• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"This house believes that the principles of sustainability cannot be adequately implemented within the property industry of market- led, democratic Western societies."

Extracts from this document...


"This house believes that the principles of sustainability cannot be adequately implemented within the property industry of market- led, democratic Western societies." (Argument against the motion) When attempting to argue the case in favour of sustainable practice in commercial buildings, it is important to ascertain exactly what is meant by the terms used in the question. The definition of a commercial building is not quite as straightforward as one would think. It is commonly agreed that they are certainly not residential. The Commercial Buildings Energy Consumption Survey, (CBECS) an information source of energy statistics for the US Government, defined a commercial building as "an enclosed structure with more than 50% of its floor space devoted to activities that are neither residential, industrial, nor agricultural." (Energy Information Administration, 2004). Other sources, however, define commercial buildings as anything other than residential, including industrial, contradicting the CBECS, saying commercial buildings should be defined as any building other than residential including those "constructed for industrial or public purposes." (US Department of Housing and Urban Development, 2004) For the purposes of this debate, we shall regard the definition of commercial buildings to lean more towards the former definition: we are referring to those structures that are not residential, industrial or municipal buildings, such as those used for offices and retail purposes. The principles of sustainability in this context are very broad in their scope and thus difficult to define. The United Nations defined sustainable development as "...development which meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs." (UN World Commission, 1987). The Stationery Office outlined four basic objectives in light of the United Nations' core definition: First, social progress which recognises the needs of all in society must be met; second, the environment must be protected; third, natural resources must be used prudently; and finally, economic growth and employment must be maintained at high and stable levels. ...read more.


Bluewater also provides a number of services aimed at families, including baby care rooms, baby changing facilities, bottle warming facilities and a private mothers' feeding room. All of the centre's dining areas have been designed for pushchair access and all contain high chairs. Pushchairs can be obtained free of charge from the concierge desk and there is a fully staffed cr�che and designated 'kids village' where children can be supervised while they play and learn (ibid). The priority of social interaction is also reflected in a range of activities that are available for both adults and children. These include fishing, golf, cycling, boating, cinemas and a discovery trail sponsored by a major clothing manufacturer. Blue water also houses a unique quiet room available to guests, hosts and employees to reflect, pray or meditate and a community room has been implemented for non-profit groups such as schools and charities to hold meetings or give presentations free of charge (ibid.). By contrast, Canary Wharf is a prestigious 35-hectare commercial and residential development in the East London Borough of Tower Hamlets. It comprises 23 office buildings with a floor area totalling 1,200 million square metres. In design terms, the development encourages social interaction by means of its three malls and leisure facilities which total 56,000 square metres. In addition the development has nine hectares of landscaped open space for its residents to enjoy ('http://www.canarywharf.com/mainFrm1.asp?strSelectedArea=Lifestyle'). The Canary Wharf Group (CWG) has established a Community Outreach Programme aimed at encouraging contact and involvement with the local community, authorities and support agencies through twenty-four social and environmental targets met between July 2003 and June 2004. These focus on both present-day and future social sustainability by aiming to promote the accessibility of Canary Wharf to the local community and to enhance education levels in the Borough. Specifically, the measures have included the formation of a football academy, local gymnastics club and hurdling squad, the appointment of a CWG local sports development officer and sponsorship of the local football league. ...read more.


All three factors carry their own importance, and contribute to the theory of sustainability in such a way that it would be redundant if one of the Triple Bottom Line was excluded. In today's Western society, a cynical but perhaps realistic view would suggest that the inclination to implement sustainable practice in commercial buildings is fairly low primarily because many believe it is not economically viable. Therefore the task in hand is perhaps to focus on the education of the economic benefit of sustainable building, as this seems to be a key inhibitor of progress in the field. There seems to be confusion and lack of clarity of peoples understanding of the economic aspect of sustainability, while the environmental and social issues enjoy widespread consensus of their benefits. Future legislation may make sustainability in commercial buildings necessary rather than optional, and perhaps such legislation is required to fulfil the benefits and requirement sustainable commercial buildings have to offer. Social, as well as Government pressure may also speed up the process of implementation. Many companies, such as those involved with Canary Wharf, under the pressure of measurements such as BREEAM, have gained considerably in terms of image from focusing on social sustainability. Again, education is a key factor here as growing awareness of commercial sustainability will force developers and occupiers to satisfy public demand. Luckily, while the implementation of commercial sustainability has been relatively low thus far, the notions of sustainability are backed internationally as shown at the Rio Earth Summit in 1992. The environmental problems are ongoing and remain a strong motivation for action, and as new technology and ideas develop, sustainable commercial building should flourish. 1 For example, a survey of many investors and their advisers has revealed that individuals feel committed to environmental improvement but look to the UK government to take a regulatory lead (Parnell and Sayce, 1999). Group Seminar Paper: Sustainable European Built Environment John Kordas, Shahan Lall, Oliver Morton and Edward O'Brien 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human & Social Geography section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human & Social Geography essays

  1. What is meant by the term social construction of childhood

    in their home ground like a pet, and even the wealthiest of children were treated like paupers, their bodies sewn into sacks and thrown into common graves6. Towards the end of the eighteenth century, the view that children should be treated like adults started to change and they now began to be seen as innocent and in need of protection.

  2. Explain the view that shopping is about both lifestyle and need.

    However, these retail outlets do not cater for everyone, and as a result help to further increase the divide between those who are able to consume effectively and those who are not. Only those who are mobile, have transport and enough disposable income are able to shop there, therefore excluding

  1. Discuss the impact of the Haiti Earthquake on the environment and discuss the effectiveness ...

    The plate boundary is mainly dominated by a left- lateral strike slip motion and compression, and accommodates about 20 mm/y slip, with the Caribbean plate moving eastward with respect to the North America plate. The Earthquake struck 5km (10 miles)

  2. Compare and contrast Buchanan and Mondermans approaches to the production of order in public ...

    Monderman believes that if you give motorists more responsibility for their actions rather than forcing strict regulations upon them, it would have a better effect. Furthermore, Monderman came up with the idea of the 'naked street'. It promotes the concept that pedestrians and motorists will naturally know how to

  1. Examine the view that developing societies can, and should, follow a path to development ...

    According to modernization theory the main obstacles to growth are internal factors such as a society?s values and tradition which will make it difficult for the transformation needed to evolve and join the global process of interconnectedness. Also there is no alternative to development because of capitalism expanding force and

  2. I have chosen to discuss Wokings Italian community, as it directly relates to my ...

    These days intercultural understanding? is a statutory component of the National Curriculum and is absorbed under the umbrella of Modern Foreign Languages and Citizenship. These promote the following ideals in children: 1. Tolerance: openness to others; curiosity; respect, a willingness to listen and learn (Walzer 1997: 11).

  1. Experiences of Life as an Immigrant. Cross-cultural analysis of Eva Hoffman "Lost in Translation"

    Tensions generated between individual and within individuals As I mentioned before, the whole book is a tour of mixed feelings, emotions and tensions which affect Eva during her exile in Canada. I think it is really important to focus on the tensions that Eva faces above all during the first period in her new life.

  2. In the aftermath of the devastating earthquake in January of 2010, Haiti (already among ...

    The public is viewed as a passive receptor of care, and their ability to contribute to their own recovery is seldom acknowledged. In the accounts of the medical delegation from Stanford, the only Haitians mentioned are the ?minimal local law enforcement,? who are then assisted by the U.S.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work