• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"If one accepts that it is through close conditioning that a women learns to conform, and that it is this close supervision w

Extracts from this document...


"If one accepts that it is through close conditioning that a women learns to conform, and that it is this close supervision which prevents criminality, then any lessening of the control would lead to increased criminality" (Williams 2004, pp. 469-70) Introduction In a direct response to the quotation, the essay will attempt to identify a possible causal link between the development of the modern 'women's movement' and an assumed increase in female criminality. The discourse and debates within the discipline will be evaluated to determine if there has been an increased female criminality since the 1960's. The assessment will further be improved by analogy of criminal statistics prior and post manumission and collate those findings to current statistical data. Other suggested alternative explanations, social forces such as 'marginalisation' and the possible changing attitudes of law enforcement agencies in regards to the processing of female offenders will also be considered. In regards to the ensuing impact of a feminist critique, the creation of various strands of feminist theory will be outlined and defined within the appendix because of the wordage constraint. 'Malestream' Criminology Historically, to a large extent, Criminology through facilitation of its meta- narratives has been perceived as failing to provide valid explanations and empirical research in relation to female criminality and is primarily concerned with the phenomenon of male criminality. Another shortcoming is its failure to address the issue of gender inequalities. Heidensohn (1985) is of the view that sociological approaches to crime and delinquency have seriously neglected gender variables, which is the crucial variable in predicting criminality and in effect, have produced explanations of 'male' behaviour opposed to behaviour generally. Criminology has for many feminist writers and researchers been a constraining rather than a constructive and creative influence. Those theories that have attempted to address the issue of female deviance have been confined to the predestined actor model theories, such as Lombroso's positivist theory (et al, 1885) ...read more.


Also, as women are 'climbing up the corporate business ladder', they are making use of their 'vocational liberation' to pursue careers in white-collar crime. A practical example of which can be seen in the high profile case of Joyti De-Laurey, Goldman Sachs secretary who stole �4.5m from her employer. She plundered her bosses' private bank accounts by forging their signatures and writing cheques to herself and spent it all on a lavish lifestyle of diamonds, designer labels and fast car. Adler in a later study commented, "Women would naturally wish to emulate male patterns in criminality and would adopt masculine roles to do so" (Adler, 1977). She discovered that in the United States, between 1960 and 1972, robberies committed by women rose by 277%, in comparison to a 169% increase in male robberies, embezzlement by women rose by 280%, whereas for men the figure rose by 50%. Overall, arrest rates for females were rising three times as fast as those for males and particularly quickly amongst female delinquents (cited in Harralambos et al, 1995, pp 438:5). The statistical support for Adler's theory was based on a comparison of rates of offending among genders for the period 1960 to 1972 using U.S. Uniform Crime Report (UCR) arrest data (Adler, 1975, pp 15-16). . But what evidence exists to support the 'liberation thesis? As crime is generally linked to 'poverty', and that "Women are the poorest of all in our society" (Booth, 1985: 9), would 'feminism' not lead to less crime being committed by women, as the options for employment increase? Another criticism is her over reliance on official criminal statistics which are notoriously problematic. Recorded crime statistics only include those offences dealt with by the criminal justice system. Many offences are never reported to the police, especially 'white-collar' crimes which remain largely hidden, of those that are, a substantial proportion are not cleared up. Smart (1976) ...read more.


The maturation and impact of the modern 'women's movement' has undoubtedly influenced and altered the social control of women and has produced changes in their behaviour and the way in which they are processed within the criminal justice system. Although, there was a clear argument that refutes the effect liberation has had on the emancipation of lower-classes females. The increase in female crime is more practically explained as a result of economic marginalisation through unemployment, divorce or separation from a partner. Consideration must also be applied to the way in which female crimes, especially those of a serious nature arouse the greatest publicity and controversy, despite the obvious small amount in ratio to male crime. Appendix 1 The Various Feminist Theories 1. Liberal Feminism- This perspective is essentially concerned with equal rights and opportunities for women by demonstrating how women are being ignored and has primarily concentrated on sex differentials in crime and discrimination practices in the criminal justice system in its research. 2. Radical Feminism- This perspective focuses on the oppression of women by men and examines how women came to occupy subservient roles within society by focusing on their physiology (the necessity to bear children). For Radical Feminist Criminologists, the only way to understand crime is to see it through a female perspective. 3. Socialist Feminism- This perspective views oppression as rooted in patriarchal capitalism. They support practical action to improve the position of women's lives on an everyday basis. 4. Post-modern Feminism- Its approach is broadly 'deconstructionist'. Writers such as Carol Smart (1990) proposed that the very concerns of Criminology (Burglary, street crime, etc) are actually a reflection of male concerns and that women should be looking beyond those to consider how harm comes to women. It is also opposed to accepting the 'male' boundaries that other theories offer. 5. Marxist Feminism- This approach views 'patriarchal ideology', male domination and female subordination as developing out of the relations produced by the capitalist system. For Marxist Feminists, we need to rid society of capitalism and then gender inequalities will also be remedied. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Criminology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Criminology essays

  1. Methods of Uncovering the Dark Figure of Crime

    In 2001, the BCS estimated that 56% of the comparable subset was recorded. Therefore, through the BCS, it is evident that victimization surveys are a strong method to uncover the dark figure of crime. In 2006, the Central Statistics Office (CSO), part of the Quarterly National Household Surveys, surveyed 39,000 households in Ireland.

  2. Examine the contribution of feminism to contemporary criminology

    One of the main ideas of this feminism was to reject the concept that there was only one single explanation for crime. An important belief of postmodern feminism is that it places itself in opposition to essentialism which is a understanding that differences between men and women are natural instead of socially constructed.

  1. Compare positivist approaches to crime with at least two other perspectives discussed in the ...

    For instance, individuals with more extreme physical flaws have less access to legitimate social pursuits. Furthermore, the assumption of the existence of these physical characteristics provokes unequal and unfair treatment for the people who are exhibiting them. People must not be labelled as criminals due to their physical disorders.


    in miscarriage cases, further rights for individuals in police stations, and Human Rights Act 1998, Article 6, the right to a fair trial. As a consequence of these Acts being introduced there has been a slight decrease in the number of wrongful convictions, however, there is some dispute concerning these

  1. Crime and violence is a problem that affects all areas of the world, but ...

    In this experiment the visual material consisted of pairs of cards with three different lengths of vertical lines (called comparison lines) on one and a single standard line the same length as one of the three comparison lines on the other.

  2. Literature Review - Male Rape.

    The study seeks to explore and define the different ways in male rape is interpreted by the victims taking into account their sexuality. She explains that in her sample group there were 17 heterosexual men who had been anally penetrated with a penis, they all defined the attack as rape at the time of the incident.

  1. Restorative justice is currently hailed as a progressive way to deal with young offenders. ...

    effect not only on the victim but the community (Gray, et al 2003). Studies in Plymouth, England, found 95.2% of offenders he questioned felt that Restorative Justice had held them responsible for their behaviour, with 90.2% having a better understanding of the effect of their behaviour on others, and 73% having more consideration toward the feelings of the victim.


    According to Save the Children UK (2007b.p.1), 218 million children throughout the world are being forced to work long hours for little or no pay and left vulnerable to ?extreme harm, violence and rape?. Muncie et al, 2009, p.24). The children involved are seen as a commodity that can be traded across all continents.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work