• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast the Presentation of the Relationship between Raleigh and Stanhope in Journeys End with the Presentation of the Relationship between Stephen and Weir in Birdsong, in the Light of the Opinion that War Makes Relationships,

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and Contrast the Presentation of the Relationship between Raleigh and Stanhope in Journey's End with the Presentation of the Relationship between Stephen and Weir in Birdsong, in the Light of the Opinion that 'War Makes Relationships, but Ruins Others'. Strong relationships between men play a key part in any war, and comradeship is an element of the First World War that is often dramatised or written about. The government even used the idea of comradeship in their Pals Battalion scheme, the plan being that men would fight harder if they fought with their friends. It is no wonder that fiction often focuses on the friendships between men at war. It is also no question that relationships at war are different to those at home. They are placed in extraordinary circumstances which causes massive amounts of pressure. Relationships could go either of two ways; they could crumble, or become stronger. An example of a strong comradeship caused by war is Stephen's relationship with Weir. These men form a bond that would not have been of the same nature had the men not been in a combat situation. The war causes them to understand each other well. An example of this is that Stephen reads Weir's rune cards: 'I want you to do the runes. Tell my fortune,' said Weir. Stephen smiled at him. 'You're a hopeless devil, aren't you?' ...read more.

Middle

Bring the whisky!' showing how dependent he is upon alcohol. There is a link here to Birdsong; the first time we see Stephen and Weir together they are finishing a bottle of whisky: 'Jack looked towards Weir and noticed the almost empty bottle of whisky that stood on the table.' This shows the men's similar coping mechanisms. Despite his hardened exterior, we learn that Stanhope has a soft heart. This is particularly apparent in his conversations with Osborne, in which he calls him 'uncle'. However his hardened mask is presented to Raleigh, which creates tension between these characters. Stanhope has become a different person to the one Raleigh knew before the war. Osborne warns Raleigh of this: 'Osborne: You know, Raleigh, you mustn't expect to find him - quite the same.' The pause in his speech is heavily loaded with meaning. Osborne cannot tell Raleigh just how much Stanhope has been affected by the war. This also links to Raleigh's naivety about the realities of warfare. He also still calls Stanhope 'Dennis' which shows he cannot accept Stanhope as this new, nerve-wrecked officer. Stanhope is horrified that Raleigh has been sent to his company, shown by his reaction at seeing him for the first time: 'Raleigh stands smiling awkwardly...He stops short at the sight of Raleigh. There is silence. Raleigh: Hullo, Stanhope! Stanhope stares at Raleigh as though dazed.' ...read more.

Conclusion

An interesting comparison is that death breaks both of the relationships apart. Raleigh and Weir's deaths are extremely harrowing in their own ways. In Raleigh's death, the audience will feel hopeless sympathy after an insight into Stanhope's real emotions. His death is particularly poignant as he is a naive youth. One view that could be taken is that Raleigh's imminent death is the factor that changes Stanhope's attitude toward him, as it is only in his injured state that he becomes caring. However it is more likely to be the case that Stanhope resented Raleigh's being in his company so much because he cared for him. At Weir's death in Birdsong we feel pity and regret for Stephen, because his last words to Weir were that of frustrated anger. Ultimately, war has tested both of the relationships, but they are both destroyed by death - a hopeless reality in war. In conclusion, I believe that the conditions of the First World War were testing and pressurising, but it was ultimately the perfect time for comradeship to flourish. The underlying feelings in the relationships between Weir and Stephen and Stanhope and Raleigh are that of care. In the case of breaking or making relationships, perhaps it is easier for war to create a new friendship, rather than to keep up a relationship from home, as any reminder of home is too complex an emotion to deal with. This is certainly true in Stanhope's case. Ultimately, war can break a friendship through the harsh reality of death. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level War Synoptic Paper section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level War Synoptic Paper essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Henry V compared to the War Poets. Throughout 'Henry V' there are very ...

    4 star(s)

    Whose blood is fet from fathers of war-proof!'. Repetition is used as a means of encouragement, with Henry stressing the words 'On, on' to urge his soldiers forward, and alliterating the 'f' sound stresses that fighting and carrying on from their fathers preserves family honour and security. It is better to die fighting for England, to 'close the

  2. Tim O'Brien's 'The Things They Carried' and Pat Barker's 'Regeneration'. Compare and contrast the ...

    They fight in the war 'to avoid the blush of dishonor,' and they are even willing to die 'so as not to die of embarrassment'. The point is that the soldiers are too frightened of the consequences of not being brave to be brave enough to confess to their cowardice.

  1. Free essay

    Explore the ways Peter Whelan presents the complacency of the home front in The ...

    The effect on the home front was a long term horror; the horror felt by the men on the frontline was immediate. 'They closed ranks', they entered into the 'unspoken conspiracy', because they could no longer express the horrors they had seen.

  2. Explore the ways in which Journeys End presents ideas about heroism. Compare and contrast ...

    Yet in ?Goodbyeee?, George?s character is developed as he admits his fear of death ? which suggests he?s been aware of the dangers for quite some time and perhaps just feels inclined to fight ?for king and country?. This isn?t unheroic by any means, but somewhat tragic, and it?s quite

  1. Explore Sherriffs presentation of class in Journeys End and compare this with Barkers treatment ...

    stage directions uphold where Mason ?brings Trotter?s porridge? and ?arrives with Trotter?s bacon?; we prejudge him as inferior. The other officers also give orders, Stanhope requesting ?a cup of tea? on numerous occasions and Osborne requesting ?plenty of bread and butter.? However, Mason, the inspiration for Elton?s Baldric, is never

  2. Compare and Contrast the ways in which Sherriff and Whelan present Stanhopes and Tom ...

    `They can?t see further than they know. Mentally stuck. ` Hackford believes that people live independently but rather should live for others. He believes those who live autonomously are made narrow minded as he describes them as `mentally stuck. ` Hackford is only interested in his idea of free exchange that the war will bring about.

  1. Compare and contrast the different ways in which Resistance and On The Black Hill ...

    Bickertons ??The Bickertons, were an old Catholic family made rich by the West India trade.? however in ?Resistance' it is more implicit as the Germans and their invasion could be seen as an metaphor for the English cultural invasion of Wales because then actual notion of invasion is stronger, as

  2. No war is identical to another but having read Tim OBriens On the Rainy ...

    He is given a life sentence for the London bombing and murder of five people. Despite being innocent, he is considered an easy ?scapegoat? by the British authorities and the IRA. The IRA mentioned earlier he?s just a ?hassle? to their plans and therefore have no problem with him being convicted.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work