• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In what way(s) can the theory of the Panopticon be applied to information technologies and / or electronic surveillance? Address the possible limitation of this theory.

Extracts from this document...


In what way(s) can the theory of the Panopticon be applied to information technologies and / or electronic surveillance? Address the possible limitation of this theory. The evolution of surveillance technologies throughout the last two decades has been outrageously enormous. Physical spaces have been swarmed by a new colony of electronic surveillance and information technologies. With so many 'eyes in the sky[AS1]', public space has been eroded by the electronic Panopticon[AS2]. Surveillance is concurrently becoming sophisticated and intrusive as well as being accepted. It can be attributed to the need to maintain control and to discipline society (Sewell, 1999). Bogard remarks, "The power of monitoring & recording have expanded exponentially in postmodern socitiessocieties...where virtually every space, interior & exterior, has become a space of observation" (2006: 61). This essay will look more in depth at today's modern electronic panoptical society. It will be segmented into three main parts starting with the origins and recognition of Panopticism, followed by its application to information technologies and electronic surveillance by using the academic works of Foucault, Lyon, Bogard and, Boyne principles and theoretical frameworks to explain, and . It will concludefinishing with the possible limitation the theory of Panopticism insinuates. FirstPrimarily, the Panopticon, meaning anrefering to an area where everything all is visible, was proposed as a prison design by the philosopher Jeremy Bentham in 1791 (Engberg, 1996). The Panopticon functioned as a the perfectfaultless disciplinary apparatus, devised to ensure that no prisoner could ever see the guard who conducted surveillance from the privilegedan upper, central observation watchtower. The prisoner would never know that they were on no account knew when they were being observed, or when they will be watched over, which mademaking them mentallypsychologically uncertain[AS3] (Boyne, 2000). ...read more.


James Rule's (1973) outlook of electronic surveillance also has an Orwell vision, which can be viewed as a system that "would work to enforce compliance with a uniform set of norms governing every aspect of everyone's behaviour. Every action of every person would be scruitinised, recorded, evaluated both at the moment of occurrence and forever afterwards. Any sign of disobedience, present or anticipated, would result in corrective action" (cited in Sewell, 1999: 4). Orwell's analysis of technology surveillance and information was somewhat a mental plague that is forced upon our humanity in order to be manipulated by the influential to conform to what suits them best (Lyon, 1994). However things have changed since Orwell's times and it can be seen that some of his work has been outdated. It is well past 1984 and electronic surveillance has grown strong and reached global lengths where it is not only a government apparatus, but also a private one as well. People are even using the electronic surveillance to protect their privacy and right to security. Companies also have caught up with the use of information technologies and electronic surveillance in the name of consumption (Lyon, 1994). Nonetheless Orwell's account and work must be acknowledged as it delivers an insightful point. To a certain extent, the Panopticon provides a much more constructive understanding of information technologies and electronic surveillance. Lyon perceives the Panopticon as an alternative to Big Brother and that its panoptic principle was to anticipate for a utopia scheme in support of a social reform (Lyon, 1994). Subtler and less coercive methods have become increasingly well known in the advance societies, the argument is that this is due to the social control the panoptic power generates (Lyon, 1994). ...read more.


In what way(s) can the theory of the Panopticon be applied to information technologies and / or electronic surveillance? Address the possible limitation of this theory. Reference Bogard, W (1996) The simulation of surveillance: Hypercontrol in telematic societies. Cambridge: University of Cambridge, 'Social Control in the 1990s Engberg, D (1996) The Virtual Pantopitcon: Impact of New Media Technologies, Fall 1996 [Online]. Available from: http://besser.tsoa.nyu.edu/impact/f96/Projects/dengberg/ [Accessed 24 May 2008] Foucault M. (1977) Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison. New York: New American Library Danaher, G. Schirato, T. and Webb, J. (2000) Understanding Foucault. Sydney. Allen & Unwin Davis M. (1998) City of Quartz. Pimilco. London. 'Fortress Los Angeles' pages 223 - 263 Hudson, B (2002) Punishment and control in Maguire, M et al (eds) The Oxford Handbook of criminology, Third edition, Oxford University Press Sewell, G (1999) On the Possibility of Sociology of Workplace Surveillanc. Department of Management. University of Melbourne. Parkville, Victoria Van Krieken, Robert, Habibis, Daphne, Smith, Philip, Hutchins, Brett, Haralambos, Michael, Holborn, Martin. (2006) Sociology: Themes and Perspectives: 3rd Edition. Longman, Melbourne. Whitehead, J (2002) Down With Big Brother: The Thought Crimes of George Orwell. Old Speak online journal. [Online]. The Rutherford Institute |. Available from: http://www.rutherford.org/oldspeak/Articles/Art/oldspeak-bigbrother2.asp [Accessed 24 April 2008] Burke, R. (2005). An Introduction to Criminological Theory: Second Edition. Willan Publishing. United Kingdom. Young, J (1999) The exclusion society. London: sage 'From inclusive to exclusive society'. Pages 1- 29 [AS1]This is a quote, you need to reference it. [AS2]For example? CCTV [AS3]Uncertain regarding what exactly? Perhaps elaborate on this point, mentioning something like, acting as a deterrent effect of potential crime that may occur. [AS4]You should not reference Boyne, rather reference the actual book by Foucault because that is where the ideas actually come from, not Boyne. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Criminology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Criminology essays

  1. Early on in Discipline and Punish, Foucault makes the argument that discipline and punishment ...

    to work and that was being supervised, it is the act of supervision that was penetrating their psyche. Furthermore, the status of supervisor is vital here, for "discipline is an art of rank." The idea that a person of greater power was watching one made the workers want to work harder and more efficiently so as to avoid being reprimanded.

  2. Using Hirschis (1969) social bond theory to analyse the drug detoxification camp run by ...

    It will result the less likely the child grows to be delinquent (Rankin & Kern, 1994). Therefore, I believe the stress that Wu Oi has put, in encouraging inmates to restore and restart nurturing their past broken family relationships, is playing a decisive role in helping them to resist future temptation and thus prevent recidivism.

  1. Crime Scene Photography - Footwear Marks

    Figure 4 The inverse square law The inverses square Law states that associate degree object doubly the space from a source of light will receive a quarter of the illumination.

  2. Imprisonment should only be used as a last resort due to its long-term negative ...

    As Wacquant (2001b) would agree that prisons are the institutions that control social order. Those professionals that are involved in the realms of justice are unwilling to confess their involvement in dictated harm (Clear et al, 2001). Although due to imprisonment, suicide rates inherently rise and mental health issues fester.

  1. Why has the United Kingdom adopted CCTV technology with such enthusiasm and how effective ...

    adoption of CCTV in the UK was not solely based on the need to reduce crime but also the fact that it tied neatly with Conservative policy and plans to revive the economy once more and therefore could also explain why the government channelled such large sums of money into new and existing schemes.

  2. The origins of the criminological imagination lay with C. Wright Mills and his book ...

    Young raises the argument that criminologists can take past events and readjust their theories so that they fit to what the data shows (Young 2011). However he argues that data on crime is ?severely limited? and that data is scrutinised until the data that is presented to us can fit the theory people are trying to argue.

  1. Surveillance of Society. This is the first step towards a submissive and controlled civilization. ...

    There was a constant viewership, with the government controlling everyones thoughts and moves. Congruently, the characters live in a society that has been compared to the 21st century. One that is filled with surveillance, invasiveness and issues involving privacy.

  2. Perceptions of wrongful convictions amongst Americans working in the criminal justice system.

    Third, other participants in the criminal justice process suffer. For example, jury members, prosecutors, and judges are faced with the fact that their actions were instrumental in sending an innocent person to prison, or worse, to death row. Also, imagine the feelings of a rape victim who later discovers that

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work