast 5th September 2003. Cunningham, S and Turner, G. (2002), The Media and Communications in Australia, Allen & Unwin, Crows Nest, New South Wales. Golding, P and Murdock, G. (1991), "Culture, Communications, and Political Economy", Mass Media and Society, pp.15-32. Herald Sun Article, "Olympians to defy Athens bombers", 6th May 2004. McKee, A. (2001), "A Beginner's Guide to Textual Analysis", Metro Magazine, No.127/128, pp.138-149. Metamucil Advertisement (2002), Channel 10, 24th April. Schudson, M. (2002), "The News Media as Political Institutions", Annual Review of Political Science, No.5, pp.249-269. Turner, G. (1997), "Media Analysis: Competing Tradition", (in) The Media in Australia: Industries, Texts, Audiences, pp.297-314. - 1 - ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Paper-based media studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Paper-based media studies essays

  1. How Does the Media Source News and How is it Selected? To What Extent ...

    words and a picture where such person is in good mood or state, whereas if the image of a negative person wants to be created, disapproval statements and criticising words will be employed, along with an off putting picture of the person.

  2. Semiotic Analysis of Advertisements

    Following that Bignell states "while the cover image is for a woman to look at, it is constructed with reference to a wider social code in which feminine means 'taking pleasure in looking at oneself', and taking pleasure in being looked at by men."

  1. Textual analysis and Critical Political Economy

    However textual analysis helps analyze the text in relation to the text as a whole. This basically means getting the overall message in the text. In the CNN news article, the components of speech on Independence Day and addressing by the president, as well as the less information provided about

  2. To what extent does the print-media influence young people into smoking, in relation to ...

    Other forms of advertising and promotion were previously restricted by two voluntary agreements that were negotiated, periodically, between the Government and the tobacco industry. Advertising was covered by one agreement and the other governed tobacco sponsorship of sport. Unfortunately, the agreements were unsuccessful in reducing advertising and their negotiations had little impact.

  1. My essay will analyse the heroes in the following four texts, The Epic of ...

    Heaven21 and Humbaba22, rivals, gods and even from within, is testament to his mythic status. He finally arrives at Utnapishtim23, "the epitome of both life everlasting and death that is eternal"24. Gilgamesh is ordered to "stay up with the stars for seven long and sleepless nights"25 and he will be rewarded with the intangible elixir of immortality.

  2. New media culture/ Cyberculture

    Solely basing on the avatar, profile picture, people can't know for sure if it is the owner's or someone else's. Psychologically, people tend to pay more attention to someone who is good looking, thus an average, attention-seeking teenage girl would be more likely to trick the public into seeing another better, much attracting version, whether it's hers or not.

  1. "Dreamland Japan" - The Manga and Anime Market - Book Review

    However, sacrificing some quality make manga much more superior to American or European comics concerning story structure and character composition. Japanese manga artists develop ordinary stories further by including cinematic styles and making the character's mentality more complex. Referring to this, Schodt quotes the American comic artist Brian Stelfreeze.

  2. This paper examines the influence that media has on adolescent females feelings towards their ...

    Fashion and beauty articles also focused on pleasing males, and then ways of using that approval to their advantage. Images of females in teen magazines portray girls as sexy, yet reserved; passionately desirous, yet coy. The sexual images presented to adolescent females in teen magazines were acute, while at the same time mixed and conflicting.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work