• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is genocide just another form of war?

Extracts from this document...


Transfer-Encoding: chunked Is genocide just another form of war? The first half of the 20th century saw the destruction of approximately 150 million lives according to Matthew White and Steven Pinker in Atrocities, in which they account ?Humanity?s 100 Deadliest Achievements? (Pinker, White, 2013, p. 34). The underlying causes of the tragic acts of genocide during this period have deep historic roots and scholars have searched far and wide in order to provide an explanation for this phenomenon. Academic discourse on the topic varies, including questions as to the role played by modernity and the effects of war and revolution on the political sphere. However, despite the conflicting arguments amongst researchers, there are common themes within their analyses. This essay will explore some of those common themes, arguing that genocide and war are closely linked while also recognising the distinctions between genocide, war, revolution and degenerate killing as proposed by Martin Shaw (Shaw, 2003). It will conclude, to a certain extent, that genocide is a manifestation of modernity by drawing on the works of thinkers such as Bauman, Horkheimer and Adorno. Ultimately, it will be found that there is no definitive explanation for genocide and that it is the product of a combination of factors. ...read more.


It must be stated however, that fascist and totalitarian dictators aren?t the only ones guilty of targeting unarmed civilians as part of the process of war, in fact during the second world war, the Allies routinely bombed areas inhabited by civilians, such as railways and industrial districts as a means of weakening the armed opposition. Markusen and Kopf argue in their book The Holocaust and Strategic Bombing: Genocide and Total War in the Twentieth Century, that strategic bombing such as that carried out by the Allies is genocidal in itself (Markusen, Kopf, 1995). Shaw expands this argument further with his proposition of the concept of ?degenerate war?, which he describes as the ?annihilation of civilian populations for strategic reasons.? (Shaw, 2003). Although this form of warfare is also responsible for the massacre of civilians, the UN Convention fails to recognise this in the same breadth as genocide, which is arguably justifiable when looking more closely into some of the core dimensions of degenerate war in contrast to genocide and regular warfare. Shaw explains that, as a type of social action, there is a clear distinction between war and genocide in that war is about the destruction of an organised army or enemy whereas the destruction in an episode of genocide is aimed towards an unarmed social group. ...read more.


This new dynamic between revolution and genocide doesn?t explain all episodes of violent mass killings against targeted social groups and of course, not all revolutions are genocidal. However, taking into consideration some of the most notorious, widespread acts of genocide in history like those committed in Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union, there?s no denying the pattern that appears to emerge in the 20th century of revolutionary movements characterised by genocide and ethnic cleansing, conducted against the backdrop of war or within militarised societies. Thus, it remains that the roots of genocide are complex to say the least. The twentieth century was a major turning point in the history of violence and armed conflict in society, which was reflected in both the increased number of genocidal episodes and inter-state and civil wars. It would appear that there are strong correlations between genocide and war, with evidence suggesting that although war does not necessarily cause genocide, it is fundamental to it?s nature. Various features of modernity such as enhanced technologies and changes to bureaucracy allowed states to systematically exterminate the undesirable groups within their populations, with certain ideas around nation and race born out of the Enlightenment also having played a part in this. As well as a form of war, genocide also acts as a key component in many of the revolutions, which emerged out of WWI, revolutions grounded in the creation of a new, homogenised society. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Political & Economic Sociology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Political & Economic Sociology essays

  1. Discuss the factors which led to the rapid industrialisation of Japan

    a tranquil countenance, a desire to preserve an attitude of respect, a desire to be sincere in words, a desire to see clearly when he looks at something, a desire to be careful in his work, a willingness to enquire further in to anything about which he has doubts, a

  2. Critically analyse the relationship between globalisation, crime and crime prevention.

    A duration of someone being in custody for just a month is about �2,000 compared to a prisoner with a probation order which is �89, hence suggesting the demolishing of the prison service. It has been proven that Britain has the third highest prisoner rate in the European Union (Abercrombie 2002).

  1. Poverty : The definition, the cause and the possible solutions Is there an end ...

    to short-term, low-paid, temporary and possibly 'unofficial' work (Moore et al 2001: 143). A minister of the Labour Government and poverty campaigner, Frank Field MP (1998), although in agreement with Charles Murray !1998) regarding the advancing underclass in British societies, viewed its existence a great deal more sympathetically than his American counterpart.

  2. Age of Innocence - Explore Wharton's Presentation of Women In The Novel.

    Ellen leaves immediately to live in Paris, and Archer resolves once again -- and this time finally -- to do his "dull duty" and become "what was called a faithful husband." The New York society have a farewell dinner for Ellen and she leaves the country.

  1. In "The Company: A Short History of a Revolutionary Idea", John Micklethwait and Adrian ...

    However, these inequalities are to be arranged in such a way so as to benefit the least advantaged as much as possible, and to be attached to positions that are equally accessible to all. Applying this principle to the business sphere, conflicts of interests between the affected parties must be

  2. Identify and evaluate some of the evidence used to argue that we have moved ...

    extreme skepticism about our ability to carry on the sociological tradition as it has been conceived since the nineteenth century.' (Kivisto. 1998. p140) Postmodernists such as Lyotard or Baudrillard suggest that sociology must become more modest in its attempt to explain or understand society.

  1. Gang affiliation

    But is it always the "poverty stricken" and the individual from a broken home that makes a conscience decision to become part of a violent gang? This is nothing more than another myth. Many gang members come from prominent families in their community.

  2. Can and should public policy decisions be based solely on scientific evidence?

    The issue seems to be a wilful retreat from complexity by oversimplifying the problems. But what needs to be understood is that as geo-engineering has to be thought of in multi dimensional levels in terms of how the world might be affective, another reality is just being ignored.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work