• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Alliance Formation and the Balance of World Power.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The University of Sydney Government and International Relations International Security in the 21st Century Reading Review: Alliance Formation and the Balance of World Power Stephen M. Walt Anthony Zafirakos SID: 0305028 In his article, Alliance Formation and the Balance of World Power, Stephen M. Walt explores the causes of alignment. To gain an understanding of how states select their alliances, Walt defines three key areas - alliances as a response to threat, alignment between consistent ideologies and the tools of bribery and penetration - in the bipolar political world of 1985, influenced by the power of the Cold War's main actors, the USA and USSR. One of the main assumptions of this period is that most states were affiliated with or relied upon one of the two super powers for political, economic and military support, thus making alliances and their formation a central issue in Cold War politics. Causes of Alignment - What are they? Walt identifies the formation of alliances as a response to threat as the most significant factor of the three. ...read more.

Middle

The democratic peace theory states that war is unlikely between democratic nations, which supports Walt's original argument. The subconscious belief of the inferiority of communism and other non-Western cultures such as the Middle East is a flaw in Walt's argument and leads to his claims that under communism, factions conflict, and that any success achieved under such regimes is by chance and unique. Walt describes bribery and penetration as tools used by states in seeking out allies. The notion of bribery implies the provision of assistance from one state to another. The assumption that all states, as a rule, will respond to such tributes and that only their continuation will maintain an alliance is one typical of realism. The very idea of acquiring allies suggests self-interest. Walt states that these "policy instruments" (p 27) facilitate alliance formation rather than create them, and are rather limited in their effect. Marginal Arguments Walt uses the examination of the different factors of alliance formation to put forth a commentary on the actions of the US, both past and future. ...read more.

Conclusion

Although he justifies many of his points with empirical evidence, Walt retains a dismissive disposition in relation to Communism's stability and aggregate power, by making seemingly biased, self-contradictory and unclear claims. Empirical Content - How evidence is used Walt supports each statement he makes with empirical evidence. Furthermore, the evidence he uses is generally taken from 20th century politics and political theory, which supports the relevance in its use, and improves its significance. These examples are clear and concise. On proximate power: "if the British press pay more attention to the increase of Germany's naval power than to a similar movement in Brazil, this is no doubt due to the proximity of the German coasts and the remoteness of Brazil." (p 10) Conclusion Stephen Walt provides a clear understanding of how alliances were formed during the Cold War, and identifies some key features such as balancing and bandwagoning. Although his methodology and logic are clear and simple, he does fall victim to ungrounded arguments at times, when his use of evidence fails to support them. He uses his analysis to compose an effective commentary at the conclusion of the article, on how the US should approach the future. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree International Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree International Politics essays

  1. The game of Risk can be used as tool to understand the international system. ...

    The conflict researcher does not accept that the cause of conflict is an instinct in man - a drive to dominate.27 Rather, conflictual behavior is a response to an actor's perceptions of the environment. Thus threats are not the only form of social interaction, for, just as the environment can

  2. Nato's Istanbul Cooperation Initiative. NATOs Istanbul Initiative inscribes itself in the ...

    terrorism which took a hallucinating nature with the September 11 attack on America's military, financial and economic symbols. The third and last reason to continue the alliance is the one most people still want to push under the rug. This is the matter of Germany.

  1. Several times in the 2nd half of the century, the military has ousted the ...

    it seems that the guardian coup best encompasses the Turkish case for several reasons (Hale, 1993:307). It generally occurs in states in which the new urban middle class already enjoys unchallenged control: the RPP in a Turkey is a particular example because the first coup in 1960, for example, took

  2. Does Liberalism best explain contemporary world politics?

    So if one country makes a gain of one unit but another makes a gain of two units then the country has not made a relative gain but a relative loss. If the same situation (where 1 unit is gained by country X and 2 by country Y)

  1. Critically evaluate post-war realist explanations of international politics with particular reference to power

    For instance, realpolitik dictated that Turkey should have supported the recent war against Iraq to obtain economic and military assistance from America. The state of Turkey opposed the war, perhaps because of fears of domestic unrest or because of pan-Islamic sentiments of solidarity.

  2. The power of citizenship is probably best known by those who are denied it. ...

    If the Lebanese people realise that the people who have lived with them for the past 60 years share parallels, whilst removing their threat of political dissent then they could be more open to the improvement of their position. The status quo is a grim one.

  1. To what degree does the level of industrialisation experienced by individual countries influence the ...

    The most prominent nation that proficiently epitomizes the paradigm of industrialization and the interrelated relationship with global power is the Kingdom of Great Britain. Instigated in 1750, the Industrial Revolution transpired within Great Britain offering innumerable advantages to the empire and bolstering its political and economic influence.

  2. How Realistic is the Rational Approach to Real World Policy Making? Discuss Using Relevant ...

    Along with the assumptions stated in the previous argument, the assumption of rationality and knowledge required to detail and assess all options to formulate the best policy can cause drastic issues. Firstly, the approach assumes that using the required research and consideration with the application of rationality, all options will be available and the consequences already defined.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work