• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast rational and incremental models of policy making.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Making Public Policy Assignment Compare and contrast rational and incremental models of policy making. Decision making is recognised as a fundamental activity of public administration. The debate of rational versus incremental models of policy making is could be viewed as a debate over alternative political systems and values. Rational decision making has a centralising bias, while incrementalism tends to favour representative and pluralist decision making. Additionally, the rational model tends not to favour any community contribution while incrementalism leans towards widespread popular participation in decision making. Despite their numerous differences, both techniques can work well or even fail, depending on the situation in which they are used. The rational model is aimed at maximising efficiency and 'net value achievement'. This means that all of the values of society are known and that any sacrifice in one or more values required by a policy is compensated for by attainment of other values. This definition could be viewed as interchangeable with the concept of efficiency - it comes down to more than money - all social, political and economic values have to be considered. Many techniques are employed to limit alternatives and to promote effective decision making; these include hierarchy, specialisation, premise controls and 'grid regulation'. ...read more.

Middle

Here stages of the policy process follow on from one another but the policy process does not terminate. Solutions define the context for the next problem; hence, the stages of policy process can be seen as a cycle.6 The incremental approach was originally proposed by the economist Lindloom and attempts to correct the imperfections of the rational model and to illustrate how policy decision-makers actually behave. He touts the advantages of a 'successive limited comparison mode over "the rational comprehensive method"'7. This perspective accepts that political objectives may be purposely kept unclear with the intention of building political consensus and support. He argued that decision makers do not annually review all existing and proposed policies, highlight societal goals and research costs, as suggested by the rational model as impractical. Instead they take an incremental approach in which there is slow evolution of policies by cautious incremental changes. The incremental approach is conservative in that existing policies, programs and expenditure are considered and attention is concentrated on new policies and on increases, decreases or modifications of established programs. Perhaps this suggests that they do not totally remake policy every time they make a 'policy-decision', but in its place modernise existing policy. ...read more.

Conclusion

or constituency; avoiding overly rigid adherence to rules; the oversimplification of reality; the over-quantification at the expense of qualitative factors; and, the reluctance to engage in policy and program evaluation and feedback. This policy model is effective where as the incremental option may not be as in the case of the Falklands. This method of policy making was and is still being used with the Europe issue - the stance being 'wait and see'. Incrementalism is a continuous, exploratory process and the policy makers tend to operate within an existing framework and adjust their position in light of any feedback. The whole issue of the Falklands illustrates the inability of Whitehall to plan any long term policy and make decisions. 1 Financial Times - 7th March 2001 2 Herbert Simon 1982, Page 66 3 Simon 1983 4 Psychology Review 63 - Rational choice and the structure of the environment 5 Making Public Policy - Lecture 7 - taken from Baybrooke and Lindboom (1963) 6 Making Public Policy - Lecture 6 - Rational Models of Policy Making 7 Public Administration Review - 'The Science of Muddling Through' by Charles Lindloom 8 Lindloom 1959 - Page 266 9 Lindloom 1959 - Page 226 10 Landing On Your Feet: How To Control Policy Problems - Chapter 8 11 http://www.uh.edu/~lnielsen/pdf_files/ps6314e1.PDF 12http://www4.gvsu.edu/josephe/gpy309/chapter1/The%2520Science%2520of%2520Muddling%2520Through.pdf Page 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Social Work section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

This essay demonstrates a basic understanding of rational and incremental models of policy making. Some good points are made with regards to advantages and disadvantages but many of the points would be improved by using examples

Marked by teacher Diane Apeah-Kubi 25/03/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Social Work essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Social Work Values. Values and ethics have been of fundamental importance throughout the ...

    4 star(s)

    for which they work and it is the job of the social worker to challenge these values; after all, values can only evolve when challenged in this way. Social workers are required to consider values and ethics in every aspect of their conduct, not just in relation to contact with service users.

  2. Counselling in a diverse society - stereotyping, language issues, different belief systems, ...

    The role differences between counsellor and client. The client and the counsellor are two halves of a therapeutic relationship. The client comes to a counsellor, in general when he/she is dissatisfied with their present situation i.e. when he/she acknowledges dissatisfaction and wants to look at a problem; this is at stage 3 of Roger's 7 stage process.

  1. Nepotism - research project

    It must be noted that a variety of social aggregates in Buffalo City, e.g., politicians; civil society; including Bisho civil servants themselves have voiced their concerns in this regard. On January 7, 2002, the Daily Dispatch published an article in which the Commissioner of Tamara police station, Captain Siphiwo Hewana

  2. Reflective practice as a Social Worker

    I found the Cognitive Behavioural approach instrumental in helping me to help the young people build on what they already knew, examine their behaviour and develop their own strategies for coping. By leaving the power with the service user and allowing for their self-determination, this enabled me to re-enforce with

  1. Compare the Social Democratic and New Right Approaches to theWelfare State and the Social ...

    the prevention, diagnosis and treatment of illness...the services so provided shall be free of charge, except where any provision of this Act expressly provides for the making and recovery of charges (section one)." (Jones, K.1991: 140). * The Education Act, 1944.

  2. The advantages and disadvantages of Ethnographic methods.

    Several methods of data collection tend to be used in ethnography, such as in-depth interviewing, participant observation, personal documents and discourse analysis of natural language. As such, ethnography has a distinguished career in the social sciences. There have been 'travellers tales' for centuries, which count 'as a form of ethnographic

  1. Unit K/601/7629 Professional Organisational Issues In counselling assignment

    Rogers stated that 'Individuals have within themselves vast resources for self-understanding and for altering their self-concepts, basic attitudes, and self-directed behaviour; these resources can be tapped if a definable climate of facilitative psychological attitudes can be provided.' (Carl R. Rogers.

  2. TASK-CENTERED APPROACH. This essay takes a social work case study as the basis for ...

    preferred to ?keep myself to myself?, and he also apologized for being rude. Obviously it?s unlikely that this simple explanation covers the entirety of the emotions that he was feeling at that time; nevertheless, his attempt to articulate his problems fits in, broadly, with Thompson?s suggestion that it is best

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work