Compare and Contrast Essay on Siddhartha

Authors Avatar

DaeYong Jang                                Pd. 4th                                        12/6/2009

Siddhartha Compare-Contrast Analytical Essay

100 points

        All civilization that existed relied on some sort of monetary system from the start, and many people base their happiness on how much wealth they posses. However, many people who were wealth have reported that they are not as happy when they acquired less wealth. In the novel Siddhartha, however, Herman Hesse conveys that money does not necessarily bring gratification to one’s life by comparing Siddhartha, the son of a Brahmin, with Kamala, the courtesan; then comparing Gautama, and Vasudeva, poor, yet enlightened ferrymen, with first comparison.

        In the chapter Samsara, Siddhartha transform his life from a poor shramana who begged for the living to a rich merchant who is living in a nice house, owns many servants, and finds lover. Yet as time passed he felt “disgust for himself, for his perfumed hair, the odor of wine on his breath, the tired flaccidity and the repugnance of his skin. As when one who has eaten or drunk far too much vomits it up in agony and is pleased to feel relief…” (66) which clearly illustrates that Siddhartha was not happy even with everything that could be bought with his money. He realizes that the materials he owns only distracted him from the enlightenment, not bring him closer to achieving it. Experiencing the similar situation as Siddhartha, Kamala also finds herself discontent with just physical opulence. When Siddhartha left the city, she “received no more visitors and she kept her house locked…” (68), which conveys that she no longer found happiness from the materials around her. After the disappearance of Siddhartha and birth of son between her and Sid, Kamala gave “her garden to Gautama’s monks, taking her refuge in the teachings...” (88) also distancing herself from the materialistic world, Samsara, and seeking peace by following the Gautama. In the end when both see each other again later in the story, Kamala sees Siddhartha has returned to his old self before she met him; she sees that Siddhartha reached enlightenment by freeing himself from the materialistic world and by meditating. There, Kamala also finds inner peace by reuniting with her lover and dies in serenity.

Join now!

        Comparing to Siddhartha and Kamala, who suffer from the temptation of wealth and power, Gautama and Vasudeva both are in a state of contentment even though they have little to no possessions. In the novel, Gautama is the first person Siddhartha meets that truly reaches the state of enlightenment. Herman Hesse describes Gautama as a monk that “went out into the city with [his] bowls to collect food for the midday meal, the only one of the day. Even the Buddha himself, the Enlightened One, was in the habit of making the beggar’s rounds in the morning” (24), who has ...

This is a preview of the whole essay