• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Comparison of "Who's for the Game" and "Dulce et Decorum est".

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

A Comparison of "Who's for the Game" and "Dulce et Decorum est" For this essay I am going to compare and contrast the two poems "Who's for the game" was published by the daily mail. The poem was designed as a propaganda poem to encourage men to join the army in the war effort. This addressed the men of Britain and reassured them that if they joined it would be nothing to be scared of. It makes the war sound easier by comparing the war to a game throughout the poem. In contrast to this view of war a totally different attitude is given by "Dulce et Decorum est". Throughout the poem Owen describes to us about the tragedies and horrors of war. In the poem Owen tells us about a group of soldiers that have been at the front line for some time and are falling back as they desperately need rest, they then are attacked with gas. Owen then describes the soldiers rush for their masks, however one soldier does not get his mask on in time. Owen explains to us the feelings and emotions he felt as he had to go to war and fight. This poem is his experience and he saw the soldier dying." Dulce et Decorum est" was written in response to poets such as Jessie Pope as Owen did not agree to the way that the war was portrayed in their poems. "Dulce et Decorum est" was addressed to the people of Britain to give a realistic truthful view of war. Both poems have the same theme of war but have totally opposite attitudes towards it. In the poem "Who's for the Game" Jessie pope makes a comparison between war and a 'Game'. The use of 'Game' gives the indication that war is easy. It gives the idea it will be easy to cope with and that it will be fun. ...read more.

Middle

'blood shod' "all went lame all, blind" For this quotation Owen uses the word 'lame' this term is usually associated with injured animals like cattle. This implies that the men are in such a bad state that they can be compared to as animals. The second part of the quotation says 'all blind' To me this indicates that their vision has been compromised due to tiredness. The metaphor "drunk with fatigue deaf even to the hoots" Suggests that the soldiers are so unbelievably tired that they have had too much and become drunk. In the second part of the quotation it implies that due to tiredness there senses have failed so they cannot even here the guns of war. The mood of this first stanza is depressing. The pace is very slow to me this is reflecting on the speed at which they are walking and it has a serious tone. The second stanza has an immediate change of pace. This is where the soldiers are attacked with gas. "Gas! GAS!" The first two words of the stanza create a major sense of urgency; it does this by the way it is written and the use of large capitals and exclamation marks. This words 'GAS' is repeated twice on the second time it is larger. This suggests that it is being shouted very loud and creates a rushed feeling. The word 'QUICK' says that the gasmasks needed to be put on immediately. Owen creates a sense of fast action by the use of words like "an ecstasy of fumbling ". The soldiers are in a desperate panic, struggling to find their masks. When they do find them they are in such a rush to put them on they become clumsy. "fitting to clumsy helmets" It suggests that their hands are shaking. However in the mad rush someone did not get his mask on in time. ...read more.

Conclusion

This however is a very realistic view of war, many did die this way. Owen describes his hellish experience. Very different imagery is used by Jessie Pope, she hid the truthful brutality of war by depicting it as a game. Pope tries to encourage young men to join up by creating a false image of war as a though it were a sports game, in a game you would just come out with a few cuts and bruises. She suggests that war is fun and if men did not join they would be missing out on "fun". The structure and rhyme scheme of "Who's for the Game" as it adds to the effect of the poem. There are four stanzas in the poem each has four lines. The poem has an Ab Ab rhyme scheme, which is constant throughout it make the poem sound light hearted and jolly. This is what Pope wanted but this is inappropriate as the poem is about war. The structure "Dulce et Decorum est" is three stanzas the first two have eight lines the third has twelve lines. The poem initially take on a sonnet from it has iambic pentameter it's stressed then unstressed. The sonnet farm is usually associated with love. I think that Owen does this because the poem is so opposite to the theme of love. However the pattern starts to break down at the attack as the rhyme scheme has gone from Ab AB to Cd Cd. This is significant in the poem as it gives it a more serious atmosphere. Overall I found both poems quite interesting to read and discuss. "Dulce et Decorum est" was truthful and realistic and therefore found it more interesting as the events actually happened, although "Who's for the Game" is a very good poem for it's intended purpose, I believe that it should not have been published as it was false and war in my opinion should never be compared to a game, as so many young and innocent people died. Rachael Browne 11JD/U ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

Phew! What a long, rambling essay of poorly-constructed sentences and sloppy punctuation! It is at least twice as long as necessary to make its points.
The two poems are analysed separately, and mostly concerning the lexis, with little direct comparison of the language and poetic devices used by the two authors. Quotations are well chosen, though often not quoted accurately.

The concluding paragraph is short and does not effectively sum up the comparison promised in the title. With some serious editing, this could be a much better essay.

3 stars.

Marked by teacher Jeff Taylor 10/06/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level War Poetry essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Compare the presentation of the psychological effects of war on the individual in 'Regeneration' ...

    5 star(s)

    and Anderson's constant worry and conflict concerning his profession and future is evident, "I've devoted all my adult life to medicine...what do you do when the doctor breaks down?", "I have a wife and child to support". These characters in both texts demonstrate how war can drastically change men, and affect their life even after the war has ended.

  2. This paper describes a design-based effort to build an effective closed-system air standard gas ...

    The third isentropic relation is the following equation: Ideal gas (3) The specific heat ratio k, in general, varies with temperature, and this an average k value for the given temperature range should be used. We are going to use a compressor, a combustor, and a turbine.

  1. POETRY ANALYSIS: Dulce Et Decorum Est by Wilfred Owen and My Lai by David ...

    "Who would have thought that they would lie so heavily upon my heart?" this question can be implied both literally and emotionally. The resolution is in the last stanza, where the poem reveals that the soldiers are still there, and they have the idea of blowing up the cow the protagonist is under.

  2. A Comparison Between Dulce Et Decorum Est and Pro Patria

    Seaman says that those left at home whilst their sons go to war must be "strong in faith and in prayer" and that they should "ask what offering we may consecrate", suggesting to the people back home to turn to their faith for comfort, and to be willing to give

  1. 'Strange Meeting' by Wilfred Owen - Questions and answers.

    as nobody was safe during war. Which basically means that innocent people would also die during war. 8. What do you think is meant by: "Foreheads of men have bled where no wounds were"? The above quotation suggests that these people are no longer able to transmit their experiences, which could have taught many others what was war like and how useless and cruel it is.

  2. Dearest Mother, - letter from a soldier in the first world war

    of bursting through the German lines in order to allow cavalry to restore open fighting. These officers sit in their comfy huts and plan attacks through terrain they could not possibly be familiar with. It seems they are satisfied with sending us in to die due to old fashioned, undeveloped tactics.

  1. Compare The Soldier and Dulce et Decorum Est

    While Brooke mentions nothing of the pain and of death and the unpleasant ways soldiers die in war, in Dulce et Decorum Est, Owen shows the horrific consequences of war. Owen seems to show the misery of war by setting the scene effectively he does this by saying, "In all

  2. The diffusion of Ammonia Gas

    Diagram 4 cm 8 cm 12 cm 16 cm 20 cm 0� 2 18 42 83 121 30� 2 20 47 87 144 60� 2 32 54 92 198 90� 2 28 55 136 243 120� 2 30 58 135 240 150� 2 30 58 135 236 180� 3 28

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work