• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In modern Western societies, God is dead. Is this correct?

Extracts from this document...


In modern Western societies, 'God is dead'. Is this correct? The words used in the topic for the first time were used by F. Nietzsche in his 'The Gay Science' (1882) and popularized by 'Thus spoke Zarathustra' (1883-1885) in which he shows his idea of God being dead. What he meant is of course not the case that God has died literally. It has rather to tell that religion (in this case - Christianity) is a caricature of what it should be or what Jesus intended or would wish it to be. However, sociologists use this sentence in different meaning although its source still lies in Nietzsche's understanding of this particular phrase. I will try to find out the connection between Nietzsche's death of the God and the sociologists' discussion on whether modern Western societies are already secular or not and then to suggest some answers to the question depending on the stand one is looking from. The point that Nietzsche makes is that the particular Christian God (or rather the idea of him) has rather been killed (by the people of course) than died. Moreover, he has written that 'Gott ist tot' rather than 'Gott starb' which means rather 'God is dead' (which would focus the attention of God being dead NOW) ...read more.


However, it should be mentioned that people arguing so miss out something important by rejecting to accept this term. It can be easily seen that there are measurable ongoing processes considering a constant loss of interest in religion in European societies (in surveys 13.5% of British people are members of the Church of England, while in Poland - around 90% are members of Roman Catholic Church). For that reason it is hard not to make an assumption that there is such a thing as secularization of the society. Focusing on the methods of measuring this unclear process, some different ways of doing that can be mentioned. Steve Bruce argues that it should be done in most empirical way it is possible. For him, 'we are concerned with the changing popularity and place of certain beliefs and types of behaviour' and 'we are not in the business of judging the quality of those beliefs and actions or the sincerity of those who adhere to them' (1996, p. 25-26).What he means by this is that secularization can be considered for example in terms of statistically measurable behaviours (like per cent of mass attendance). The second idea comes from Wilson. ...read more.


It is also much more comfortable to do what one sees as appropriate than what one has to do. Because of this a consumer culture can also be a challenge for contemporary religion. The last problem for that has to be mentioned is science. They have always been competing with each other for which of the sides is right. However, there has been a raise of science recently and because of that it is rather impossible for the situation similar to the Galileo's to happen again nowadays, which would suggest that religion has indeed a weaker position in Western society than it had in 16th century. As long as data taking society into account is under the consideration, it seems that it indeed confirms the thesis that we do live a secular society. However, most of the people declare that they believe in something supernatural (regardless of what it is) and thus it cannot be said that religion is in complete decline. It just has moved to the personal level and every one of us decides on their own how important it is for themselves. Still, if we are answering the question whether God is dead, and as it has been stated above it refers to the overall society, we are likely to say: Yes, God is (still?) dead. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Religion in Society section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Religion in Society essays

  1. Is the influence of religion in western society declining? Can we reasonably measure its ...

    According to the 1851 British census approximately 40% of the population attended church. By 1950 this had dropped to 20% and was less than 7.5% in 2000. Sunday school attendance had also dropped considerably from 55% in 1900 to just 4% in 2000 despite the fact that the population had grown considerably.

  2. The good sides of patriotism.

    In the war , every Turkish person struggle the enemies by taking the risk of death. Now it is time to think that where the delusion is, in patriotism or in Tolstoy's thoughts.

  1. How much and in what ways has 9/11 influenced public perceptions and the self ...

    (Islam in the West, 2007, p66) . Only about 1% of Western European Muslims are converts. The USA, although a republican state, still allows religion to play a part in public life and 'American Civil Religion' (Islam in the West, 2007, P48)

  2. Critically examine the statistical evidence that supports the Secularisation thesis.

    In his book 'The Phenomenon of Religion' Moojan Momen says there are five ways of looking at secularisation firstly the decline of popular involvement in institutionalised religion; this can be seen in the decline in church attendance, with fewer marriages, baptisms and funerals being performed under religious auspices.

  1. According to secularization theory what should happen to religion as society undergoes modernization?

    Which may be detrimental to the advancement and expansion of the society. However some authors state that it is only Western societies that are seen as modern making all other societies less inferior, primitive or un-evolved by comparison, although Japan is now considered very modern.

  2. The Changing Role of the Catholic Church in Latin America

    As such, the Catholic Church as an institution operates within the complex framework of a politically, socially, economically and culturally evolving society that perpetually transforms, to varying degrees, the relevance and applicability of the Catholic Church in contemporary Latin America.

  1. Is religion really in decline in the west or is it merely changing?

    Weber suggested that prior to this, ?otherworldly-asceticism? was the only to exist, and predominantly among the very pious in society. Monks often lived in isolation in monasteries to remove themselves from societal temptations. Martin Luther, a key initiator of the protestant revolution, argued that hard work and good performance worked to glorify the individual in the light of God.

  2. Homosexuality and Christianity

    These statements define the so-called Christian way. (18) These statements also leave a lot of room for the individual to take what he or she wants, such as how they interpret the Bible. According to ?Coming Out in Christianity? people could have been exposed to the idea of homosexuality as morally wrong because of their religious upbringing.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work