• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is it true to say that the British parliament is no longer truly sovereign?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Is it true to say that the British parliament is no longer truly sovereign? Parliament, legally, consists of the House of Commons, The House of Lords and the monarchy. However, since the monarch today has only prerogative powers, and since 1911 the House of Lords has lost much of its power, sovereignty now rests largely with the House of Commons (Economist 1995, p25). The doctrine of Parliamentary sovereignty is the idea that parliament is effectively the most powerful decision making body in the land. It can essentially be broken down into three elements: firstly that it has the ability to 'make or unmake any law' (Scully, 2003, p124), secondly that it cannot pass any laws which bind its successors, and thirdly, that any acts passed by Parliament cannot be questioned by the courts of law. There are many contemporary issues which have come to affect the sovereignty of the British Parliament. The rise of Brussels, the process of devolution, the power of the executive and the issue of globalisation, amongst other things, have all contributed to the erosion of parliamentary sovereignty. ...read more.

Middle

Another, more fundamental issue has arisen with the Britain's decision to join the European Community and later the European Union. Because of the supranational nature of the European Union, British membership has greatly affected the issue of parliamentary sovereignty. Britain now has to abide by rules and treaties set by the EU and European law which significantly hinder the UK's independence of action. In other words, the British Parliament cannot pass laws which contravene EU treaties and regulations and has to follow these rules at all times. The European Communities Act of 1972 created a situation where all EU regulations and laws instantly apply to the UK without the assent of Parliament. The Act also gives EU law precedence over the law of the UK (Jones, 2001, p302). This was seen most notably in 1990 when a law was passed by the British Parliament to prevent the practice of 'quota-hopping' by Spanish fishermen. The EU blocked this law because it went against EU legislation on the freedom of movement of workers. (Fisher(ed), 2003, p124). The decisions of Parliament are no longer truly final, as other bodies, namely the European Court of Justice can set these decisions aside. ...read more.

Conclusion

Globalisation has also played a part in the erosion of parliamentary sovereignty. Multi national corporations have become so economically powerful that the richest of them have a higher Gross Domestic Output than many countries. They can effectively dictate demands to governments in return for financial rewards. Although this is more of a contingent factor than a constitutional one, it cannot be underestimated in the argument over national sovereignty. Although some believe that Parliament in Britain has never been truly sovereign for any long period of time, I feel that as the only publicly elected component of government, it should be the most powerful element in a democratic system of rule. The House of Commons is used by Cabinets to pursue their policies which may not be even in the public interest, the EU, the most powerful elements of which are not publicly elected, dictates to Parliament to a certain extent on a number of issues; and private businesses push their own agendas upon the government. All in all, I believe that the only elected organ of Britain's government is no longer truly sovereign and has become essentially a talking shop and rubber stamp for government and EU legislation. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree UK Government & Parliamentary Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree UK Government & Parliamentary Studies essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Critically assess Rhodes' (1997) argument that 'Policy networks of resource dependent organisations are a ...

    3 star(s)

    The Westminster model is a concept that has been extensively used by political observers to describe the situation of government in Britain. It depicts the executive as being, the strong dominant power concentrated in the central government known as Westminster or Whitehall.

  2. The question of whether or not Parliament is effective as a government watchdog consists ...

    The golden age of Parliament was between 1832 and 1868, this was the period when Parliamentary strength over the executive was at its maximum. It was the time when the government lacked stable Parliamentary majorities, as the party system had not been developed.

  1. Institutionalised racism and how it manifests in contemporary Britain.

    For three nights in early June, Oldham, in Lancashire, Northern England was rocked by a spontaneous act of rebellion in which Asian youth fought running battles first with neo-Nazis, then with the Greater Manchester Police. The reverberations of the youth uprising continued with major confrontations in the city of Leeds

  2. THERE IS NO LONGER A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN MANAGEMENT OF THE PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SECTOR

    The requirement to submit local authority services to competitive tender under the Local Government Acts of 1988 and 1992 has been the subject of debate. Moving towards a truly competitive environment has required local authorities to relinquish many long-established practices and attitudes.

  1. Critically discuss the degree to which Parliament holds the Executive accountable

    Any amendments in the Lords are voted on a motion to agree or disagree back in the Commons. Legislative scrutiny can be said to rest with the back-benchers as it is only by crossing the floor of the house when the government in majority can be defeated.

  2. How successful is British Drug Policy?

    Bean (ibid) argues that 'treatment works' suggesting that British policy is on the right lines to peruse enforced treatment programmes, but his argument for coercion rest solely on the fact that drug abuse is on the rise rather than any empirical evidence.

  1. DOES THE BRITISH PARLIAMENT STILL PROVIDE AN EFFECTIVE CHECK ON EXECUTIVE POWER?

    One must also state the more detailed inspections provided by parliament to check on the executive power. That is that firstly one may argue that the government also known as the executive is accountable to parliament and through parliament to the people and as a result it is in the parliament that the government must elaborate and defend its actions.

  2. Scottish Devolution

    All MSPs have equal status in the Scottish Parliament. The voting system used is known as the Additional Member System(AMS) and is a type of proportional representation. At a Scottish Parliament election each voter has two votes. With one vote, people choose between candidates standing in their constituency.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work