• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the way that Rhoda Brook and Mrs. Marroner deal with the ‘the other woman’ in their lives.

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the way that Rhoda Brook and Mrs. Marroner deal with the 'the other woman' in their lives. In "Turned", the main character is called Mrs. Marroner. She is an upper class women, who has a house, a remarkable education, a job which brings her in a lot of money judging by the way her house is described and that she is upper class, she has a husband and she also has a maid called Gerta. In "The Withered Arm", the main character is called Rhoda Brook. She is a lower class milkmaid, who has no education, hardly any money and a son out of marriage, which makes her a fallen woman. Mrs. Marroner has a superbly furnished house, " In her soft-carpeted, thick-curtained, richly furnished chamber." Rhoda Brook has a cold cottage in the suburbs of the village, it is plain, cold, and airy with a thatched roof, "It was built of mud-walls... the thatch above....", and this is a simile. This contrasts with the house of Mrs. Marroner. Rhoda Brook is a nutritionally deprived woman, "... where a thin fading woman of thirty milked some apart from the rest." This quote also shows us that Rhoda Brook is a foreigner/outcast. ...read more.


Rhoda copes differently because, first of all she is jealous of Gertrude because she has married Rhoda's old lover, and is upper class, ladylike etc. The community plays a very big part in not helping Rhoda to cope; they are all spreading rumours about e.g. that she is a witch. By Rhoda hearing these, she begins to believe them and it damages her self-confidence and self esteem. This all begins with the first mention of Gertrude being brought home to live with Farmer Lodge, "he do bring home his bride to-morrow, I hear. They've come as far as Anglebury to-day." Rhoda is financially dependent on Farmer Lodge, which leaves Rhoda emotionally insecure. This means that if Farmer Lodge makes Rhoda redundant, she will have no other job, because she has had little or no education. Also she is lower class that makes finding another job much more difficult, she will have nowhere to live. This contrasts with Mrs. Marroner, who unlike Rhoda has her own house, she is financially independent, and is able to buy her own house when she leaves her husband. Rhoda has no education so this means that she cannot think rationally about things, and is unable to cope with the situation at hand by thinking about it (she forgets who she is). ...read more.


Also that if it was your husband's fault, then you shouldn't be at war with the other woman. To conclude, Mrs. Marroner is an overall stronger woman than Rhoda, and is able to manage much more easily with the situation because she has an education, a job, money, and her own house. All these factors help Mrs. Marroner to cope, whilst Rhoda cannot deal with the situation so she leaves the town, where she used to live. Mrs. Marroner makes a totally new life for her self and lives with the other woman. Rhoda's experiences are the complete opposite, and no matter where she goes, her problems will follow her and it will all begin again. As Rhoda having so many problems with no education, jealousy, being an outsider, she is unable to cope with 'the other woman' Gertrude, whether as Mrs. Marroner is able to cope with 'the other woman' Gerta. Mrs. Marroner at the end puts her husband in the spotlight and challenges him what he wants, "What have you to say to us?" Rhoda returns to her old town and everybody remembers who she is and what has happened, "Here, sometimes those who knew her experiences would stand and observe her, and wonder what sombre thoughts were beating inside that impassive, wrinkled brow, to the rhythm of the alternating milk-streams." ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Thomas Hardy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Thomas Hardy essays

  1. Good women- Bad men?

    Every few months Sophy brings the matter up but her son just dismisses it, leaving her unable to act upon her promise. In the end Sophy dies. I would not say that Sophy is a good woman; I do not think anyone is.

  2. Compare and contrast at least two of the female characters in two or more ...

    This act of selflessness makes the reader warm to Rhoda. By causing the reader warm to Rhoda, when she loses Gertrude's friendship, Hardy creates sympathy for Rhoda, as she did not inflict such pain on Gertrude purposely. Neither woman deserves this suffering, and because of it, they have lost eachother as companions.

  1. The attitudes and beliefs which influence the outcome of the story 'The Withered Arm' ...

    for Gertrude and making her feel she was almost not worthy of his love. Through out the story you are made to feel sorry for Gertrude, she has been bewitched with a horrible disfigurement when she was just an innocent sweet pretty lady.

  2. A comparison of 'Old Mrs Chundle' by Thomas Hardy and 'A Visit Of Charity' ...

    promote himself as doing the job as he thinks it should be done. He cannot cope. He avoids going to see Mrs Chundle after the pipe is removed so as not to have to discuss it with her, and by the time he does go, she is dead.

  1. Rhoda Brook has many difficulties to face - How does she cope with them ...

    Because she was really jealous of Gertrude, she built up anger and envy against her in her mind that lead to Rhoda having a dream in which an incubus in the form of Gertrude visited her, Rhoda hurts her physically by making her arm withered.

  2. In the short story entitled the withered arm, Thomas Hardy introduces us to a ...

    We realize that his son is treated like he's own father doesn't even want to know him that would off been hard to cope with. Farmer Lodge tries to ignore him as much as he could. He was very relieved when he got away from the boy but when he

  1. Read the Short Stories the Three Strangers By Thomas Hardy, and a Vendetta By ...

    On several occasions, Hardy refers to the first stranger as a 'solitary pedestrian.' This adds to the mystery rather well because if one is alone, no one will know if something happens to you. Later, as he is about to enter the house, the first pedestrian is described to be 'mentally looking through the door' (page 135).

  2. The characterization and lives led by Gertrude Lodge and Rhoda Brook in Hardy's The ...

    This was due to the lack of opportunities, which meant women were unable to undertake careers of their choice and had to make do with the low paid labour extensive jobs available, such as milkmaids, which many only just managed to survive.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work