The Spirit that I have seen/may be a devil Can we be quite sure about the Ghost in Hamlet? What are your own conclusions on this matter?

Authors Avatar

“The Spirit that I have seen/may be a devil” Can we be quite sure about the Ghost in Hamlet? What are your own conclusions on this matter?

The Ghost first appears in Act One Scene One. In this scene Shakespeare presents the audience with a mood of anxiety and uncertainty. This is portrayed by the way in which the verses flow thus creating mystery and apprehension. For example, the monosyllabic tone of Horatio “A piece of him”. It is also typical of Shakespeare to start the play with an immediate sense of darkness and melancholy which is predominately presented through the character of Hamlet this is also a common theme throughout the play. The characters help add to the anxiety, for example, when Francisco says “Tis bitter cold and I am sick at heart” and this also helps to emphasize the worrying times to which Denmark have been exposed .The speech starts in a very fragmented way, this shows that the guards are worried, cold and glad to be relieved of their duty.

       When the ghost first appears they are instantly sceptical of its form. This is because it resembles King Hamlet. Their anxiety may also be explained by the historical context in which the play was written and set. This means that superstition would have had a greater impact on the Elizabethan England audience. However, I think there is a lot of contradiction in the ghost’s character and it is clear that Shakespeare was only using him as a theatrical catalyst to create a morally equivocal tragic plot. For example, it is apparent that the ghost is in purgatory.  However, it is interesting to acknowledge that the ghost’s purpose is to generate evil and manipulate Hamlet into killing Claudius which obviously is against Christian law: “thou shall not kill”. Therefore it may be within reason to say that the ghost is in fact in the form of the devil. Evidence to support this is that the ghost only appears at night “it was about to speak when the cock crew”. Protestants who would have been present in Shakespeare’s audience will have assumed that the ghost was the devil as they would not have believed in purgatory.  

Join now!

        The idea that the Ghost is an ambiguous  and contradictatory character is reinforced in Act One Scene Five  when the ghost thrives on his false authority to decide that it is acceptable to kill Claudius and yet the equally incestuous Gertrude shall be left “to heaven” or  “God” to decide. This is Shakespeare creating a contrasting view between women’s power and women’s frailty. There is also the point that the Ghost is “the radiant angel” (which is found in Act One Scene V) this continues to bombard the audience with uncertainty associated with the ghost. Irony ...

This is a preview of the whole essay