'All our sympathies are with Juliet because she receives very little help or guidance at home.' How true is this statement?

Authors Avatar

‘All our sympathies are with Juliet because she receives very little help or guidance at home.’ How true is this statement?

Romeo and Juliet is said to be the world’s most ill fated romance in the whole of drama. The story follows “a pair of star-cross’d lovers” who are willing to sacrifice anything and anyone for the sake of their love. Romeo and Juliet come from “two households both alike in dignity” hindered in their families’ feud. The loathsome feud concerns the Capulet and Montague families which spawned from an ‘ancient grudge.’ Romeo is a young man who is the Montague’s son. Juliet, a young girl who is fourteen years of age, she is the Capulet’s only daughter. It is greatly argued that the young lover Juliet was faultless in the entire ordeal, as she was young and received little or no guidance at home.

Initially, it was evident that Juliet received aid from her father from the beginning.

Paris was originally introduced to the audience during his conversation with Capulet, in which he was again, asking about his “suit”, which concerns Juliet’s hand in marriage. But in Capulet’s mind Juliet was still "a stranger in the world." Although Juliet was not told or consulted it appears that Capulet had her best interests at heart and was asking Paris to prolong the marriage, for another two years. Capulet thought that Juliet was still young and had more to learn. He asked Paris to wait for another two years not only because of the metal stress that awaited her but, because it could otherwise endanger her life as well as that of her child. He made this apparent as he stated "And too soon marr'd are those so early made". Capulet had spoken from experience and worries for his only daughter. This illustrates that although Juliet was not consulted directly, her father was already guiding her, solely for her own happiness. It can be said that any normal father in society at that time, would have accepted Paris’ offer without a thought. The reasons for this are self explanatory as Paris is a county, ; he is wealthy and is a suitor that some girls would only dream of.

Furthermore, during Capulet’s conversation with Paris, Capulet invites him to a party. Capulet’s comments can be comprehended as if he is trying to persuade him to look at other women who are "Earth-treading stars that make dark heaven light" which will captivate his eye.  Capulet may be worried that Paris is not as good a suitor as he seems, or perhaps he wants Paris to refrain from inquiring for an answer as it was made evident that it was not Paris’ first time asking for Juliet’s hand. Capulet could feel that Juliet is too young and Paris will grow restless and in hope find another girl that is suitable for his needs. However, Capulet could have just been modest about his daughter and still have every intention to marry her. Capulet could be perceived as a caring father, whether with the will or not to marry her to Paris. He still said that at the end all relies on Juliet’s consent he states this unmistakably as he feels that his “will to her consent is but a part". Even though Juliet has not been directly guided, she is being guided as her father is only worrying about her and is waiting for her to come of age of marriage and also for her consent to marry. From this it is understandable that Juliet is being aided by her father. At these early stages, Juliet considers Paris and states that she will “look to like, if looking liking move.” Regarding this, it is obvious that Capulet is concerned with his daughter, and indirectly, although she has not been told, she is being aided by her father.

Join now!

The final piece of advice Juliet receives is when her father has changed his attitude dramatically and she is married to Romeo. The change in her father’s attitude has resulted in Juliet being forced to marry Paris. Juliet is left powerless, dependent on other and is in a desperate situation.  After her fathers outburst Juliet attempts to seek aid from her mother. Sadly and irresponsibly her mother turns tell her to “talk not to me, for I'll not speak a word.”  How is Juliet to be guided or helped if both parents turn on her? Her parents have not ...

This is a preview of the whole essay