• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Has power in Britain shifted significantly into the hands of unelected individuals in recent years?

Extracts from this document...


One of the key areas of British politics where it has been argued that power has shifted significantly is in the relations between the legislature and executive. Whilst it can be argued that this analysis is meaningless since the Cabinet is generally comprised of elected Members of Parliament (MPs), I intend to define the Cabinet of the United Kingdom as a group of unelected individuals since they are not directly elected by the public to these elevated positions of authority. Rather, they are selected by the Prime Minister, whose only real elected authority is as that of a MP. My definition of a truly elected individual as someone who is elected by the general public leads to the conclusion that the only true elected body is the House of Commons. The idea that the executives power is growing is a concept alluded to by Foster (Flinders, 2002, p.28) in 1997 who argued that "The House of Commons must not become the Prime Minister's poodle". However, in reality the balance of power between the Cabinet and The House of Commons has always been significantly in the hands of Cabinet members. ...read more.


Whilst it can be argued these kind of checking measures have long been prominent in Britain with the House of Lords, the creation of the Supreme Court has taken this to a new level. This independence of the judiciary is particularly dangerous as Locke argues (Weir & Beetham, 1999, p.447 ) "it may be too great a temptation to human frailty...for the same persons who have the power of making laws to have also in their hands the power to execute them". As has been shown, in the case of the judiciary, power has dangerously shifted towards unelected individuals in recent years. Whilst the role of courts within the United Kingdom have been shown to shift power away from elected individuals in recent years, this is an issue which seems almost insignificant when assessed alongside the powers that the courts of the European Union have. The creation of the European Communities Act in 1972 is one example of a significant shift in power into the hands of unelected individuals. By giving precedence to European Union law over the law of the United Kingdom this act has taken power from elected individuals in the United Kingdom not least because it means that European Union regulations and laws instantly apply to the United Kingdom without the permission of Parliament. ...read more.


The power the media holds is in forcing those elected in government to act in a certain way by treating them as prisoners accountable to the interest of the public. As Foucault (Owen, 1994, p.177) comments, "This optical relation makes the exercise of power automatic in that the prisoner, because he cannot be sure as to whether he is being observed, becomes his own supervisor, he becomes the principle of his own subjection". It could be seen that the media has long been a part of British society and so its political influence should not be seen as a significant recent shift in unelected power. However, it is better viewed in light of the medias expanding breadth and depth of involvement in politics in recent years through the age of the internet which defines the rising power of the unelected media. This power of the media should be seen as a significant shift towards power being held by unelected individuals due to the fact that, as Curran and Seaton argue (2003 p.392) "the media...absorbs over thirty hours a week in the average person's life" which is in contrast to the past where more political information was government controlled. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree UK Government & Parliamentary Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree UK Government & Parliamentary Studies essays

  1. Is there justification for government intervention in the uk housing market and how has ...

    into account the individual household's ability to pay for the housing assigned to it' (Robinson, 1979, p. 56-57) Barr similarly argues that it is not that imperfect information is a major problem - poor people live in sub-standard accommodation less because they misperceive the benefits of housing than because they cannot afford anything better.

  2. John Locke and Thomas Hobbes are two philosophers who thought extensively on the subject ...

    Machiavelli does support a Utopian form of representative government. This parliament or senate would allow the people of the nation to have a say in their government and how they are ruled. If any corruption occurs, the populace will now have a means of stopping it. Machiavelli said of a good ruler: ?

  1. Britain and the Eurozone. Britains May 2005 parliamentary elections produced some very telling ...

    Only one "passed"; the one related to the ability of the City of London to maintain its competitive advantage in the global financial markets. The other four were deemed to have "failed""9. The reality is that the Blair government has only offered tepid support to the idea of having the

  2. Where does decision-making power lie in the British executive?

    In addition, the post of the Prime Minister is recognised as carrying a great authority by other ministers, the civil service, and heads of foreign states. Prime ministerial signals can have an immediate and dramatic impact on the direction of policy.

  1. How far have the reforms of the Blair Governments addressed weaknesses in the UK ...

    The dire predictions of floods of cases and judges running wild have been proved to be false. In the few cases where judicial review has occurred, the government has taken remedial action in every case, by repealing or amending the offending provision.

  2. Is Representative Democracy An Effective Way to Distribute Political Power?

    Other theorists have famously voiced their concerns for the democratic representation and the limitations of the electoral system and the way in which the UK votes. Parliamentary representation serves to include 'the people' in decision making, indirectly and infrequently through the process of elections; yet simultaneously, it serves to exclude

  1. To what extent do the media in Britain determine political attitudes and opinions?

    disagree with the invasion of one of the world's poorest countries on the rightful grounds that not all Afghanistan's are terrorists. In this way, media can possibly shape the opinions and views of events. Additionally, the media's obsession with bad news, investigated by the Glasgow University Media Group (1976), such

  2. Does the Media have too much political power in Britain?

    Spin Doctors build the roles of these Prime Ministers as presidents because it is central in showing strong characteristics and strong leadership skills. "Political actors pursue own goals and frequently dominate the media, audience no active role in media... careful packaging of Mrs Thatcher by Gordon Reece from mid 1970s

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work