• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Women's imprisonment in England and Wales at the end of the twentieth Century is: Excessively punitive; totally inappropriate to the needs of women being sent to prison; and ripe for abolition in its present form"(Carlen 1998)

Extracts from this document...


"Women's imprisonment in England and Wales at the end of the twentieth Century is: Excessively punitive; totally inappropriate to the needs of women being sent to prison; and ripe for abolition in its present form" (Carlen 1998) Prison is inappropriate to the needs of women. There is a need for women prisoners to be regarded differently to their male counterparts due to their roles, reactions and stress caused as a result of the separation from their children. This is an important area to address as it is a very real and immanent problem for nearly two thirds of incarcerated women 1. This is exasperated further by the fact that only one quarter of these children are looked after by their father or their mothers current partner (HM Chief Inspector of Prisons 1997). These is a contrasting picture to that which faces imprisoned fathers as 90 per cent of these and have the peace of mind that their children are being looked after by their mothers or by their current partner (HM Chief Inspector of Prisons 1997). This highlights the plight of incarcerated mothers whose concern is not only with separation with her children but also with how they will be cared for (Ward and Kaussebaum 1965) and one of the many differences between incarcerating women as oppose to men. ...read more.


Simple alterations and achieving consistent standards across all prisons would ensure imprisonment would be a more humanistic experience. There were also frequent complaints about the regimes that the imprisoned women had to undertake as these failed to allow the mothers to develop their own methods of baby care (Devlin 1998; Carlen 1998, NACRO 1991). Dobash et al highlight that 'regimentation is the characteristic feature...life in these unit is as regulated for the babies as it is for the mothers' (Dobash et al 1986 p.198). This is a very negative aspect of the mother and baby units as such regimentation can reduce what little confidence some of the mothers already have in their abilities to cope with their babies outside prison (Carlen 1990). As a direct result of this, both in cases where the child is allowed to stay with the mother and those where the mother and child are separated, the woman is denied the right to be a mother to their child(ren). Should this be prohibited, therefore adding a further harrowing aspect to their imprisonment, or should this sanction remain the punishment that it is meant to be - the deprivation of liberty? Although we can see that the conditions are at least unfavourable, there are steps that could be taken to improve these. More worryingly perhaps is the lack of stimulation that the babies received and the long-term effects that this can have. ...read more.


It appears from the above that women who may be criminal are presumed to be mentally ill, if this was so it can be further presumed that officials believe that the best place for these women is prison. The Thematic Review (HM Chief Inspector of Prisons 1997) certainly acknowledge that custody is not the best setting for therapeutic work, even for those who are incarcerated and suffer from mental health problems as these can be 'worsened by the effects of imprisonment' (NACRO 1991). Therefore the inappropriateness of prisons as a form of punishment for women can be seen whichever way we choose to look at this problem 1 Nearly two thirds of the women interviewed in the Thematic Review were mothers with the majority having at least one child under the age of 16 (HM Chief Inspector of Prisons 1997). 2 Carried out by the Department of Health in November 1996, Inspection of facilities for mother and babies in prison. 3 This monitored the physical and psychological development of babies between one and eighteen months old who accompanied their mothers into mother-and-baby units compared with those of a similar age who were separated from their mothers and cared for by relatives or others. This research was carried out by Sussex university, commissioned by the Home Office 1 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Criminology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Criminology essays

  1. As prison populations rise to unprecedented levels, to what extent can it be argued ...

    Studies claim that a small increase in the prison population and longer custodial sentences can prevent colossal numbers of murders, assaults, thefts, burglaries and rapes that otherwise would be committed (Murray, 1997; in Jewkes, 2006, p41; Wooten, cited in Davis, 2003, p285).

  2. Domestic violence. The following essay will concentrate on patriarchal-terrorism (Gilchrist et al. 2004) meaning ...

    Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 15, 181-97. Guerra, N.G:, Huesmann, L.R. and Hanish, L. (1994). 'The role of normative beliefs in children's social behaviour,' in N. Eisenberg (Ed.). Social Development. Newbury Park, CA. Sage, pp. 140-58. Hague, G., Mullender, A., and Aris, R.

  1. Critically Analyse Imprisonment as a means of Punishment.

    the reconviction rate is rising and is currently representing over half of the prison population. This then leads to the question of whether imprisonment as a form of punishment is really working in this country based on these figures. Some of the purposes that imprisonment is supposed to serve can be highlighted to understand their importance.

  2. Is the British penal system effective? Most of the evidence points to prison not ...

    all letters going in and out of the prisons; this is just to make sure the letters did not contain any restricted items, such as drugs and money (Coyle, 2005). The effectiveness of prisons are not affected by the letter itself, however, if letters make a difference to a prisoners

  1. The prison system in England and Wales could reasonably be described as being in ...

    and the huge moral challenge that is involved in managing the penal system, it is difficult to classify the system as in a crisis, as all day to day running?s of the system are bound to encounter some form of trouble which shall have to be addressed and resolved.

  2. Imprisonment should only be used as a last resort due to its long-term negative ...

    there are portions of excellent work from within the prison service, in addressing drug addictions and treatment programs that are more accessible within prisons than communities. Yet, predominately prisoners problems anti-incarceration still exist post-incarceration and it is not clear whether these changes were caused due to prison or despite of it (Cole, 2005).

  1. Critically analyse the arguments for and against the controlled prescription of pharmaceutical heroin.

    The temptation to by heroin from drug dealers may trump their common sense. When in pain and desperate people may do things they may not normally do. So if they did decide to buy heroin from ma drug dealer, it would most likely be an impure substance.

  2. Perceptions of wrongful convictions amongst Americans working in the criminal justice system.

    time a convicted criminal will spend in prison ? especially for those individuals convicted of drugrelated crimes (Clear 1994). Prisons and jails have been built and expanded at a record pace in order to accommodate those criminals who are caught by the police and sentenced by judges (Currie 1985).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work