• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A critical review on the text by Thomas Szasz; Cruel Compassion: Psychiatric Control of Society's Unwanted, and also of the text, 'The Myth of Mental Illnesses.

Extracts from this document...


Module Title: Issues in Psychology Critical Analysis: Should people with psychological problems be hospitalised against their will? The following is a critical review on the text by Thomas Szasz; Cruel Compassion: Psychiatric Control of Society's Unwanted, and also of the text, 'The Myth of Mental Illnesses. In the text, 'Cruel Compassion', Thomas Szasz (1994) develops an argument that psychiatry is an exercise in social control, which allows society to remove from its midst and incarcerate people who are unwanted and dependent. Supporting this are the assumptions that mental illness does not exist and that psychiatric practice largely consists of coercion and control. This book is a recent instalment in Szasz's crusade against mental health care in its many guises, and in particular, against the use of cruelty and oppression in psychiatry. He says that the victims of psychiatry are bullied in many ways. They are hospitalized against their will, they are forced out of hospitals and into the streets when the state decides to deinstitutionalize them, and they are nearly always made to follow some kind of invasive treatment, ECT, lobotomy, or psychotropic drugs. Literature One could state that the above mentioned view does not allow for consideration of the anguish and disability suffered by the mentally ill or the distress and despair which this creates in their families. Instead, Szasz gives an account of how a young person might be diagnosed as schizophrenic as a way of rationalising his "uselessness" and "idleness," which bears no relation to current concepts of schizophrenia and which will seem frankly absurd to many people with direct experience of this illness. ...read more.


Moreover, why not address the issue of psychiatric 'help', and ask whether mentally ill people who break the law could not be offered drugs, counselling, or even temporary hospitalization? One does not need to share Szasz' philosophical and political views in order to share his indignation at the treatment meted out to those diagnosed as mentally ill, nor to recognize our tendency to 'store' away those we cannot interact with. This leads to the question whether the political and philosophical views in question do form an important part of Szasz' arguments. In particular, his claim that there is no such thing as mental illness (undefended in this book) is not needed to conclude that schizophrenia (the condition he focuses on) is an unauthentic category, or that being diagnosed as mentally ill does not justify having one's liberty taken away. Szasz believes that giving some people power over others is commonly justified in the name of "compassion." In the article 'The Inhumanity of "Compassionate" Compulsion' (Reviewed by Jim Powell, J. November 1995), it is demonstrated by Szasz that "compassion" is a cover for oppression. He provides shocking historical perspective on the inhumanity of compulsion. He tells how 18th century English "reformers" like Jeremy Bentham promoted rounding up indigent people in "poor houses," so they would be out of sight and under control. Szasz talks about supposedly benevolent 19th century psychiatrists who urged that epileptics be forced into "therapeutic communities." ...read more.


His own good, either physical or moral, is not sufficient warranty." (Mill 1859, quoted in Szasz 1971, pp 349-340). Mill made an exception for those without the full use of their reason but Szasz does not do likewise. According to Szasz (1978), it is a precondition of a free society that we do not force help on one another. We must be free to make our own choices and decide what is in our own best interest. In a society pledged to the advancement of individual freedom and responsibility, the State, the family and the medical profession must restrict themselves to offering help. He goes on to say that the law should prevent them forcing help on unwilling people. However, he does not say that compulsory psychiatry is always harmful to the patient. His basic case is that it is unable to coexist with a free society. He says, in fact, that some increase in liberty gained by outlawing compulsion, might be at the cost of the impaired health or even death of some people who, he says, make themselves ill, or who want to kill themselves. He says that freedom, to a certain extent, entails the right to make the 'wrong' choice. William Blackstone (1723-1780) in his Commentaries on the Laws of England, wrote that: "It was the doctrine of our ancient law, that persons deprived of their reason might be confined till they recovered their senses." There are two long established reasons for the legitimate use of compulsion against mad people: 1. the protection of society 2. compassion for the mad person. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Healthcare section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Healthcare essays

  1. Mama Might Be Better Off Dead: Book Review.

    in their early stages, are often left untreated, thus resulting in the further deterioration of patients' health. Anecdotal evidence cited by Abraham's includes life threatening cases such as the kidney failure of Robert Banes (28) or the infection of Mrs.

  2. Interprofessional working in mental health

    to dis-empower the service user, because if the workers feel they are having a 'tug-of-war over this intangible 'power' the focus of the interaction between all parties e.g. meeting the needs of the service user is lost. (Payne M 1996 p41)

  1. What are the main challenges faced by mature students studying Healthcare courses in Higher ...

    However, this process again needs skilful application in the recognition of phrases, incidents or types of behaviour specific to the environment under investigation. (Mays & Pope 2000) which brings us back to the concept of reflexivity. As we are not aware of the background or expertise in the field of

  2. MSc/ Postgraduate Diploma in Forensic Mental Health Studies

    the MHA a constable will carefully consider the following criteria to satisfy the law and best practice. 1. A Public Place- this is where the public has access and not private premises. 2. Evidence of Mental Disorder- the officer should note what is said and done by the person, together with their appearance and demeanour.

  1. Drug Abuse In Contemporary Society.

    Employing the term crack tended to make the drug seem more desirable to youngsters who wanted to impress their peers. The stages described represent the worst case; many drugs do not make it past the early stages. Epidemic use (Stage 1)

  2. Care versus Control: make a critical analysis of the debate, locating it in terms ...

    health problems and protection of the patients civil and human rights (Hale, 2003). The GSCC provides a Code of Practice which Social Workers should work within. Statements 1,3 and 4 out of only 6 statements are particularly relevant to the tensions AMHP face when considering compulsory admission. These include: 1.

  1. Review of Factors Influencing Successful Patient Education in a Rehab Unit for Spinal Cord ...

    and its associated implications were analysed thoroughly. The gaps such as conflicting information, improper knowledge and heavy work load, lack of awareness, self-efficacy, and self-esteem were identified by using gap analysis theory. The fundamental gap that has been identified is the lack of communication between spinal unit and community team.

  2. Open University. What would be the benefits and drawbacks for Bronwyn, whose story was ...

    However, in the next breath she is asking why the kids or Rob don?t help her around the house, or cleans the kitchen floor themselves. Rob and the kids clearly do not notice that Bronwyn is experiencing mental distress. Because of the way Bronwyn is feeling it would probably be best to seek professional help.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work