All My Sons ∙ Using the Greek concept of the tragic hero, discuss whether Joe Keller can be described in such terms. The definition of a tragic hero is a protagonist who is otherwise perfect except for a tragic flaw

Authors Avatar

Kate Lally                        All My Sons                        

∙ Using the Greek concept of the tragic hero, discuss whether Joe Keller can be described in such terms.

The definition of a tragic hero is a protagonist who is otherwise perfect except for a tragic flaw (otherwise known as a fatal flaw), that will eventually lead to his demise.  This concept derived from Ancient Greek tragedies and is defined by Aristotle.  An aristotelian tragic hero must have four characteristics: goodness, superiority, a tragic flaw, and the realisation of both his flaw and predestined downfall.  Usually the realisation of the tragic flaw results in death, so that the moral balance of the situation can be restored.    

Also, the typical tragic hero is usually an ‘ordinary’ person, someone that many members of the audience can relate to, and therefore compare their moralities with.  Joe Keller fits this description well and therefore many people would be able to relate to him.  

Throughout the play, it is ambiguous to the audience whether or not Joe Keller is guilty, and therefore the audience finds it difficult to obtain a clear impression of him, and consequently his nature.  It is not until the latter part of the play that we realise there has been a constant stream of deception throughout the play.  Miller has used several strategical quotes to portray this feeling of dishonesty throughout the play.  For example, act one appears to show a steroetypical view of the ‘perfect family’.  Then as the play goes on, we realise how wrong the impression we received of the Keller family actually was.  Contrasting quotes such as ‘I had one of the biggest shops in the state, a respected man again’ – Joe Keller, and, ‘everyone knows Joe pulled a fast one to get out of jail’ – Sue, show this deception further.  Also, Joe’s comments about Steve, ‘I owe him a good kick in the teeth, but he’s your father’ show blatent deception and two-facedness.  

Join now!

The opening of the play consists of a very detailed description of the Kellers’ house.  This symbolises the constant and varied goings on throughout the play and the chaos of varied themes and occurrences.  

The majority of the information that the audience uses to create an impression of Joe does not come from Joe at all, but from other characters.  There are several speeches throughout the play that show this.  For example, ‘the trouble is you don’t believe in anything’ – Frank.  This shows that he is not a superstitious man and is shallow-minded.

‘I resent ...

This is a preview of the whole essay