• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The power of citizenship is probably best known by those who are denied it. Examine this statement with respect to the experience of Palestinians in Lebanon.

Extracts from this document...


Transfer-Encoding: chunked ?The power of citizenship is probably best known by those who are denied it.? Examine this statement with respect to the experience of Palestinians in Lebanon. In 1948 over 100,000 Palestinians fled from Israel to Lebanon following Nakba. In the present day this number has swelled to over 450,000, even more if those undocumented are included (UNWRA, 2015). They occupy over a dozen camps and are make up the biggest user of UNWRA resources. Their swelling numbers has put strain on aid resources whilst also souring their initial warm welcome with locals. Palestinian refugees in Lebanon live in poverty, in a society that discriminates and oppresses them. Citizenship is political tool that could have the power to change their abject position. Citizenship can be defined as ?an institution mediating rights between the subjects of politics and the polity to which these subjects belong? (Isin & Nyers, 2014, p. 1). This is a definition of great breadth. The relevant concept within this definition is the rights afforded by citizenship. It is these civil, political and social rights that are denied to many Palestinians in Lebanon (and its resulting ?power? for them). For Isin & Nyers the power of citizenship is similar to Arendt?s ?right to have rights?. ...read more.


(UNWRA, 2011) UNWRA is also the main provider of care as all Palestinians are denied access to Lebanese public health care as well as any forms of social security. (Shafie, 2007, pp. 12-13) In addition to this are property rights. Presidential Decree 11614 of January 1969, modified in April 2001 by Law No. 296, prohibits persons ?who not carry a citizenship issued by a recognised state? from owning property in Lebanon. This has severely limited any chance of social mobility for Palestinians and has essentially left them confined to crowded camps whose limits have not been expanded since 1948 but with at least 300,000 more inhabitants. Worsening this issue is de facto outlawing of construction materials in the camps which has left them in a state of severe disrepair. (Shafie, 2007, p. 13). This confinement is exacerbated by the limits on movement. Movement to and between refugee camps, are subject to strict security measures. The Lebanese army maintains checkpoints at the entrances to many of the camps. To top this off international travel documents and visas are difficult to procure. (Universal Periodic Review, 2015, p. 100) If Palestinians were afforded the rights of citizenship or that of a permanent resident they could enjoy the right of private ownership, free movement and avoid their increasing ghettoization. ...read more.


This would remove them from the damaging legal ambiguity, alleviate Lebanese fears of tawteen and allow Palestinians the opportunity as UNWRA coined it to ?get on with their lives?. Secondly there should be the fostering of Palestinian civil society and identity this would not only focus Palestinian political efforts but also ensure the enduring of the right of return. These recommendations would serve to ease pressure on both sides of the dilemma, with the power of the aforesaid citizenship serving to improve the lives of the hundreds of thousands of Palestinians in Lebanon. In conclusion it has been shown that the legal ambiguity of the Palestinians has led to a clear protection gap. This gap led to difficulties for the Palestinians due to the concept of reciprocity in Lebanese law, the enshrinement of the right of return in Arab consciousness and the fear of tawteen among the Lebanese political class and public. Some could argue that these problems are intransigent. The Palestinians are stuck in the impossible position of a hostile host nation with the aid of a powerless ?caretaker?. What could be the salve to these difficulties? It has been clearly demonstrated that the guarantor of rights in Lebanon is citizenship; Palestinians are feeling the power of its absence. Therefore the granting of citizenship in accordance with the recommendations above would have the power to lift the Palestinians to a level playing field as their rights are guaranteed by law. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree International Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree International Politics essays

  1. Does Liberalism best explain contemporary world politics?

    These agents had conflicting interests and the government, rightly or wrongly, for reasons of human rights, a very liberal cause, decided to favour the public and human rights pressure groups over big business and forced UK companies to pull out of Burma.

  2. "Forced Labour in Burma: An assessment of procedures and strategies for the international protection ...

    The military forces people to work from particular ethnic minorities. These include the Karen, Mon, Shan, Rohingya, Karenni, and Chin people which make up the one third of the Burmese population. The Rohingya minority are in their majority Muslims. This has been argued is the reason why the Burmese government continues to demand forced labour from them.

  1. Why Is the Middle East a Conflict Area?

    There is little that the United States can do to rescue the Palestinians from their flawed leaders as long as they continue down the road of violence. Arafat has had ample time to prove himself as a true partner for peace, but he has failed to do so.

  2. Human Rights materials - outline of the Human Rights Act and quotes and ...

    ---- Jimmy Carter, Former President of the United States - The only way to make sure people you agree with can speak is to support the rights of people you don't agree with--- Eleanor Holmes Norton, US Congressional Delegate Advantage: 1.

  1. Critically examine the relationship between war and underdevelopment

    and non-combatants, and whether or not such effects could be counterbalanced or stopped, is not accurately understood. (Keen, 2006). The relationship between war and underdevelopment There exist a variety of published works by historians on the economic costs and benefits (such as technological and organizational development)

  2. Justification for Oppression

    force my righteousness upon you...for your own sake"; thus trying to paint themselves as saviors and champions of truth in order to cover up their true intentions of obtaining power, glory and wealth. In his article, Makau touches on the mentality of Imperialism when he says'...The first dimension of the prism depicts a savage and evokes images of barbarism.

  1. September 11

    The "original contract" present in the moral state, Kant believed, would carry over to the international system of states.6 He believed the international system of states, despite the lack of government ever present in the international system, would become a transparent representation of the new moral civil society within the

  2. Should the United States Get Involved with Problems in the Middle East?

    Two alternatives were open to Muslims in practice. One was to retreat into the fortress of Muslim identity and reject the West. Numberless groups and organizations have chosen that course, from the Muslim Brotherhood to Hamas and Islamic Jihad and Hizballah today, as well as the Taliban and their proxy, Osama bin Laden.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work