• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the extent to which debates about 'culture' are actually debates about power.

Extracts from this document...


1215467 76A4 Society, Media and Culture Assignment: Monday 21st March, 2005 Tutor: Pedro Nunes (Monday 12pm Seminar) Word Count: 1656 Question 3: Assess the extent to which debates about 'culture' are actually debates about power. The Collins English Dictionary defines culture as: 'The total of the inherited ideas, beliefs, values and knowledge which constitute the shared bases of social action; the total range of activities and ideas of a group of people with shared traditions which are transmitted and reinforced by members of the group; the artistic and social pursuits, expression and tastes valued by a society or class; the enlightenment or refinement resulting from these pursuits. One example of a culture within our world today is Popular Culture, which is generally associated with the entertainment of the lower classes, carrying some negative connotations. Popular Culture consists of, amongst other elements, soap opera, sport, popular television and music, and in more recent years can also be thought of to incorporate the sub-culture of celebrity. Another example from the opposite end of the scale is High Culture. This is seen to be produced for, and aimed exclusively at, the upper class sector of society. ...read more.


Hence 'the people' control and regulate their own government. Unfortunately the same cannot be said for the media. The public do not 'own' the media, nor do they have the ability to control it. This task is left solely to a small fraction of the population, who have gained control, more often than not, by means of wealth and situation. It is these people who decide the information that the public are 'allowed' to gain access to, which incidents are worthy of reporting to them and which viewpoints they are subjected to. This small group of media leaders therefore has the ability to set the public agenda on an endless number of issues. One example that can be used to illustrate the power that the media hold over the shaping of various cultures is the televising of sporting events, particularly the showing of football matches. In recent years all forms of the media have concentrated a large portion of their coverage on sport and in particular, football. The experience of viewing a match has become so highly interactive by means of the internet and digital television that fans now have a choice of camera angle, which players they wish to focus on and instant replays of live television, all at the touch of a button. ...read more.


I feel that we should not be told what we should and should not believe, or even be influenced on such matters by such a subjective organisation. Audiences should be given the right to an input on what they are consuming, what issues carry the most weight and therefore should be reported on, and what they wish to be exposed to. Traditional values of spirituality have been replaced by the media, and as a result they can now claim to have a large degree of control over the population with regards to what is perceived as 'the norm'. It may not be possible to consider such a drastic change as a media based more on a democratic structure of elected leaders than the current autocratic design that we possess today as being a realistic prospect in the foreseeable future. However, through continued coverage and debate concerning the issues raised I believe that what is a possibility is a mediated culture that concentrates on the important events that are occurring around the globe, presented in an objective manner without hidden agenda; one which does not try to alter our cultural beliefs but on the contrary, one which celebrates and respects the vast number of differences that distinguish diverse cultures. An ideologically honest media. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Anthropology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Anthropology essays

  1. Frankfurt School on Popular Culture

    They maintain that the revolutionary time that Marx so long hoped for has passed and that the only hope the lower classes have is to better themselves by tapping into the products and ideologies of their oppressors. Something that even Marx himself would have trouble digesting.

  2. Tutorial Assignment - Organizational Culture

    Philosophy - There are policies that set forth the organisation's beliefs about how employees and customers should be treated. At Hewlett-Packard employees show a common concern for product innovativeness and responsiveness to customer needs. All employees in a financial research company such as AMBA Research would pay attention to detail.

  1. The media is a very powerful force.

    Herman and Tiffen's arguments can be applied to women's magazines, such that the ultimate power of content does lie in the proprietor' hands and very large corporations do own most of the women's magazines in Australia. Nevertheless, both Herman and Tiffen recognise that there are limits to this argument as there are "routines, constraints, incentives and traditions" (2002: p36)

  2. Management styles: Democratic, Consultative & Autocratic

    made instantly as only one person has the power to make decisions. There is only one way communications however there will be a autocratic management style. Role Culture: In a role culture there will be a very hierarchical business structure and the power is derived from the employees.

  1. Assess the evidence for and against the 'media imperialism theory'

    When one goes nation by nation, even a "cultural nationalist" country like France had nine of its top ten grossing films in 1999 produced by the Hollywood giants. "Many leftist intellectuals in Paris are decrying American films, but the French people are eating them up," a Hollywood producer noted.

  2. Is Popular Culture an Influence on Violent Behaviour?

    The child was subsequently placed in a playroom setting and the incidence of aggressive behaviour was recorded. The result was that children shown the violent images were more aggressive in the playroom than those children who were not. Bandura's findings highlight a definite link between popular culture, in the form

  1. Mass media audiences are hapless dupes of the culture industry - discuss.

    Paine was correct in his predictions, as literacy rose quickly in the developed world, and class distinctions did begin to fade. Yet as the power and ease with which to communicate with the growing masses began to be realised, a new division arose, between those in control of this new media, and the audience to which it preached.

  2. Primary research report on an aspect of group identity in football fans.

    As said in a previous paragraph this can be due group competing for status. Football teams have certain uniforms (kits) that they have to wear on the pitch the most famous on this is the football shirt. Fans are encouraged to purchase replicas of these t shirts and the majority of them wear them when at the stadium.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work