Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7

To what extent, if any, do feminist ethics improve upon traditional ethical theories?

Extracts from this essay...

Introduction

To what extent, if any, do feminist ethics improve upon traditional ethical theories? Virginia Woolf wrote about medicine 'it would seem is not sexless; she is a man, a father, and infected too'(Woolf 1938).1 This in many ways sums a feminist approach, both to medicine, and to the wider spheres of life. A central view of feminism is that women are oppressed. The male-domination of society has left women 'systematically subordinated' by 'a system which is so familiar, so entrenched in our habits... that it is possible not to notice them at all'.2 Sherwin draws together the oppression of women with that of other groups, providing a broad interpretation of feminism as being a challenge to the domination of women, alongside other subjugated groups; the 'goal of feminism is to pursue the changes necessary to accomplish [change in society]'3 The questioned posed asks if the input of feminist ideas into medicine has improved on traditional ethical theories. A conclusion cannot be drawn without an understanding of some of the issues and theories within 'feminist ethics' and this is where this paper will start. Areas of overlap and argument can be can be identified, both between proponents of feminist ethics itself and between feminist ethics and traditional theories. These will be discussed before drawing together a conclusion as to the impact of feminist ethical ideas on the practice of 'medical ethics'. Feminist arguments in moral thinking are not a recent phenomenon; as long ago as the 18th century, Mary Wollstonecraft commented on a link between the perceived feminine virtues of docility and gentleness and the subjugation of the female sex.4 This was in response to the notions espoused by the notable intellectuals of the time(many of whom praised these same feminine virtues): that

Middle

within different moral domains.16 Feminist ethics can be characterised as aiming to direct ethical debate and action towards a model encompassing the 'different voices' of female experience. It challenges ideas of moral autonomy and guidance by the strict application of rules or principles, be they of Utilitarian or Deontological origin. Feminist ethics argues for the importance of context and narrative in deciding about the ethical dilemmas facing individuals, factors that Gilligan identified as being especially salient to women. It recognises that people are partial to those with whom they have a relationship whilst allowing for the fact that in some situations it is not always possible to act on that partiality. Real-life ethical dilemmas do not always fit neatly into the principles of rule-based philosophical theories and the context of a 'dilemma' can provide certain clues to their resolution. Proponents of feminist ethics such as those identified in the 'ethics of care' accept that understanding some degree of context is required in the application of traditional ethics. However, for example in Kantian theory, this is only to the extent that it allows the subsequent application of a principle that will be generalisable to all other similar circumstances. Thus the rules on truth-telling and maintaining a confidentiality will be consistent, once a maxim has been identified.17 In Utilitarian terms, the balancing of utilities for all those involved or affected by a set of circumstances, although context specific, do not allow for the fact that the relationships between the individuals involved will vary. No extra 'weight' or utility is given in respect of those partial relationships and so the resolution of a 'dilemma' can only be distorted.18 General criticisms of traditional theories as applied to medical ethics, from a feminist perspective focus around the negation of, or inadequate emphasis on, contexual relationships.

Conclusion

relational view of moral agents'.28 Baier views the best model of a moral community as one which is based on co-operation between men and women, justice and care. Gilligan asks for a 'marriage' of established principles and articulations of female insights. It is women who are likely to drive this synergy of moral thinking as they are aware of the need for communication and exchange. Feminism challenges the focus on autonomy, impartiality and the universality of principles without adequate regard to attachments and context. Partiality to others is not morally bad and is a feature of human society so that the traditional indifference to the special needs of others is incompatible with ethical action. The 'care' perspective is especially pertinent to health care contexts where the application of general rules cannot provide guidance in all contexts. However, society cannot function without some rules and the combination of approaches to ethical debate in medicine is likely to produce the most benefit. Cook argues that women's concerns can be addressed through appeal to the four principles.29 Importantly, they allow feminists to advance their theories in the language of philosophical debate; perhaps this is the way towards Gilligan's 'marriage' of ethical theories. She states that moral maturity involves the ability to use perspectives of both justice and care. Green emphasises that feminists cannot disregard reason and justice, and traditional theories cannot afford to ignore feminist orientations. Feminist ethics do improve upon traditional foundations but not to the extent that they can replace them. The future of feminist ethics appears to be closely tied to principle-based theories and the perceptions of Baier's 'moral world' will be enhanced by the incorporation of such theories; the whole is likely to be greater than the sum of the two parts.

The above preview is unformatted text

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • Over 150,000 essays available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Over 180,000 student essays
  • Every subject and level covered
  • Thousands of essays marked by teachers

Related University Degree Religion in Society

  1. Ethnography - A Christian Youth Group

    She was brave and we admired her for that..." At approximately nine o'clock in the evening, after having heard the first few talks of the weekend, it is "dinner time". "Team Leaders" will call out "sleep groups" of up to six youngsters who will be picked up by a "sleep group sponsor".

  2. To what extent are individual soldiers morally responsible for the protection of civilians during ...

    Obviously the distinction between combatants and non-combatants cannot always be made clearly.2 Not all civilians, for example munitions workers, could be considered to be absolute non-combatants, for example. However, for the purposes of this essay I will make my distinction between civilians and soldiers.

  1. "What Is A 'Moral Panic'? What Does This Tell Us About Crime And Criminality? ...

    one of the two boys had rented it prior to the murder. However, it was revealed soon after that neither child had actually seen the film. Nevertheless, the scare mongering press did not stop there. Stories continued to be published about the film of how 'sick' and 'evil' it was,

  2. Ethical and Legal Aspects of Health and Social Care.

    Some argue that its never ethically acceptable because it violates the right to autonomy and independence but others believe that sometimes it is necessary when working with those who are vulnerable or in danger of harming themselves or others. This relates to euthanasia because this is saying that the patient

  1. Can we Predict Moral Behaviour? It is Kohlberg's stage theory of moral development which ...

    The children were asked who should get the proceeds from the sale of the pictures. Damon found a clear developmental progression on the basis of the children's answers, from awarding the money to them at age four simply because they want it, , to allocating the money at age eight onwards considering the social goals of the group.

  2. How much and in what ways has 9/11 influenced public perceptions and the self ...

    and highlighted the difficulties involved in being a Muslim in the West. Ideally, Muslims would be able to maintain their faith whilst also benefiting from western influences. Their faith should give them the strength to cope with the western world to 'confront the challenges of their society'. (Ramadan, 2004, P127).

  1. Is the influence of religion in western society declining? Can we reasonably measure its ...

    Reference List * Ballis, P & Bouma, G 1999, Religion in an Age of Change, Christian Research Association, Kew. * Bellah, R 1967, Civil Religion in America, Daedalus. * Bentley, P & Hughes, P 1998, Australian Life and the Christian Faith - Facts and Figures, Christian Research Association, Kew.

  2. What is 'moral panic'? What does the concept tell us about crime and criminality? ...

    Twelve students and a teacher were killed, accompanied by the suicide of the two teenage killers.

  • Over 180,000 essays
    written by students
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to write
    your own great essays

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.