• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluate the extent to which the United Kingdom Parliament is sovereign

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Evaluate the extent to which the United Kingdom Parliament is sovereign. Consider both legal and political factors. Before exploring the extent to which our Parliament is sovereign, one must first understand what Parliamentary sovereignty means. When describing Parliament as sovereign, it means it holds the supreme power - the ultimate source of political authority and the authority to impose and amend laws. In other words our Parliament is sovereign, and it owes obedience to no other. However, there are some limitations on this power that need to be discussed. How far can the United Kingdom Parliament be sovereign, if certain, more specific areas of law or other jurisdictions can overrule it? In this essay I will explore how far Parliament is sovereign, and if there are limitations, what they are and whether they mean Parliament cannot be sovereign at all. There are many arguments that suggest that even from the outset, Parliament had limitations put on it - in other words it was born unfree. The 1707 Acts of Union brought about the Great British Parliament between Scotland and England, many agree that this itself induced limitations on Parliament's Power. This is most strongly argued by JDB Mitchell, TB Smith and Neil MacCormick on two points.1 Firstly, the Acts of Union preceded the new Parliament, and were enacted by two separate entities - the Scottish and English Parliaments respectively which can be regarded as a constitutional act which created and limited Parliament. ...read more.

Middle

A law may have legal force, but if it were inhumane and undemocratic it would perhaps have no political force. The question is could the courts refuse to follow it? Lord Irvine of Lairg has rejected this4, yet it continues to be a topic of debate. One good example is that of a constitutional crisis - the courts may challenge Acts in this case, and perhaps this could lead to other examples of court interference in the future. European Union Law is an important limit on Parliamentary Sovereignty - the European Court of Justice is the highest court in relation to Community matters and would therefore be supreme to our Parliament. This means that Parliament cannot legislate against EU Law, which puts a limit on what Parliament can do. Unless the United Kingdom withdrew, our Parliament would still have to legislate in accordance with EU Law. This highlights another important political point - even though Parliament would be legally supreme, would it be politically acceptable to withdraw from the European Union, and consequently is this limitation of Parliamentary Sovereignty due to a political factor? Furthermore, one could argue that Parliament is still Sovereign in domestic affairs. The Human Rights Act 1998 is another important "political" factor in Parliamentary Sovereignty. It has not been entrenched into our domestic law and therefore courts should not strike down legislation that is incompatible with it. ...read more.

Conclusion

Secondly, it has been said that Parliament can in fact bind future Parliaments over the composition of the houses, or the means of succession to the throne. This was the Great Reform Act of 1832 whereby the House of Commons was reformed in order to be more democratic. This would bind future Parliaments in that the House would only be lawful if elected in accordance with the 1832 Act.8 This question is a difficult one to conclude, although it can be argued that at every election Parliament changes with the people, and consequently Sovereignty should perhaps apply to the Parliament of the time, otherwise it would be very easy to make irreparable damage to the future democracy of our country (one could keep a particular Parliament in power despite elections). In my opinion, Parliamentary Sovereignty still remains intact, not only in a legal sense but also in a political way too. There have been undoubted erosions in Parliament's power, but how much they affect the doctrine needs to be questioned, for example, EU Law is only supreme in community matters, and holds no baring in our domestic jurisdiction. Furthermore, courts are reluctant to call into question legislation, and in most instances has no power to rule against law, meaning that even politically Sovereignty still exists. This biggest argument is that when Dicey introduced the idea of "Parliamentary Sovereignty" he meant it to be an expressly legal doctrine. In this way Parliament is of course still Sovereign - legally they can legislate on what they wish, whether it has political ramifications or not. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree UK Government & Parliamentary Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree UK Government & Parliamentary Studies essays

  1. The question of whether or not Parliament is effective as a government watchdog consists ...

    This supposedly gives MP's a chance to criticise and scrutinise the Prime Ministers policies. Tony Blair has revised the timetable for Prime ministers Question Time, and it is now held twice weekly. Due to this, it is now possible to examine issues in greater depth, and MPs get a greater chance to speak.

  2. Modern Studies Dissertation

    The Liberal Democrats biggest success to date would have to be their coalition government with the Labour Party in Scotland. In the first Scottish elections of its new parliament, the Liberal Democrats won enough votes that they formed a coalition government with Labour.

  1. Sovereignty and Democracy in the European Union.

    Cricket, they discover, has sprouted all sorts of new rules while they were not looking. They pine for the game they used to play, and love, in which Westminster stood proud and unchallenged at the centre. But that is like a conservative cosmologist during the Renaissance pining for the Mediaeval

  2. To what extent was the outbreak of the civil war in england caused by ...

    killing the Protestant settlers, it can be argued that the people had lost faith in the King at this time as 'many believed that the king could not or would not repress the insurgents.'34 When Charles went to Parliament to request an army with which to repress the Catholics in

  1. What have been the main points of disagreement between 'the left' and 'the right' ...

    (Richard Titmuss, Sociology Themes and Perspectives, Haralambos and Holborn, 5th Edition, Collins Educational) argues that the changes brought about by total war helped to create the conditions for the establishment of a welfare state. The Labour government was elected to power in 1945-51.

  2. Immigration in the United States.

    I feel that immigration should be reduced in order to keep the United States environment and culture from diluting. Many Americans feel that the federal government should ease their immigration control. Several people believe that the government should open the borders and have open immigration.

  1. History of the European Union.

    Two Commissioners come from each of the "big" Member States; * Germany * Spain * France * Italy * United Kingdom The "smaller" Member States have one from each; * Belgium * Denmark * Greece * Ireland * Luxembourg * The Netherlands * Austria * Portugal * Finland * Sweden

  2. Ascertain whether the EU suffers from a democratic deficit

    Following the Treaty of Amsterdam Parliament can now veto presidential candidates, the President able to veto member states' choices for membership of the Commission. A legitimate Commission is certainly essential with regards to the much-maligned Comitology procedure; the situation where the Commission may itself legislate via powers by the Council of Ministers.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work