• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Public policy and health in the UK and the USA

Extracts from this document...


Public policy and health in the UK and the USA Odin W. Anderson in his article "Issues in the health services of the U.S." claimed that the United States of America and the United Kingdom occupy extreme ends of the market plus/ market minus continuum as far as their respective health systems are concerned. It is true that the U.S. system is market oriented, and that there is often a high degree of government intervention in the operation of the health system of the U.K., however, developments in both countries have arguably effected their position upon this continuum. It is the purpose of this essay to outline the key features of both the U.S and the U.K.'s health systems in relation to their evolution over time. I also intend to discuss the problems facing both systems, which are often remarkably similar, and to outline the variations in policy style employed to tackle such problems. In so doing I hope to make explicit what might explain the variations to be found when comparing the two countries systems. The health system to be found in the United Kingdom is seen as a good example of the `direct' model of health care provision. It is a system of universal coverage paid for out of general taxation and administered by the state. ...read more.


For instance, the increased burden of chronic illness, the increased importance of new infectious diseases, the growth of the elderly population , and the persistence of variations in health status according to social class, geographical location, gender and ethnicity. Such trends have ramifications for all aspects of health policy. Other common problem areas include the obvious need to control costs. This problem was most obvious in the American system during the late '60's/ early '70's. Attempts to control expenditure took several forms indicating the complexity of the problem given that no one method appeared to be sufficient. In 1989 American health care provision cost �1300 per head, whereas this figure was as low as �550 in places such as the U.K. There is also the common need to monitor efficiency and accountability. In the U.K., bearing in mind the structure of the N.H.S., this problem largely centres around the overlap, duplication and lack of co ordination between its various components. There is also a fundamental contradiction at the heart of the N.H.S. in that the Secretary of State for health has full responsibility for health policy, but has little direct control over the activities of the N.H.S.. The health system in the U.S. suffers from the fact that there has been little overall planning, and this has arguably hampered co ordination and efficiency, as well as any attempts to attain universality and equity of health care provision. ...read more.


re organisation of 1974 created three tiers of health service management at regional, area and district level. However, this re organisation did not solve the structural problems inherent in the service as there still remained three separate agencies involved in the provision of state health care. However, the policy makers continued to place their faith in structural reform, giving rise to further re organisation in 1982. Policy making here differs from that of the U.S. in that the problem is seen to be inherent in the structure of the N.H.S., resulting in structural reform. In the U.S. more piecemeal, less general reform is used, and there appears to be no overall planning strategy, largely due to a dislike of mandated direction in the American political culture. In conclusion, it would appear that the challenges facing the two countries health systems are often very similar. For instance, the need to combat upcoming health trends or the goal of universal access. However, the methods used to combat such challenges are often very different, with the Americans invariably focussing on market led provision, whilst Britain has a strong tradition of government intervention in this area. This can often be put down to political culture and the importance placed on health systems within the two countries. There is a sense in which things have changed, however. For example, the Thatcher years saw a move towards the American market led approach in health care, whereas a more comprehensive policy approach has recently emerged in U.S. health policy. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Healthcare section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Healthcare essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Unit 10 care practice and provision

    3 star(s)

    An example could be an elderly service user with sudden deterioration in physical functioning. This is a benefit to the service users and practitioner as they can provide/ receive improved health care for the elderly. A03 How quality assurance is promoted by Ravenswood Quality assurance is a system for evaluating the performance, the quality if the services they provide i.e.

  2. The government's idea of meaningful partnerships between statutory agencies and the local community to ...

    There are many recognised benefits of partnership working. Partnership allows groups to get together at the same table to discuss common issues rather than apart from one another; this improve inter-sectoral communication. Partnership is designed to provide a space for dialogue amongst partners with different perceptions, thereby developing a more collective way of working for local development.

  1. The Effectiveness of Brief Interventions in Reducing Binge

    create hindrance in the research work which was avoided by using specific search terms including 'binge drinking', alcohol, perception of brief interventions and 'interventions to reduce binge drinking'. * For the purpose of ensuring smooth research process the interview questions were pre-evaluated and designed to cut short the questions for a focussed response.

  2. Communicating in Health and Social Care.

    Me - why do you like you old school more than this school? Gemma - (enthusiastically) it wasn't so big and there are too many other kids and teachers here (she pulls a face). I didn't get in to as much trouble in the old one, and all of my friends were there.

  1. Key aspects of public health in the uk

    This partnership approach takes into consideration known determinants of health and health inequalities, any historical trends and other health improvement programmes and strategies. The strategy is being implemented locally for 4 investing for health partnerships comprising of statutory community and voluntary organisations in each area.


    as having the overall authority of defining illnesses. Some doctors' records of their patients' illnesses may be based on class perceptions, e.g. a working-class smoker may be blamed for lung cancer due to overindulgence whereas a more 'sympathetic' explanation may be given to a middle-class smoker with the same condition. This is hardly being objective and emotionally detached!

  1. Today's healthcare environment dictates that management decisions are clinically sound, operationally efficient, financially responsible ...

    A more detailed account of the research proposal can be found on page 27. LITERATURE REVIEW The development of quality assurance in health care and the development of clinical practice benchmarking as a quality assurance tool The development of health economics as a discipline has contributed greatly to the atmosphere

  2. Critically Evaluate the contribution epidemiology has made to the understanding of and policy response ...

    (THT bulletin 2011) Socio medical approach to health has been one of the approaches used to understand the social causes of health. Wall and ottewill (2004) states that Socio medical model of health results from complex and interactions within the social, economic, environmental and personal factors.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work