• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the role of the researcher as participant observer in Goffmans' study of asylums.

Extracts from this document...


Discuss the role of the researcher as participant observer in Goffmans' study of asylums. The late Erving Goffman spent three years (during the 1950s) as a participant observer in the St Elizabeth Hospital in Washington D.C. Having already carried out much of his work on the structure of the 'self', Goffman turned to the 'self' within an institution, a mental asylum. My aim throughout this essay is to elaborate on Goffmans' role as a participant observer. I shall discuss participant observation in general, and more specifically covert participant observation - the method Goffman chose. As with any method of research there are advantages and disadvantages of participant observation. Participant observation through experience allows the researcher to understand the motives and meanings behind peoples' behaviour; this is exactly what Goffman did, and as a result, his findings became more than just an academic publication - they became material for government policy reform. Goffman says of his work Asylums (1961) 'A chief concern is to develop a sociological version of the self' (Branaman & Lemert: 1997: p.xiii) and more specifically on the essay The Moral Career of the Mental Patient 'This paper, then, is an exercise in the institutional approach to the study of the self.' (Goffman: 1961: p.127). In his quest to understand the 'self' in a mental asylum, Goffman as researcher, actually became the research tool by taking on the role of participant observer. ...read more.


Goffman had access to the physical, verbal and expressive behaviour of the patients at the asylum. (Lecture2: 2005) By then combining his role as participant (understanding things form the subject's point of view) with his role as observer (possessing sociological insight) Goffman could reach a fuller understanding of events that the subject may not understand. (website: 2005: p.12) However, by not revealing himself as a researcher, Goffman immediately restricted his means of data collection: he could not for example arrange interviews or question people directly about their actions. Thus Goffman must have used considerable intellectual sophistication in order to gain information. (Lecture: 2005) Participant observation as a method does have its problems, one being the restriction to small-scale studies and the following lack of representativeness. (Website: 2005: p. 3.) In Goffmans case however, further studies and investigations yielded similar results and even led to reforms in the area of mental health care. Additionally there are downfalls to Goffman's use of covert participant observation, as opposed to overt participant observation. In a practical sense, because Goffman could not openly record data, he had to rely on his memory when writing his field diary at the end of each day. Thus any reader must trust that the researcher has correctly remembered and interpreted behaviour, events and experiences, something more difficult with covert participant observation due to restrictions in questioning. ...read more.


x). To conclude, Goffman's role as the researcher as participant observer in his work on asylums, was to actually become the research tool itself in a bid to understand the motives and meanings behind the patients' behaviour: 'to develop a sociological version of the structure of the self' (Branaman and Lemert: 1997: p. xiii). By using subjective sociology ( in the form of covert participant observation) Goffman avoided pre-judgement of the issue at hand, and afforded himself more flexibility in his research. Participant observation meant he could really get 'backstage' and obtain a rich, reliable and detailed pool of evidence. Goffman could match actual behaviour with past claims or statements, and by combining his roles of participant and observer, come to a clear understanding of the patients' actions. Inevitably there are disadvantages to this method, both practical and ethical such as the implications of small scale studies. I suggest that perhaps had Goffman been a patient rather than a member of staff he could have gained a much clearer understanding of the patients' viewpoint and structure of 'self'. Nonetheless, as other studies yielded similar and supporting results, and Goffman's study led to reforms in mental health care, this matter seems largely irrelevant now. Thus Goffman's role of participant observer made him not only the research tool, allowing him to accomplish his personal task of building an image of the structure of the 'self' (through experience), but also it seems turning him into a vehicle for reform. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Healthcare section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Healthcare essays

  1. Medicine is the science and art of healing. Medicine is a science because it ...

    The development of immunology. Smallpox was one of the most feared and highly contagious diseases of the 1700's. It killed many people every year and scarred others for life. Doctors had known for hundreds of years that a person who recovered from smallpox developed lifelong immunity (resistance)

  2. Free essay

    Explain the Purpose and Role of Research

    It will help to improve the quality and speed of services and hopefully provide a world class health and social care infrastructure, provided of course the Government is willing to give support. Best Research Best Health 2006 sets out a five year research and development strategy for the NHS in England.

  1. The Effectiveness of Brief Interventions in Reducing Binge

    theoretically self-aware and conscious of the ethical issues raised by social research. 3.6 Complexities of the Research Project The investigative questions covered great many confidential aspects including health related facilities offered by the government, technical aspects covering the adoption of binge drinking pattern, by assessing comments of respondents.

  2. Free essay

    Socialisation in sociology

    This indicates that behaviour is learned and not instinctive and that we as individuals learn and form our concepts on the behaviour/beliefs of other people. We all experience political socialisation where we acquire political norms and values based government ideologies and legislation.

  1. Literature Review and Case study on CBT

    Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 41, 713-726. Cambridge University Press Velting, O, N., and Albano, A. (2001). Current Trends in the understanding and Treatment of Social Phobia in Youth. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 42, 1, 127-140 Cambridge University Press Case Write-up "Joe" Case History Identifying Information Joe

  2. Free essay

    Cardiorespiratory case study

    ACBT would be indicated with all three components used. BC will help reduce his breathlessness. TEE would be carried out as able, to increase expansion. Holds would be avoided due to breathlessness. FET would be included, as huffing to low lung volumes helps to clear the secretions from peripheral airways (Bhowmik et al, 2008).

  1. The role of government in welfare legistion

    Local Government Communities and local government is responsible for national policy on local government in England. Local government makes a difference to everybody's lives, delivering essential services and making communities better places to live. Each region in England has a Regional Assembly; part of their role is to represent the voice of the regions in Whitewall and Europeans institutions.

  2. Review of Factors Influencing Successful Patient Education in a Rehab Unit for Spinal Cord ...

    The research study by May et al in 2006 has explored the actual purpose of patient education amongst individuals with spinal cord injuries through one-group repeated measure design. The evaluation of knowledge (through multiple choice questionnaires), problem solving ability (using life situation scenarios)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work