• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why Does the Issue of Privacy and the Media Continue to be a Controversial One?

Extracts from this document...


Why Does the Issue of Privacy and the Media Continue to be a Controversial One? There are two sides to the debate which are based on two human rights, Article 8-the right to privacy and Article 10-the right to free speech. It's complicated as the two rights oppose each other with important conflicting issues on both sides. For each argument for there is one just as good against which is why it has lasted so long. Controversy, when something stimulates a prolonged debate is generally complex, hotly debated and has two strong sides, as there are so many different issues. At least three different bodies have been involved in putting together different versions of the Code of Conduct. The controversy doesn't just remain in Britain, though, in the USA an anti-abortion website was closed down as it printed the names and addresses of some doctors who were willing to perform the procedure. Three of the doctors were killed. When the court closed the website it overruled the First Amendment of the Constitution-the right to free speech. It was very controversial and caused a big stir in the US. It is not a new issue. ...read more.


Following Calcutt's first report in 1990 the newspaper industry published a Code of Conduct and replaced the Press Council with the Press Complaints Commission (PCC) which would investigate any complaints made. Criticisms were made that there were too many newspaper employees on the Commission. They also didn't stick to the Code of Conduct. Clause seven stated that no unconsented photographs may be taken on private property unless in the public interest but this was broken almost immediately. They could also claim that just about anything was in the public interest. The Daily Mirror published photographs of Princess Diana in the gym. An invasion of privacy that is not in the public interest? Apparently not. The photos were printed to show how easy it was to endanger the Princess and the public have a right to know if their Princess is at risk, claimed the Mirror. After the death of Diana the Code of Conduct was revised and although the Princes William and Harry were left pretty much alone, other celebrities were not so lucky. In February 1998 Nicole Kidman was photographed leaving hospital after an operation even though a hospital is a supposed "private place". ...read more.


Even though editors insist that they are only thinking about the public all they really care about is sales and they will do anything to get them. If the opportunity to boost sales, in the form of an intrusive but juicy story, is available then the possibility of a complaint to the PCC isn't going to make much difference. The newspapers have unstable sales figures, which along with the price war means that editors really have to try to keep the circulation up. The newspapers are also a very powerful medium and can make or break a person's career especially if they have a dodgy past like John Profumo, who was exposed by a newspaper and never worked in politics again. Because of this politicians are reluctant to speak up, as they don't want to risk making enemies. We are now left waiting to see what effects the Human Rights Act will have and if this problem can ever be solved. But if the public continue to buy newspapers with these intrusive stories in them then they will keep being printed. If something is in demand someone will always be there to provide no matter what it is. One thing is for sure, that it will never become any less controversial because whenever one side comes up with a new argument the other has an equally good defending one. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Paper-based media studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Paper-based media studies essays

  1. The media in Japan is controlled by big business and politicians - discuss

    They negotiated exclusive agreements to prevent journalists from smaller newspapers from joining the clubs - a practice that would become commonplace in Japan. The clubs survived reform attempts by SCAP (Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers) after the Pacific War and exist today in similar form to when they were first established.

  2. Press freedom gives journalists the right to present stories to the public that are ...

    the Press Complaints Commission will require a full explanation by the editor demonstrating how the public interest was served." Despite the differing definitions of the public interest, the term does encapsulate the cultivation of editorial standards - that somebody can exercise free speech, but that they should talk about what they think is in the public interest.

  1. What role do the media play in creating moral panic on the issue of ...

    Channel 4 has not made clear in their programme, or any subsequent statements, that not all the ten people facing charges are Asian. Police have confirmed that they are not all Asian, but those who have watched a preview tape believe that Channel 4 have created the impression that they all are.

  2. Racism In the Media.

    The truth is that Blacks make up 29% of Americas poor. Pictures of poor African Americans appeal to editors as 'a readily recognisable form of poverty'. Gilens says that if an editor wants a picture that is easily identified as poor, and believes that readers strongly associate poverty with black people, then he/she will use it.

  1. What caused the British media to become more independent of governement?

    In 1695, the 1662 Licensing of the Press Act expired and it was decided by Parliament not to renew it (The British Library, 2010), allowing for a press that is freer from censorship and is capable of having a much larger circulation, in turn creating mass audiences.

  2. Issues Risk and Crisis Communication Critique and Case Study

    The warning signs at this point were obviously when the commission impended the discovery of the shortfall of funds, David Jackson lead an inquiry examining the actions of the company in the funding to the compensation fund and the communication strategy devised to support the separation of the liabilities.

  1. Report of media coverage of Pan pharmaceuticals recall and its implications for ACCM

    Current Situation 20 5. Recommendations 21 List of References 25 Appendix A -3- Issue Brief: Preamble: The Australian Council of Complementary Medicines (ACCM) has been impacted negatively as a result of the Pan pharmaceuticals/Therapeutic Goods Administration recall. This called into question the safety and effectiveness of complementary medicines.

  2. In the light of a number of recent high profile complaints about invasion of ...

    In his report the Chairman of the PCC, Lord Wakeham states that "huge advances" have been made on the central issue of privacy. He "is certain that the first question any editor asks him or herself is "can I justify this if challenged?"

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work