• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6

Compare and contrast ways in which David Guterson and Grahame Greene present painful conflict in love relationships that cross boundaries within Snow falling on Cedars and The End of the Affair

Extracts from this document...


"Here's much to-do with hate, but more with love" (Romeo). Compare and contrast ways in which David Guterson and Grahame Greene present painful conflict in love relationships that cross boundaries within "Snow falling on Cedars" and "The End of the Affair" Caroline Finnerty Guterson and Greene profoundly scrutinize how love and hate entangle within their characters of Ishmael and Bendrix. The painful aftermath ensuing the death of a passionate love affair leads to an apt account of internally conflicting emotions and the blurry line separating them - as Bendrix comments: "hatred seems to operate the same glands as love: it even produces the same actions"1 A pivotal issue for both Guterson and Greene is the way in which conflict of emotions and relationships affect men and women differently. Both authors use the male characters to depict a selfish love centred on desire and romantic ideals. Ishmael is portrayed as naive and childlike in his blind dreams: "Love is the strongest thing in the world you know. Nothing can touch it. Nothing comes close. If we love each other we're safe from it all."2 He chooses to ignore the problems arising both from the war and Pearl Harbour and the culture of their people. The Japanese and Americans were enemies in the war, who would have objected to the romance. Dissimilarly, Bendrix is perceptive of the cruelty of the world. He becomes obsessed by the idea that Sarah will eventually end the affair, returning to her safe marriage, to the extent that he "hated her because I wished to think she didn't love me" and subconsciously attempted to push her away. Both writers depict the women as self less and aware of their real responsibilities and restrictions in life. Whilst the men blame culture and religion, the women turn to it in the hope for more than just a self focussed existence. Laura Kryhoski comments: "For Sarah, love is physically fatal, for Bendrix, it becomes a "record of hate."3 Yet this seems to over simplify the varying approaches to love the characters hold. ...read more.


Ishmael too shares this sort of sickness, his personal obsession towards Hatsue preventing him moving on with his life. He finds empty relationships because he cannot let go: "'he slept with them angrily and unhappily and because he was lonely and selfish'" 14 Sickness is used alternatively in "The End of the Affair" through Mr Parkis and his son. Mr Parkis' boy is healed by Sarah's love, "Mrs Miles who came and took the pain away", suggesting that eventually love and mercy conquer misery. This could depict that ultimately God's love will rescue Bendrix from his 'sickness' in as it rescued Sarah from her suffering. There is no such chance of spiritual rescue in "Snow Falling on Cedars" as Ishmael is expected to move on alone. Yet in the absence of God Ishmael finds refuge in family: "'What else do we have?' replied Ishmael. 'Everything else is ambiguous. Everything else is emotions and hunches. At least the facts you can cling to; the emotions just float away.' 'Float away with them,' said his mother.' If you can remember how, Ishmael. If you can find them again. If you haven't gone cold forever.'"15 An epistolary style is used to explore painful relationships from varying views. In "Snow Falling on Cedars" we see Hatsue's letter to Ishmael and the ocean report whilst in "The End of the Affair" we see Parkis' reports, Sarah's diary, Sarah's letter and Parkis' letters to expand our ability to understand the situation. Critic A. A. DeVitis spoke of this technique in "The End of the Affair": "Greene's use of the diary and of the journal allows him not only to characterize his people but also to portray the various levels of meaning of the spiritual drama enacted. Bendrix looks at Sarah; Sarah looks at herself as she looks at God. The Bystanders look at Sarah, and she leaves her mark on them."16 This seems to be an accurate review because the diary allows Greene to give us a true insight into his characters. ...read more.


to Guterson's more sophisticated approach "beneath the surface of everything else he'd been thinking of her with pleasure"29 This difference may stem from Greene's own experience in a painful relationship, which Guterson lacks, having married and settled down at a young age. Guterson also focuses more on the impact of culture in destroying relationships, whilst for Greene the external factor is mainly religion. Although in neither novel are the lovers reconciled, there is a contrast between a seemingly positive and negative ending; both authors effectively convey a different side of the nature of pain in love relationships. 1 End of The Affair page 19 2 Snow Falling on Cedars page 182 3 Laura Kryhoski, Critical Essay on The End of the Affair, in Novels for Students 2003 4 The End of the Affair page 1 5 The End of the Affair page 40 6 The End of the Affair page 76 7 The End of the Affair page 120 8 Snow Falling on Cedars page 181 9 Nicholas Evans - Introduction to Snow Falling on Cedars 10 The End of the Affair page 41 11 The End of the Affair page 112 12 The End of the Affair screen play by Neil Jordan (1999) 13 The End of the Affair page 59 14 Snow falling on Cedars page 312 15 Snow Falling on Cedars page 303-304 16 Twayne's English Authors Series Online - A.A DeVitis 17 Snow Falling on Cedars page 311 18 Francis Wyndham 19 Snow Falling on Cedars page 56 20 Barbara Bleiman - e-magazine author 21 Snow Falling on Cedars page 21 22 The End of the Affair page 44 23 The End of the Affair page 31 24 Snow Falling on Cedars (screenplay) Scott Hicks 25 The End of the Affair page 160 26 Snow Falling on Cedars page 404 27 The End of the Affair - quote by Leon Bloy 28 The End of the Affair page 36 29 Snow Falling on Cedars page 310 ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level David Guterson section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level David Guterson essays

  1. What is the significance of the island setting and the weather in Snow falling ...

    Snow makes everything "one world" and makes everything equal, like the description of the sea being "just one ocean" however although the sea "mixes underneath" on the outside perspective the differences remain prominent and "wrong" The fog is also significant as it obstructs your senses of seeing and hearing, which

  2. What impression do we get of the community from the descriptions Guterson provides in ...

    people who live on the small island, we can see that the islanders feel very uncomfortable towards people who they don't know or who are from another country. The first incidence we see this is aimed at the reporters who are placed next to the radiators giving out sweltering heat,

  1. Snow Falling on Cedars

    As the linear flow of the novel is interrupted, Heine recalls telling her husband, "We're not such paupers as to sell to Japs, are we?" The victim's wife, Susan Marie shows that she is not inherently prejudiced but knows little of Japanese culture and is therefore wary.

  2. In "Snow Falling on Cedars," write about the way Guterson presents the character of ...

    He is married to Hatsue and has three children. Guterson displays Kabuo throughout the novel to still have his religious faith, although his faith does not comfort him. This is surprising as many people would have lost their religious faith because no one seemed to be looking over him.

  1. How does the author create suspense in chapter two of the "Snow Falling on ...

    Also the author uses very long sentences, which again slows down the pace of the chapter, this changes towards the end of the chapter. The pace increases in speed, which also increases the intensity and the fact that something is going to happen.

  2. Snow Falling on Cedars.

    It is ambiguous in its representation as it is often described as "beautiful" and "rare" and "precious", allowing an insight to Ismaels' memory of his childhood with Hatsue but also gains the opposite interpretation of destruction through the "ferocious" weather overturning the cars, which represents the negative and positve sides of all the situations, perceptions and relationships in San Piedro.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work