• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Summary of zero tolerance policing. ZTP acts to neutralise crime (Wilson and Boland, 1978) by targeting anti-social behaviour. Both America and England provide evidence of its success as it results in complete changes in lifestyles in populations

Extracts from this document...


Summary of Zero tolerance policing Zero tolerance policing originated in New York under Rudolph Guiliani and William Bratton (1994)(Silverman, 1999) as a response to the severe urban decay and extreme street crime experienced at the time. It is derived from Wilson and Kelling's (1982) 'broken windows theory' that the physical decline of a society has a direct effect on crime: Vandalism, begging, prostitution, 'squeegee merchants' all exist without intervention presenting the impression of public disinterest and encouraging more serious crime to flourish. Zero Tolerance policing (ZTP from now on) removes the police constraints and encourages the intervention of these misdemeanours, represses street crime and anti-social behaviour and sequentially reclaims control of public spaces for respectable members of society (Innes, 1999). Both Guiliani and Ray Mallon, of The Cleveland Constabulary, have proven the practical abilities of this type of policing in tackling high crime, but not without extensive criticisms, some of which I will discuss and challenge in this essay along with Pollard's (1997) ...read more.


Alongside these factors other large cities in America saw a similar decline in crime rates under different policing strategies (Pollard, 1997), accrediting the success to other factors. This is not evidence alone to question the credibility of zero tolerance policing, nor should the policies in place in other cities be brought into disrepute. It does not claim to be the only practically workable theory in reducing crime rates, but it does qualify. It certainly proved to be a quick resolution for New York's soaring crime and silences Dixons (2005)claims that fundamental differences in crime patterns mean it cannot be applied to different societies, as the policy has allowed transfer in a number of European countries and Australia. The English success story was that of Ray Mallon reducing rates by 25% in Middlesbrough in 12 months. Nonetheless, is it just a short term fix? Lengthy application of the policy will sever community/police ties, raise tension and spark disorder, demonstrated by the inner city riots in the 1980's. ...read more.


The public are most concerned about falling victim to burglary, car theft or personal attack, even though the likelihood of it is quite low. Residents of Bankhill, an area that has recently fallen victim to physical demise regard "petty crime" (Walklate, 2007; 60) as the largest problem and are calling out for officials to act. Individuals that live in socially dilapidated areas are faced with low level crimes daily and forced inside for their own safety, but when these misdemeanours are addressed, intolerance to crime is identified resulting in a reduction in fear of more serious offences (Edwards, 2005). ZTP acts to neutralise crime (Wilson and Boland, 1978) by targeting anti-social behaviour. Both America and England provide evidence of its success as it results in complete changes in lifestyles in populations that were once delinquent and it does not end there(Bowling, 1997). The aggressive nature of the police will always cause dispute in a policy as radical as ZTP; this does not point to a flaw in the policy but a flaw in the individuals employed to implement it. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Criminology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Criminology essays

  1. Drugs and crime.

    a controlled drug or to allow premises you occupy or manage to be used for the smoking or use of drugs. As can be seen, selling, producing or using some drugs are in themselves acts of criminality, as is driving under the influence of drugs.

  2. Domestic violence. The following essay will concentrate on patriarchal-terrorism (Gilchrist et al. 2004) meaning ...

    Justifying personal Violence: A Comparison of Rapists and the General Public. Victimology, 8 (3-4), 131-150. Bushman, B.J. (1997). 'Effects of alcohol on human aggression: validity of proposed explanations,' in D .Fuller, R. Dietrich, E Gottheil (Eds.). Recent Developments in Alcoholism: Alcohol and Violence,. New York: Plenum, pp-227-243. Bushman, B.J.

  1. An investigation into the extent of homophobic hate crime and the leaders involved in ...

    (The Teachers Report 2009) Therefore, it is crucial that action be taken to advise and inform schools of the seriousness of this problem and how best they can tackle it. Furthermore, only one quarter of homophobic hate crimes are reported to the police by LGB people and seven out of 10 individuals do not inform anyone that the incident occurred.

  2. The Effect of Line-up Instructions on Eyewitness Response.

    It is apparent from exploring literature in the field of eyewitness that an ongoing issue of concern is the instructions provided to the eyewitness prior to the line-up, and whether they may be considered 'biased or unbiased' (Clark, 2005). Largely, biased instructions are likely to suggest that a selection from

  1. Discuss the key features and changes in the history of crime and punishment in ...

    The police force however came under fire from criminals, local elites, and the public as it was deemed that the force was too expensive and had a major threat to people?s liberties. Throughout this time period the changes from earlier times were noticeably different.

  2. Explore how both sociology and social psychology can help us to understand anti-social behaviour

    which gives police the rights to disperse groups perceived to be likely to behave in an anti-social manner, and the introduction of ASBO?s which is used to restrict the behaviour of people with a record of anti-social behaviour through a court order (Millie, 2008).

  1. Would the legalization of drugs in America be a good thing?

    or Drug Abuse Resistance Education is used in an estimated eighty percent of school districts nationwide. The most recent statistics show that in the year 2000, approximately $9.7 million was spent on this program. President Obama requested $5.6 billion for drug treatment and prevention in 2011.

  2. Hate Crimes in America

    One more agency is the ?Bureau of Justice Statistics? (BJS), which is responsible for funding ?The National Crime Victimization Survey the primary source of information regarding criminal victimization nationally.? (?LCCR Education Fund, 2009?). ?Hate Crimes in America 2009? (The Leadership Conference 2009 p.1) Hate has a face, a human face.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work