• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Comparative Study between Shakers and Picnic on a Battlefield

Extracts from this document...


A Comparative Study between Shakers and Picnic on a Battlefield For my GCSE comparative study, I shall be comparing two plays - 'Shakers' and 'Picnic on a Battlefield'. During this comparison I shall be exploring both play's period, society, culture and style. The play which I performed for my GCSE scripted performance was Shakers by John Godber and Jane Thornton. Written for four female actors, Shakers tackles the issues surrounding living and working in a male-dominated society during the 1980's. The majority of the play is set is a cocktail bar and it stars four waitresses who switch from role to role, playing the many characters that come into shakers. Carol, Adele, Nicki and Mel are all young women with high hopes and dreams of achieving their aspirations in order to leave their strenuous, lowly paid, laborious bar work jobs and find success in non-working class careers. Picnic on a Battlefield, written by French playwright Eugene Franklin, was set in 1914 - during the time of the First World War. The play features four main characters, two parents, their son and a foreign soldier (the nationality of this foreigner was not specified). ...read more.


Picnic on a Battlefield is certainly male-dominated, apart from there being more male characters than female characters, the place in which the play was set indicates the fact that the society was male-dominated. On a battlefield during 1914, the men took charge, lead the troops and fought for their country. It was thought that a battlefield was no place for a woman. The characters of Shakers were part of the working-class society in which people had to accept that this meant long hours, hard work and little pay - the girls continually complain throughout the play about this:- Nicki: ...I hate this job; the hours are awful, the customers less than polite. They treat you like shit, but unemployment is so high that any job is a job... We chose to set Shakers in Liverpool - the Liverpudlian accent is often seen to be a very 'common' accent, therefore the audience could therefore assume that we were members of the working-class. In contrast to this the characters in Picnic on a Battlefield came from the middle-class and we could also deduce from their more well-spoken accents that there of a higher class. However, in Picnic on a Battlefield, the characters were clearly of very different statuses. ...read more.


We played all the characters in the play, deliberately showing to the audience that we are doing this purposely. The reason why we did this was so that audience could see the mocking of stereotypes mentioned early. During performance, when we were play male television producers, we wore suits but with skirts. This worked because the audience could see that we were playing men by the way we talked and the way we sat, but knew that we girls because we were still wearing our waitress skirts - this meant that the audience could understand that we were deliberately playing the men how they would have been perceived by society, instead of acting naturalistically. I conclude that the comparison of these two texts highlights that both plays have some aspects in common regarding the purpose of writing each play (to mock the false perceptions society has of different people), but there are more aspects of the two plays which differ mainly because of the massive difference in the two plays' time periods. This not only affects their societies and cultures, but it affects the costumes, the language and the historical on-goings of each play. Katie Heskins 8100 Exmouth Community College 54269 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Plays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Plays essays

  1. The stimulus we were given to look at was the play 'Too Much Punch ...

    He was the first on the scene and who dialled 999. His first reaction when looking out onto the crash was to not go out there straight away but to wait until someone else went to help them, 'Oh shit!

  2. For my Coursework I studied 'Bouncers - 1990s Remix' by John Godber, and 'Shakers-Restirred' ...

    We decided that we needed to introduce our characters first, and we chose to do this with some music and a poem. Our play was a mixture of several short scenes which were quite funny and over-the-top, and some longer, more serious monologues, when the police tell their inner stories.

  1. Theatre Review. Shakers Re: Stirred.

    'Shakers Re: Stirred' draws the audience into their world whether they want to be or not and can keep them held with the physical force of the powerful language used alone. Shakers Re: Stirred has also been quoted to be '...very British, very depressing but simultaneously very funny...'

  2. Drama course work, a comparative essay.

    A memorable and effective stylised sequence from Nicholas Nickleby was the crashing of the carriage. Cold lighting was used, which gave an eerie atmosphere to the stage. Six men stood in a line running rhythmically on the spot representing the horses.

  1. We were given a topic area of study of the Salt industry and its ...

    identities of the other workers are simply lost as they are acting as an inanimate object. The movements were very strong and angular, reflecting the machine movements, showing an influence taken from DV8, using the body as tools in the machine.

  2. Scripted Performance Evaluation - Shakers

    This abstract piece of theatre was effective because we use mime and theatrical poses to show how supposedly happy the Shakers girls were meant to be. Because this scene was the first scene, we spent a lot of time improving it and I think it came across in performance because

  1. Evaluate the performances of Bouncers and Shakers with reference to the performance skills required ...

    they also had a nice dance routine. I thought my own group was good even though we had one actor missing, we did good chorus work but our dance routine wasn't that good because we only rehearsed for a few minutes.

  2. Our performance was a dramatised historical account of Worthing Pier.

    I also wrote an extra verse, which is on there. The class and I decided not to use that verse, because we could not dance and sing at once, and to add another 32 bars for a verse would make the opening song too laborious.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work