• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month


Extracts from this document...


HEALTH LAW AND POLICY Assessment Two Introduction Being a patient under the care of a doctor is probably the only occasion where an individual unconditionally places their welfare in the hands of another. However, not everything goes according to plan - sometimes the unexpected happens and things go wrong. It is often assumed that complaints to some form of statutory Health Ombudsman are an effective mechanism not only to resolve individuals' complaints, but also to improve the overall quality of health care (Paterson, 2001). In this assignment I will discuss the laws and legislations that are relevant to Case 00HDC00835. Secondly, I will examine the impact of law and the accountability of Health Practitioners. Thirdly, I will investigate the legal issues raised from the complaints of the patient, and the patient's family. I will pay attention to some of the issues that frequently challenge the elderly population. I will also attempt to identify some policy considerations that are specific to this case. Finally, I will form my own opinion of whether decisions made by the Health and Disability Commissioner struck a fair equilibrium. Other comments will be raised for examination. Law and the Tensions that Arise The law of torts is defined as a "civil wrong". It is concerned with those situations where the conduct of one person causes harm to another (Todd, 1997). A primary function of the law of torts - in particular the tort of negligence - is to compensate for damage caused by personal injury (Todd, 1997). Health Practitioners in New Zealand are largely protected from the "no fault" Accident Compensation Scheme (ACC), which reduces practitioners chances of being sued in court. ...read more.


Research shows that one of the most important factors in healing is the blood supply to the tissues. In some patients, it is recommended to try a limited amputation if there is a chance of healing, but to be prepared to proceed to a major amputation if healing doesn't take place. This in my view is what Dr C did. Unfortunately, there is no test that can predict in every patient whether healing will take place, and it is a matter of surgical judgment and experience whether a wound will heal or not (NZ Society Vascular Surgery, 2004). Under the circumstances, Dr C overruled the considered opinion of Mrs A, probably because he felt that she was not 'lucid enough' to make the right decision at the time. Instead Dr C took the utilitarian approach or acted on paternalism for the best interest of his patient (i.e. on the assumption that doctor knows best). Utilitarianism is primarily concerned with the "greatest good for the greatest number" and because of this, reflects the wants and desires of society (Gillon, 1992). Utilitarianism can face many criticism, e.g. if the majority of people always have their way then the minority will always be left out and will not be given a fair chance (Corey, 1993). Dr C's approach went against her, therefore she lost her autonomy. The communication level between Dr G (registrar) and Dr C could be improved, e.g. even though it was Dr C's responsibility for performing the surgery, he could have involved Dr G (who probably assisted with the operation) ...read more.


be considered, whereby a family member should have been a support backup in case the patient was not fully alert under the circumstances. Did the Commissioner strike a fair balance? In this case, the Commissioner should have looked beyond Rights 6 and 7. There were obvious communication fractures which the Commissioner ignored. Right 5 - Dr C should have ascertained whether Mrs A was in a position to communicate with him, and, if so, advised Mrs A of what options were available. If Mrs A's condition prevented her from communicating, then her family should have been communicated with, as they would have carried out her wishes. Even after the surgery, Dr C did not facilitate effective communication as to why he performed BKA, therefore in my opinion Mrs A's right to effective communication was breached. Right 4 -Services of an appropriate standard could have been breached by the surgeon and overlooked by the Commissioner. Mrs A's family felt that Dr C did not provide her with reasonable care and skill. The doctor failed to provide services (e.g. therapist, counselor) in order to assist Mrs A mentally, for surgery. I also believe the Commissioner should source other legislations or Acts apart from the CHDCSR. Conclusion There are many categories of law which may impact upon doctors but, as a general rule, the principles applied by the courts to date in civil proceedings have come principally from the law of negligence and contract (Skene, 1998). Too often we hear 'doctor knows best'. I think reasonable care challenges this view, because it argues for patient involvement in medical decision-making, and it critically examines approaches based on the assertion of patients' legal rights. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Healthcare section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Healthcare essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Unit 10 care practice and provision

    3 star(s)

    * A reduced ability to cope independently. * Which lasted before adult hood and will have a lasting affect. White paper feels that a low intelligence quote for example an IQ below 70, is not itself a sufficient reason for deciding weather an individual should be provided with additional health and social care support.

  2. The aim of this assignment is to critically evaluate the biopsychosocial perspectives and influences ...

    White and Greyner (1999) identified that this study gives an insight on the negative impact dialysis can have on a couples lifestyle but as a couple were more supportive and positive towards each other. From a biopsychosocial point results indicate that nurses need to recognise and acknowledge the impact a

  1. Select one of the public health targets in England and critically assess the appropriateness ...

    This health policy idealised that all citizens of the world should, by the year 2000, be at a level health that would enable them to lead a socially economic and productive life. The policy had six major themes, set prerequisites for health and set 38 targets to be achieved throughout Europe.

  2. Literature Review and Case study on CBT

    impacts on his ability to effectively attend a course or find and keep a job. To manage Joe takes the safest option, which is remaining in his room and playing computer games and forcing his mother into accepting his chosen lifestyle by becoming aggressive and threatening suicide each time she tries to change the status quo.

  1. Use a study of children or adolescents with diabetes and a study of adults ...

    be an autoimmune system disease, but can have genetic and environmental factors as well; it is most common in children and adolescents12. NIDDM patients make up around 90% to 95% of the population and result from insulin resistance where the body has failed to produce enough insulin or is unable

  2. nutrition and wound healing work based learning

    Literature search Provided broader and in-depth understanding of the role of nutrition in wound healing. Improved personal and professional understanding. Home visits with District Nurses. Appreciation of multi disciplinary team working Able to see how health promotion of nutritional needs is given to varying range of patients in their own homes.

  1. What are the main challenges faced by mature students studying Healthcare courses in Higher ...

    Students professed that peer support aided in them comprehending the academic demands expected, helped them to overcome writers block and to generally vent frustrations (O'Brien et al 2009). This often helped with individual motivation and course progression (Fleming & Murphy 1997).

  2. The only problem with the law relating to vulnerable adults is the lack of ...

    Section 46 of the National Health Service and Community Care Act 1990 sets out community care plans and lists the available services which include laundry services, meals on wheels, social work support and residential care. This act places a duty under section 47 on social workers to conduct a needs-led

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work