• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critical appraisal

Extracts from this document...


Critical appraisal of article entitled: "Obesity in people with intellectual disabilities: the impact of nurse-led health screenings and health promotion services" Marshall et al 2003(p1). This assignment will be based on a critical appraisal of the before mentioned article. The appraisal will include discussion of the title, authors, and topic discussed. Also included will be comments on the structure of the article, the methodology used and the research findings, whilst discussing any ethical issues that need to be addressed. Finally, in conclusion I will summarize my findings. The title in an article is very important as it is this that first draws someone to read it, as Cormack (1996) states "it is extremely important for a research publication to have meaningful and non ambiguous title", (p382). He goes on to say "it is the title which clarifies the topic of the research being described and gives the potential reader an indication of the content",(p382). Although the title is long, it is felt that it needs to be in order to describe the research topic and the content of the article in brief. Therefore giving, as much information, at a glance as possible. The authors of the article are all in a position academically, clinically and professionally to research their chosen topic. Each author has a background qualification in learning disabilities and has experience in this field. ...read more.


Academically the aims of the study are important as the findings of the research will assist future researchers on this and similar topics and the findings will assist health care professionals that are involved in the care of clients that are overweight or obese and who also have intellectual disabilities. It could be argued here that the hypothesis is to prove that the necessary follow up of these individuals will not be undertaken, as in the introduction of the report it states that "the physical health and well-being of people with intellectual disabilities has not been promoted to the same extent as with non disabled people" (Marshall et al 2003, p2). Although the report itself reads more, like it wants to investigate and alter any negligent practice towards the clients than necessarily prove a hypothesis. It is not essential to formulate a hypothesis. (Ogier, 1998). Therefore I feel this particular article doesn't have a research hypothesis. The article is a mix between qualitative research, that is as identified by Ogier (1998) "research which paints a picture in words and aims to identify concepts and common themes" (p84) and quantitative research which is described by Ogier as "research in which the data is numerical and seeks to test hypothesis by statistical analysis of the data"(p84). The type of research study used within the study is descriptive research which Ogier describes as "the researcher tries to describe accurately the findings derived from careful, systematic collection and recording of information or data" (p39) ...read more.


The discussion of the article carefully discusses the findings in a detailed manner. The presentation of the tables was a helpful way of disseminating the findings and the conclusion is well structured and thoroughly evaluates the findings, whilst confirming that people with intellectual disabilities who are overweight or obese need more specialist services to promote health. The study more or less proved that if these types of services are offered to this particular client group they are accessed on a regular basis. The results mostly agree with other reports on this particular topic, although this study found that "unlike past studies, no significant differences were found among males and females in levels of obesity" (Marshall, 2003, p8). The conclusion extends beyond the results and discusses ways in which nurse led health promotion activities can help reduce weight in the clients. The professional implications, for people involved in the care of people, with intellectual disabilities are that health promotion and education needs to be more widespread among these individuals and more readily available. The report suggests that future research could target overweight adolescents with intellectual disabilities so that it can be understood what influences their developing lifestyles and eating habits. The references used, suggest a vast amount of research was carried out on this topic whilst conducting this study. They also allow the possibility of further studying on this topic. The referencing is accurately documented, only a few minor grammatical mistakes are noticed throughout the article. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Nursing section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Nursing essays

  1. A critique of a research article from a professional journal

    be statistically significant, plus the additional intervention provided was acceptable, and was again statistically significant to within a given value for p. Looking more in depth, the analysis of the data does seem to have been slightly misconstrued, specifically the interpretation of the data obtained from the additional intervention questionnaire.

  2. Evidence based pratice - conducting a literature search and appraisal of research based on ...

    673 14583 5265 14 Self management 1507 285 3003 2138 15 Glycated Haemoglobin 253 5 79 542 16 Glycaemic control 1036 100 371 2235 17 BM 2929 0 263 6372 18 Blood Glucose 19515 172 6942 16243 19 Search for 13 or 14 or 15 or 16 or 17 or

  1. Nursing Case Study

    The suicide score was low (14 out of 42) and the BAI indicated that her severe symptoms of anxiety included fear of losing control and fear of dying and discomfort in the abdomen. Although simple in their appearance these tools served to allow a quick, simple, structured way of quantitative assessment.

  2. A critical incident report

    Despite the language barrier, Mrs. Khan and the student developed a good rapport. The hospital link worker came to visit her and translated what Mrs. Khan wished to say to the student and vice versa. During this time the student learned that Mrs.

  1. Care Study.

    However Miss A still did not participate in any exercise and ate an unhealthy diet. On examining Miss As wound it presented generalized oedema, exuding and was shallow with diffuse edges. It was recommended for Miss A to lie down on her bed for one hour and the nurse and myself would come back to carry out a Doppler test.

  2. Health Promotion

    The health visitor suggested the mother should look out for nice long swallows from the baby to determine how good the attachment is. The mother inquired as to whether it was best to change the baby onto formula milk as that is what her mother used, the health visitor advised

  1. Legal and Ethical, DNR

    is complex and can be distressing. (Payne, Hardey and Coleman 2000). One approach to ethical issues would be through, weighing and balancing the four basic principles: autonomy, beneficence, non-malficence, and justice. (Mauk and Schmidt 2004). However, the consultant in charge of Mary's care had the overall responsibility for the DNR decision.

  2. Ethic Gaining consent

    can apply such pressure. Tingle and Cribb (2002) suggests that health care settings, especially hospitals, can be intimidating and unfamiliar environments where the aspects of patient identity which give them confidence can be undermined. Consequently, it can be argued that the outcome of a decision can be affected by the context within which it is made.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work