• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Do you consider that contemporary theories of mental health ignore the cultural values of 'others'?

Extracts from this document...


Do you consider that contemporary theories of mental health ignore the cultural values of 'others'? Word Count: 2509 Interest in the relationship between culture and mental illness is not new (Kluckhohn 1944). However, in recent years, there has been a greater recognition and realization of cultures' influence over individual expression of mental distress, in psychiatric diagnosis and treatment, and in the delivery of mental health care community-wide. It is clear that cultural values shape the way in which mental symptoms are expressed and how individuals and their families respond to such distresses. Thus dictating when a cluster of symptoms and behaviours are labelled 'normal' or 'abnormal'. Cultural values also determine the accessibility and acceptability of mental health services. Consequently, effective mental health care cannot be separated from the cultural context in which the formation and expression of psychiatric distress occurs. Nonetheless, diagnosis of mental illness is still by and large taken from peoples' behaviour, often received via second-hand accounts or self reports of emotional state and cognitive processes, which may be inaccurate. Furthermore, there are very few objective, scientific tests that can be carried out to help with this diagnosis or to monitor treatment effectiveness. Therefore, even though a medical model is usually adopted, in many cases there is no real distinction between the symptoms and the hypothesised underlying disease. Despite these contradictions, the process of diagnosis aims to go beyond a mere description of symptoms and attempts to identify a (hidden) ...read more.


In addition, it is a common feature of economically motivated migration from third world to first world countries that the social class distribution of the first generation of migrants is skewed downwards so the incomers are likely to be exposed to harsh working conditions, economic uncertainty, substandard and overcrowded housing and other forms of social deprivation. Depending upon context, these experiences will, themselves, have mental health implications which may mistakenly be attributed to ethnicity. Nonetheless, these potential factors will reduce, but not disappear entirely, as a greater and greater proportion of minority ethnic groups are born into this country. One factor which is common for all generations of South Asian and African ethnic minorities in Britain is their exposure to racism. Racism, in so far as it is manifested in discrimination and economic disadvantage, may well affect both physical and mental health, as poverty and low socioeconomic status are among the best predictors of risk for many forms of morbidity. Furthermore, in contrast to physical conditions, further manifestations of racism, such as prejudice, will also impact upon psychological well-being. Whereby experiences of verbal disrespect, social rejection, denial of humanity, stereotyping and assumptions that skin colour is associated with a whole range of problems from academic underachievement to serious criminal activity, have all had considerable influences on self-esteem and mental health. The health impact of racism, previously sidelined as a focus in research and policy, has recently gathered momentum as a subject of legitimate study. ...read more.


It is clear that traditional views of mental health have in the past ignored cultural values of 'others', conversely, research in this area has boomed in recent years, and although putting these theories into practice has been slow, contemporary approaches have made distinct progress which incorporate alternative cultural values. Fernando (1991) believes that if we are to progress to a new definition and understanding of mental illness, this will have to be as part of a general move towards greater understanding between people. Where, for an understanding of this unity, a realistic approach must be taken to the problems arising from differences in culture and the divisions arising from racism. The paradox that mental health is different because of culture and race and yet the same irrespective of culture and race, is a reality that we have to face up to. In conclusion then, although there is still a significant gap in knowledge in transcultural mental health, future research will be advantaged by the availability of sophisticated research designs and statistical techniques that were unavailable two decades ago. Despite a slow start, progress over the next decade will likely outdistance the totality of what has been learned to date. It is possible that aspects of Western psychiatry may be useful if they are integrated into indigenous systems of 'psychiatry' and vice versa. However, if Western psychiatry is to participate fully in the promotion of mental health, it must break free from ethnocentrisms and racism, and reach out into the world it has so far ignored. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Healthcare section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Healthcare essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The purpose of this assignment is to complete a health needs assessment within a ...

    4 star(s)

    Recorded percentage of people with qualification level 1-5 and other Ward District North East England 72* 61* 70.89 67.22 (ONS 2004) *Higher than national average *Lower than national average Employment A rough estimate of ward figures for those of working age* from the census of 2001 and the employment census

  2. Outline and evaluate the evidence of variations in health and illness by class, gender, ...

    If so, the observed gradient is really caused by the skewed age structure of the unskilled manual class rather than by the poorer health of its members. The most persuasive attempt to explain health inequalities as the outcome of a process natural selection, has been put forward by the statistician, Jon Stern.

  1. The Effectiveness of Brief Interventions in Reducing Binge

    to inform the current practice with in alcohol support (Collins and Britten, 2006). Truly, in response to the view that qualitative research is not sufficiently scientific, some say that "all research ultimately has a qualitative grounding" (Miles and Huberman, 1994:40).

  2. Health promotion is an important element of the government's health agenda. Critically discuss this ...

    The Government's proposals for healthy workplaces are a key strand of the public health strategy (Thompson 1998). The government also recognises that for health policies in the workplace to be effective they must be professionally led; therefore, the government has singled out occupational health nurses as the key to promoting health at work (Thompson 1998).

  1. Interprofessional working in mental health

    The implications of this involves civil rights issues that health workers may not be able to advocate independently from the psychiatrist who is more powerful than them in their profession, should they take on responsibilities currently done by ASW's. Furthermore, if the boundaries of someone's work is changing this may

  2. To what extent do modern attitudes to mental illness reflect historical perspectives on an ...

    Throughout the late mid-evil period (fifth to tenth century), a mental illness was believed to be the act of supernatural forces. In a small number of cases the mentally ill individuals were treated adequately concealed in monasteries and at shrines, whereas in the majority of cases treatment and living standards were brutal and inhumane.

  1. Analysis of the Impact of Colonisation, Migration and Settlement on Colombian Health using the ...

    The fonofale model was created by fuimano Karl polotu endemann as a pacific island model of health for the use in the New Zealand context. This model can help to understand and treat people in a more holistic, safe and affective manner.

  2. Literature review on the psychological impact of stoma formation

    and was used to search for studies and researches carried out relating to the chosen topic. To get more recent studies carried out by researchers, the references list was checked to make note of other studies cited in the journals as to get a view of the chosen topic.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work