• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Critical Appraisal of a Published Piece of Research Related to Practice. Patient Dignity in an Acute Hospital Setting, by Dr. Lesley Baillie (2008)

Extracts from this document...


A Critical Appraisal of a Published Piece of Research Related to Practice For this assignment the author has been asked to critically appraise a published piece of research related to practice. For the purposes of this work, a case study entitled ?Patient Dignity in an Acute Hospital Setting,? by Dr. Lesley Baillie (2008) has been used. In justifying Baillie?s credibility as an author and as an experienced researcher, the author established she is a reader in healthcare at the University of Bedfordshire for the Institute for Health Research and she has been a trained acute nurse for the past 32 years. She is an author in her own right and has contributed to a number of other publications. Baillie completed her PhD on Patient Dignity in 2007. Between 2007?2009 Dr.Baillie was a consultant to the Royal College of Nursing?s ?Dignity at the Heart of Everything we do? campaign (Johnson, 2011). In order to maintain some structure to the essay, the author chose to use the ?Critical Appraisal Skills Programme? (CASP). CASP is an assessment tool that has been developed for those unfamiliar with qualitative research (PHRU, 2006). The programme aims to develop skills and make sense of research evidence, which in turn enables us as professionals to put knowledge into practice. The aim of a critical appraisal is to extract the following information; is it of any interest? Why and how was it done? What has it found? What were the implications and what else was of interest? (Crombie,1996). Critical appraisal is the process of assessing and interpreting evidence by systematically considering validity, results and relevance (www.evidence-based-medicine.co.uk, 2010). The author Baillie (2008) sets out in the abstract her objectives for the case study. ...read more.


The advantage to semi-structured questions is that they can be asked in what appears to be general conversation, which encourages two-way conversation and therefore the researcher can gain additional information. A disadvantage can be that, questions may be slightly different for each participant dependant on how the ?conversation? evolves. Patton (1987) outlined that in qualitative interviews questions should be clear to the interviewee, open-ended, neutral and sensitive. He then went on to suggest various types of questions that should be asked. These included experiences or behaviour, values, on knowledge, on feelings, on opinions and demographical or background details. Baillie in her (2008) case study considered the relationship between herself and the participants and how she could create the most natural and relaxed conditions, ensuring the participants acted ordinarily and without oppression. By wearing a nurse?s uniform in the ward environment, she was able to develop relationships both with the patients and the staff whilst working shifts and prior to any collection of data. Baillie (2008) in recognition of researcher bias maintained a researcher?s diary with reflective observations. Reflexivity is an important self- evaluating tool, as it identifies the researcher?s own values, prejudice?s and behaviour in any given situation and the interpretation of responses (Parahoo 2006). Following her earlier findings, Baillie (2008) later discussed them with the participants to verify they were credible. The Data collected throughout the study was analysed manually using a framework approach, which is primarily used in health care settings. It is a process, which is flexible in allowing analysis during and also at the conclusion of data collection. By listening to audiotapes and reading transcripts of field notes, the researcher was able to absorb the data and become aware of key ideas and recurrent themes (Ritchie and Spencer, 1994). ...read more.


The close proximity of beds with only curtains to maintain privacy was also an issue due to the fact that other patients on the ward could hear what was being said between the staff members and the patient. The attitudes of staff also had an effect on patients? dignity. Half the patients interviewed described how one member of staff had a curt manner, which could be interpreted as being ?off handed? or even rude. The most important aspect of maintaining patient dignity was privacy, i.e. pulling curtains around beds and avoiding bodily exposure. All the ward staff, five of the six senior nurses and half the patients that were interviewed, agreed and confirmed this. As healthcare professionals we are all morally bound to upholding patient dignity. We are regulated by the Nursing Midwifery Council (NMC, 2008) code of conduct, but the overriding principles of dignity, humanity and equality are legislated for under the Human Rights Act 1998 and the Equality Act 2010, (Jackson, 2011). Conclusion In 2010 the Care Quality Commission (CQC) carried out their annual survey. More than 66,000 patients who were discharged between June and August of that year from 161 acute and specialist trusts took part. Approximately 2,000 (3%) of these patients revealed they were not treated with dignity and respect whilst in hospital and a further 12,000 (18%) said they had been treated with dignity and respect ?sometimes? but not always. This survey showed there had been no improvement since 2002 (Stephenson, 2011). Although steps are being taken to educate healthcare professionals regarding patient dignity, it never the less remains an important issue at the core of NHS values. Dignity remains an often-overused phrase but underperformed action within the healthcare environment. ?Patient dignity? is a right, not a concession that health care professionals can hand out when it best suits them. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Nursing section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Nursing essays

  1. Law and Ethics in Nursing. The aim of this assignment is to reflect ...

    By engaging in reflection it can change your way of thinking by becoming more self aware and by using a model of reflection has helped me through the incident and analyse the situation in more detail. This assignment helped raise awareness of the laws in place and ethical issues that

  2. The aim of this essay is to critically evaluate the bio-psycho-social perspectives and influences ...

    Johns, (2002), believes that theoretical models may direct the nurse rather than allowing expertise and experience to guide them. Atkins and Murphy, (1994), question that experience alone is not enough, and support the position that nurses need models to guide practice.

  1. The aim of this essay is to look at how infection control and the ...

    Report from BBC news (2005) stated that about 100,000 get infected with MRSA each year when they get admitted into hospital. The only way health care workers can reduce this infection is; a good hand washing between patients, a good standard hygiene in hospital and patients with MRSA treated in a highly isolated as much as possible.

  2. My chosen skill is to assist the patients to feed and drink. I ...

    Nurses need to allow time with the patients to support them in choosing the menu, respecting the patient's choices but also being attentive with the patient's individual health needs. To ensure effective communication with patients with special needs D'Wynter (2006)

  1. Nursing Case Study

    The change from maladaptive/adaptive coping can restore any lost self-confidence and self-esteem. (Lyttle 1991). The pack allows for self-discovery in the client. The pack is underpinned with theoretical ideas lent from behaviour and Cognitive therapy. Behavioural therapy focuses on changing specific actions and uses several techniques to decreases or stop unwanted behavior.

  2. a critique of qualitative study regarding diabetes treatment

    The article uses direct quotes from patients interviewed and this leads us to the conclusion that audiotapes were used during the interviewing process. The researcher however, fails to discuss their role in analysing the data. This can lead to untrue results and data analysis as the researcher could have chosen

  1. Teamwork is an integral part of Accident and Emergency care and if it is ...

    As the professionals will be focused towards that particular patient. Patients are individuals with unique needs that should be addressed through careful assessment and with the use of therapeutic communication (Mallett, J & Dougherty, 2000). Good communication can prevent crises in the workplace and can remove many irritations that lead to stress, especially where these are due to misunderstanding (Skinner,1998).

  2. Nursing case study. The aspect selected is pressure area care and nursing models, knowledge, ...

    HCAs do the same, and sometimes the notes are confused and not clear, with lots of abbreviations. NMC (2007) standard for record keeping says that records should not include abbreviations, be recorded using terms that the patient or client can easily understand, be recorded clearly and in such a manner

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work