• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparative essay on poems from the 'Book of matches'.

Extracts from this document...


Comparative Essay On Poems I have decided to use two poems from the book of matches, 'Those bastards in their mansions', 'I've made out a will' and the poem 'Kid' to compare and contrast. Simon Armitage wrote 'Book of matches' in 1993. It is a selection of poems without titles. Each poem is meant to be read in the time that it takes for a match to burn down. There is a pun in the title, a packet from which we tear out the matches a book, but this is also a book in the normal sense, with words for us to read. Both of these poems are fourteen lines long, but they are not strictly a sonnet in form. 'I've made out a will' has irregular rhymes, both full and half rhymes. It is split so that there is a first block of eight lines, then a second block of six lines, which is split into a four and a two. The final section is split so that it ends in a couplet like a Shakespearean sonnet. ...read more.


He lists all of the parts that he is 'sure they can use', but some things would only be useful for research, such as veins and nerves. In 'Those bastards in their mansions', the persona of the poem has a grudge against people. He mentions words such as 'mansions', 'palaces' and 'castles'. Here this is probably a large exaggeration, but it could be taken literally as the poem could be set in the past, there is mention of 'burning torches' and 'cuffs and shackles'. Like in 'Those bastards in their mansions', in 'Kid', Robin has a grudge against Batman. Simon Armitage imagines that Robin has separated from Batman and that he has succeeded and that Batman has turned into a failure. It says how Batman has 'nothing in the walk-in larder'. This is the opposite to 'Those bastards in their mansions' because in that poem the persona has nothing compared to the people he has a grudge against and is jealous. At the end of the first eight-line section, the speaker concludes his list with the one exception, 'but not the heart, they can leave that alone'. ...read more.


In the last two lines he says how he does not want his heart to be touches, he compares this with 'the pendulum, the ticker'. These are the parts of the clock that makes everything work, just like the human heart. In this passage, Simon Armitage uses lots of metaphors. This is to emphasise points. For example, he uses not only 'pendulum', but also 'ticker' to talk about the heart. Throughout this poem the poet describes the human body merely as lots of parts, he shows no emotion towards anything apart from the heart. This could be because the speaker sees the heart as being the most important part of a mechanism, like a pendulum in a clock. It also maybe that he values the heart as a symbol of all things that make life worth living, a heart is the symbol of love, affection, energy, desire, and much more. Or, perhaps he feels that he is inside his heart, and it is like a soul, and if he gives up his heart then he is giving up his immortality. Edward Amoroso ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Simon Armitage section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Simon Armitage essays

  1. Explore Armitage`s presentation of his relationship with his parents in the poems: "Mother, any ...

    Line six, the words mentioned are important and the phrases telling about things going on, the important words being "reporting" and the measuring lengths like centimetres and metres, the phrase "back to base" and the word "reporting" are describing him telling his mother what he has done and his experiences in his life.

  2. Simon Armitage - poetry

    He describes the "tightness in the throat" and the "tiny cascading sensation" as "that sense of something else". When he finishes by saying, "That feeling, I mean," he is drawing us into the poem and siding with us. He wants us to understand what he means.

  1. How does the poetry by Simon Armitage make the ordinary seem extraordinary?

    By using metaphors it paints images inside the reader's head of what the washing line looks like, it looks alive! This is the only poem where metaphors make the ordinary extraordinary; it takes a very imaginative mind to think of metaphors.

  2. Kid - The poem is a dramatic monologue by Robin the Boy Wonder, the ...

    He includes references to: * food: jellies and ... syrups (line 3), the loaf of brains(line 4), a gallon exactly of bilberry soup (line 6) * a workshop: tubes and ... glues (line 3), the chassis (line 7). This emphasises how 'ordinary' his body is.

  1. A Critical Appreciation of 'Cataract Operation', a Poem by Simon Armitage.

    This word, like 'pantomime', has the effect of bringing to mind extremely animated images. The seventh stanza tells of 'the monkey business of a shirt pegged only by its sleeve'. I think that the phrase 'monkey business' is used in the same way as 'turns tail' and 'pillar to post';

  2. For this piece of coursework, I am going to compare two Poems produced by ...

    It is not told what is exactly meant but I presume so. On the 6th stanza it says there was a rolled up note of explanation sprayed like a carnation. This gives us a hint that he committed to suicide. The words "explanation" and "carnation" both rhyme like a simile.

  1. Simon Armitage´s poems, ‘Poem´ and ‘About His Person´

    form a judgement of him, but ask us, the readers, how it is possible to judge someone when he or she is gone.

  2. Poetry Essay

    "The sun comes like a head through last nights turtleneck." The imagery of the clothing also helps us to understand the poem. "From pillar to post; a pantomime of damp forgotten washing" The washing he sees now is particularly brightly coloured as most pantomime costumes are.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work