• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Ministerial Responsibility

Extracts from this document...


Ministerial Responsibility. 'Ministerial Responsibility is an administrative myth' Discuss and analyse this statement with reference to the practice of ministerial responsibility in recent years. The government of Ireland "Rialtas na hE�reann, is the cabinet that exercises executive authority in Ireland. It is headed by a prime minister who is referred to nationally as the Taoiseach and a deputy prime minister called the Tan�iste. The President of Ireland then appoints the remaining members of the government as a minister. These ministers are divided up into allocated departments, where they are "responsible for every single act of his or her department and of the civil servants in that department" (Byrne, 1996). Controversy over the roles carried out by ministers over the last few decades has increased widespread acknowledgment that ministerial responsibility is no longer efficient and "can no longer serve as the sole constitutional touchstone of accountability" (Connaughton, 2006). In this assignment, my first aim is to compare and contrast the roles of ministers and civil servants and their input into our State. Secondly in forming an apprehension of accountability and with the investigation into four case studies of neglected State work in the practice of ministerial responsibility over the last few decades, I hope I will have a worthwhile argument in justifying that Ministerial Responsibility is an administrative myth and how we Irish, members of this diminishing Country at present with the envelopment of recession that we take more seriously the fallen issues and roles held by our elected government. In the classical Westminster system which Ireland inherited and continues to operate, the civil service is accountable to ministers, who are in turn accountable to parliament, which in turn is accountable to the people. (Byrne, 1996). Ministers act collectively as the government in cabinet under the chairmanship of the Prime Minister (Byrne, 1996). It is the main focus of the Minister to work with the publics needs and in doing so create a better country to live. ...read more.


An operational review conducted by the panel of internal staff and external representatives was led by the new Chief Executive, Bill Morton and was undertaken to ensure that the problems in 2000 were not replicated in the following school academic results year 2001. The Deloitte and Touche report "A Review into Exam Results Issues concerning the Scottish Qualifications Authority" was published on 31 October. The report found that: "Whilst data handling issues were, ultimately, a critical flaw in Diet 2000, it would be inappropriate to conclude that this was the only deficiency in performance or that the arrangements for data handling were the single cause of the problems. No one single problem lies at the root of the SQA's poor performance this year" (Deloitte and Touche, 2000). Rather, there were "weaknesses and difficulties in a number of interlinked management, process and information systems areas which, cumulatively, overwhelmed the delivery of National Qualifications for Diet 2000" (Meeting the Parliament, 2000). These interlinked management weaknesses and difficulties included: � A lack of leadership at senior management level � An improper organisational structure and poor communication � Lack of planning in relation to the implementation of Higher Still � Inadequate computer system specification and planning � Lack of clear definition of operational processes and of contingency arrangements � Poor handling of the marking process. (Deloitte and Touche, 2000). It is the development of agencies such as the SQA that has brought issues of responsibility and accountability to the public fore. It is these various NDPBs and agencies that have created more complex and obtrusive accountability structures. With the government increasingly involving the private sector in new structures of management and letting them participate in political affairs involving the public such as the SQA, the lines of accountability becomes more unclear, and the person who is held responsible for major failures such as the exam results mayhem in 2000 which cost the people of Scotland an estimated �11 million can not be defined. ...read more.


It is our right as citizens of a state to receive proper standards of living and to be shown respect by our ministers and local government. The above cases shows that the government could be a lot stronger and take more measures in preventing such disastrous outcomes like the above selected few to happen again. (4,634) Barker, A. (1998) "Political Responsibility for UK Prison Security - Ministers Escape Again." Public Administration 76 (1) 1-23 Brett, 1996 "Cave Creek 1995- New Zealand Disasters", Christchurch City Libraries Viewed on [email protected] (http://christchurchcitylibraries.com/Kids/NZDisasters/CaveCreek.asp) Brett and tHart...... Byrne, D. (1996) 'Strategic Management in the Irish Civil Service: A Review Drawing on the Experience in New Zealand and Australia' in Administration 43 (2) Cappel et al, 1990??) Carlson, N, et al, (2004), 'Psychology', Pearson Education ltd, England. Clarence, E. (2002) "Ministerial responsibility and the Scottish Qualifications Agency" Public Administration 80 (4) 791-803. Connaughton, B. (2006) "Reform of Politico-administrative Relations in the Irish System: Clarifying or Complicating the Doctrine of Ministerial Responsibility?" Irish Political Studies Vol. 21, No. 3, 257-276 Deloitte and Touche. (2000). "A review into exam results issues concerning the Scottish Qualifications Authority" Viewed on 26/11/[email protected] (http://www.scotland.gov.uk/library3/education/sqar-00.asp ) Gregory, R. (1998b) "Political Responsibility for Bureaucratic Incompetence: Tragedy at Cave Creek." Public Administration 76 (1). 519-538. Meeting the Parliament. (2000) "The Scottish Parliament: Inquiries into SQA" Viewed on 29/11/[email protected] http://www.scottish.parliament.uk/business/research/pdf_res_notes/rn00-110.pdf Noble, Judge G. S. 1995. Report of the commission of inquiry into the collapse of a viewing platform at Cave Creek. Wellington: department of Internal Affairs Nationmaster.com (2003-2005) "Encyclopedia Higher (Scottish)" Nationwide Viewed on 28/11/[email protected] (http://www.nationmaster.com/encyclopedia/Higher-Scottish.html). Sqa.org.uk "About the Scottish Qualifications Authority (SQA) Viewed on 30/11/[email protected] 12.25 (http://www.sqa.org.uk/sqa/5656.1589.html Thompson, W. (2005) "Cave Creek haunts survivor" New Zealand Herald Viewed on 27/11/[email protected] http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10115932-ref Travers, J. (2005) "Interim report on the report on certain issues of management and administration in the Department of Health and Children associated with the practice of charges for persons in long stay health care in health board institutions and related matters", Oireachtas Joint Committee. Department of Health and Children Tvnz.co.nz. (2008) "Tragedy triggers Cave Creek memories", One News, New Zealand Viewed on 26/11/[email protected] (http://tvnz.co.nz/view/page/42344661718065 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Political Systems section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Political Systems essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Has Neofunctionalism Been Superseded By A New 'Liberal Intergovernmentalism" As Currently The Most Convincing ...

    5 star(s)

    Outside the 'grand bargains' of Treaties, looking at the crucial 'day-to-day' evolution of the PHARE programme, neofunctionalism seems the only theory available for sufficient analysis. This essay has seen has examined the main differences between the two competing theories of European integration.

  2. Research Project - Efficiency of the parliament as a legislative branch in Russia.

    Even though this party works really well, there must be opposition to show UR other sides of decisions of majority. UR is the most popular party in Russian Federation and people were satisfied all this time, but deficiency of opposition is leads to legislative acts, that are not satisfying whole country.

  1. Regionalism in China and India. In India regionalism is accommodated through the federal ...

    It can be difficult to regulate all provinces. Chinas size and diversity contribute to regional forces that challenged its nationwide unity. Decentralized development within China has been linked to the large change in the public funding basis of health services.

  2. Does the focus upon Biblical thought, Republicanism, and Liberalism present a convincing case for ...

    The French Revolution, taking place just a decade after America's own, installed a Republic that to this day continues, thought through many trails (Gilbert and Large, 1991: 427). This is only one of many nations to have done so. In this sense, the case for the concept of American Exceptionalism begins to weaken.

  1. Canadian Health Care System

    and remote care and finally an increase in waiting times for diagnosis[8]. The Federal government has always been known as ?a defender of Medicare?, yet over the past decade they have worked to reduce their responsibility for the increased costs and changing expectations for this public system[9].

  2. Is Britain part of the old or new EU

    Coupled with the size of the Union, this means that new member states are limited in taking leading roles. Looking at states approaches towards European integration may provide a more precise classification of what is old and new Europe. Beyond Rumsfeld The term 'old Europe' was popularized by US secretary of state, Donald Rumsfeld in 2003.

  1. Has the effort of the Chinese central party-state to reassert control over thought work ...

    Based on such argument, let?s turn our eyes to China?s new ideology after the reform. Last but not least, ideology plays an all-important role in ruling a country. It is the core value of the Party and provides theoretical principle for the conduction of thought work and SSC programs.

  2. The Sierra Clubs Organizational Repertoires. Over the course of the 20th century, the ...

    He lived in the mountains for five years, keeping copious notes and writing journal entries, some of which he later published. Before long, Muir had become "the nation's archpriest of wild nature."16 Muir was a spiritual and solitary man, not inclined to confrontation, but as he saw the rapid destruction

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work