• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Youth Workers - Agents of social change or agents of social control?"

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Youth Workers - Agents of social change or agents of social control?" Are youth workers agents of social change or agents of social control? That is the question that I am hoping to answer in this piece. Here you will see an introduction and brief explanation of both social change and social control. I will be using quotes and information from various books and theorists. I hope to give you a brief history and definition of what youth work is. From reading the information on social change and social control, as well as what is said about youth work, I hope that you have a clear understanding of each. I will be arguing my points based on the three key policy reports. The Albemarle Report, the Milson-Fairbairn Report, and the Thompson Report. I will be making specific references to each report and arguing whether each report feels that youth workers are agents of social change or agents of social control. Finally I will be making my own conscious decision on whether I think that youth workers are agents of social change or agents of social control and I will be referring to the three reports to back up my decision. The debate about whether youth workers are agents of social change or social control is a very complex one. But first, what is social change and social control? Social control is the processes of informal social control and formal social control of deviant behaviour which falls beyond the bounds set by social norms. ...read more.

Middle

The very fact that the youth were described as upsetting the natural 'order' of things was very clear in that Albemarle wanted the youth workers to be agents of social control. The raw foundation for youth work was introduced in the Albemarle Report. The four principle recommendations really got the ball rolling. However, one of these recommendations states that the Minister of Education should take the steps to increase the exiting force of full time leaders. What this is saying is that youth workers should lead my force and not through understanding, empathy trust etc. This is summed up by the way that an army graduate was straight away qualified as a youth leader. That whole idea boils down to one simple aspect, discipline. If a young person is disciplined then it will fulfil the role that society expects from them. The argument above states that the Albemarle Report quite obviously veers towards youth workers being agents of social control, however, it recognises that a change is needed. A contrasting view comes from the Milson-Fairbairn Report. This report was sceptical of the extent to which community schools could represent the full range of community interests. The aim of the report reads, " It is the critical involvement of young people in a society which seeks to be compassionate and participant." (Lecture Pack). The report acknowledges that there have been significant changes since the Albemarle Report and there are still debates concerning many issues. ...read more.

Conclusion

His report is central to participation and citizenship. The participation coming from both the young people and the youth workers. After looking extensively at the three reports I don't believe that youth workers can be either 'just' agents of social control or 'just' agents of social change. I feel that at the beginning of youth work, yes, there was an added emphasis on youth workers being agents of social control, however, as time has progressed and the youth have grown and different generations have come through I feel that we have passed the stage of youth workers being agents of one or the other. There is an element of youth workers being agents of both. My argument for this is that there will always be expectations from society and there will always be a structure, however hidden it may be, but there is also the need to always try and meet the needs and expectations of the young people. It has been this diversity that has helped the youth service grow and become as big as it now is. The emphasis now is to try to help the young people to participate and have a more active role in society while acknowledging that there are expectations and rules and discipline to be followed. Finally, I feel that overall youth workers should be agents of social control AND agents of social change. This is to help the youth workers be as effective as possible and to facilitate the young people to the greatest of their ability. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Social Work section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Social Work essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Individual Development and Change

    3 star(s)

    Within different cultural settings attachment varies. In Germany for example, "German mothers value and promote early independence and regard avoidant attachment as the ideal, seeing the 'securely' attached child as 'spoiled'" (Grossman et al; 1985). "Theories of attachment appear to be central to social work practice with children and families.

  2. Critically consider the argument for and against social work practice being based on research ...

    role theory plays in practice, and by so doing enhances the prestige of social work. EBP encourages and promotes training thereby making practitioners to be more efficient in their practice (seeDoH2000b), by asking practitioners to update their knowledge and make it up to date.

  1. Nepotism - research project

    that they employed their own relatives in violation of the Public Service Act. One of the dictates of the Act (p.9), "where during an employment/selection/interview process it appears that there is a direct relationship between the applicant and a member of the selection panel, the latter should recuse himself/herself from such process".

  2. Juvenile Delinquency

    Family settings dysfunctional characterized by conflict, inadequate parental control, integration, and premature autonomy are closely associated with juvenile delinquency. Families that have few opportunities for legitimate employment and face a higher risk of social exclusion are overrepresented among offenders for the children.

  1. Youth work and youth workers can play a central role in integrating young people ...

    the youth parliaments have allowed young people a voice in which to connect with the governing bodies and more importantly with those making the decisions that affect young peoples lives. An example of a this is the BKYP, Bradford-Keighley Youth Parliament.

  2. A Social Worker's role is described as being both an agent of social control ...

    A social worker's role is therefore complex and multifaceted. Social workers can provide further assistance to their clients on the grounds of hardship, family needs and so on. This is one way in which they act as agents of social control.

  1. Domestic Violence

    Leo, John (1994) Is it a war against women? U.S. News & World Report, July 11, 1994. Loring, M. T. and Smith, R. W. (1994) Health care barriers and interventions for battered women. Public Health Reports 1994;109(3):322-329. Cited in Gibson-Howell, Joan C.

  2. Assessment is particularly important as it creates the foundations of a social workers work ...

    One of the most common assessment social workers will deal with is risk assessment. Risk assessment is carried out when the likelihood of something negative happening or not happening to a child is uncertain (Buckley, Horwath & Whelan, 2006). This kind of assessment is carried out for groups of people

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work