'A manager's responsibility should be to the shareholders alone.' Critically assess this view and consider the roles of stakeholders in a business.

Authors Avatar

‘A manager’s responsibility should be to the shareholders alone.’ Critically assess this view and consider the roles of stakeholders in a business.

‘All businesses are affected by the environment in which they operate.’ (Marcouse. I 2003 P489) This environment is mainly composing by two groups: shareholders and stakeholders. The overarching business practices of large, publicly traded, companies are typically divided into two categories: shareholder-driven or stakeholder-driven. The shareholder-driven model for business has been overwhelmingly for a long time where most managers believe that their responsibility should be to the shareholders alone, which means managers’ mission is to maximize shareholder value. But, as the human civilization is developing, in recent years, people expect to know more about the business organization rather than just purchase the products and services from the business. All managers are faced with real or imagined conflicts of interest or competing demands for time and resources, between shareholders and stakeholders. In this essay, the shareholder’s and stakeholders’ definition will be outlined. It is also provides the fully explanation of the roles of stakeholders in a business. Finally, the summary that how could business deals with the relationship between shareholders and rest of stakeholders purposefully, befittingly and valuably will also be concluded.

The shareholder means the owner of the company. Shareholders are part of stakeholders; ‘they provide the risk of capital and require a return on their investment.’ (Ryan. J & Richards. J 1991 P217) They employ managers to operate the business. ‘The traditional view of an organization is known as the “shareholder concept”. Under this view managers are responsible solely to the owners of the organization – the shareholders.’ (Marcouse. I 2003 P489) According to this relationship between ownership and control, it is easily to see, when managers making decision, the only objectives they should take into account is the shareholders’ needs, whatever shareholders are looking for short-run profit or long-run growth and expansion of the firm. Although this view seems to be the best way to operate business for a long time, in today’s business world, this is absolutely not enough for the businesses’ survive, growth, expansion and profit-making. Naturally, it brings out the alternative view – the stakeholder concept. The stakeholder approach suggests that managers should responsible to other groups rather than the shareholders only, and other stakeholder groups’ needs should also been taken into account when managers making decisions. It is believed that the ‘stakeholder concept’ would bring numerous significantly advantages to the firm due to the co-operation between the firm and the firm’s stakeholders.

Join now!

Stakeholders are individuals or groups who have an interest in what a business does and either is affected by what the business does or affects the business by what they do. There are two main types of stakeholders: Internal stakeholders and External stakeholders. Internal stakeholders are normally part of business; apart away from shareholders, mainly they are employees which including managers and staffs. External stakeholders normally are not part of the business but have an interest in or are affected by business, they include: customers, suppliers, government and local communities. A number of stakeholders have the right to determine what ...

This is a preview of the whole essay