• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the ways in which Larkin and Abse write about journeys and visits.

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Compare the ways in which Larkin and Abse write about journeys and visits. In your response you must include detailed critical discussion of at least two of Larkin?s poems. Whenever Larkin presents journeys or visits throughout The Whitsun Weddings, Larkin or the persona, although Larkin always seems to use his own voice in these poems, are shown to be more interested in the lives of the people he sees or shares the journey with than the scenery, as he continues the poems into fantasizing about their lives and emotions. For example, in The Whitsun Weddings, he begins by just describing the unremarkable sight of a provincial train journey, ?the river?s level drifting breadth?, but later begins to make inferences about the guests and their feelings, ?the women shared the secret like a happy funeral?, showing his has unintentionally become attached. In contrast, from the beginning of his poems Abse is always shown to be attached, whereas Larkin presents a lonely ?voyager? who becomes swept along with others. Both Here and The Whitsun Weddings describe a lone train journey in which Larkin becomes intrigued about the people around him. At the beginning of both poems, he presents a slight irony of a disenchanted and detached observer simply describing a journey. ...read more.


Although Larkin is presented as detached and isolated from others on his journeys, neither the Whitsun Weddings nor Here hold a tone which suggests he is particularly unhappy. However, on Abse?s returns to Wales, his poems have a semantic field of dread and sadness, as he is attached to the place and the people there. Whilst Larkin makes all of his journeys through choice, the undertone of Down the M4 suggests that Abse sees visits as an obligation, ?dutiful son going back to South Wales?, which could explain Abse?s unusually low tone. In Down the M4 and Dockery and Son, both Larkin and Abse are returning to a place they spent a significant period of their life. For Larkin, what begins as a visit to presumably his university a more metaphorical journey, as he realises his own isolation and lack of attachment to anywhere or anyone through comparisons with Dockery. However, it could be argued that Larkin was always aware of this, as even at the beginning he is gently mocking his lone ?death suited? figure who attempts to reengage with the past, ?I try the door of where I used to live? buts finds it ?locked? and departs on the train ?ignored?. This suggests an awareness of the presentation in these poems of an unnoticed figure simply ?passing through?, which could be argued ...read more.


However, Larkin addresses the wider issue of the journey towards death, suggesting through the image of the ?thick and close sand clouds? that it?s closing in. The last two lines of the poem could be interpreted as suggesting we have no control over the journeys we make in life, ?what something hidden from us chose?, however this could merely be an attempt by Larkin to comfort himself. When writing about journeys, Larkin leaves himself exposed by showing direct involvement without the protection of a persona. He presents different degrees of involvement with the lives of those he passes, as in Here he is merely supposing about the lives of ?residents from raw estates? whereas in the Whitsun Weddings, he includes himself in his descriptions, pondering on the directions of their lives will take. It could be argued then that the Whitsun Weddings isn?t simply about his own train journey but about the journeys of the ?fresh couples? in their lives. In contrast, Abse is solely focused on his own journey and that of those close to him, suggesting that involvement with people or places can lead to narrow sightedness about the world around, as it simply passes by unnoticed. Finally, as could arguably be expected of Larkin, he leaves all three poems on a note of discomfort about the possibility of death and uncertainty at the end of the journey, suggesting our journeys are beyond our control. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philip Larkin section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philip Larkin essays

  1. What impression do we form of childhood in "I Remember, I Remember" and "Growing ...

    It was only the foundations of what he would experience in later life. He seems ashamed and embarrassed about his childhood when the poet writes, "staring at my boots". At the same time, this implies boredom, too. It is in a complete contrast to the question that his friend asks

  2. Comparing four or more poems, including those of Brian Pattern - Show how the ...

    Continuing to do these things for her must show a lot of love and compassion towards her. He ants her alive and by her side, he's afraid to let go. In the second verse Harrison describes the dysfunctional ways in which he doesn't let go. 'You couldn't just drop in.

  1. Compare and Contrast "Trees in the Garden" by D.H.Lawrence And "The Trees" by P.Larkin

    The Trees does not have as many evocative phrases. This may be because the poet is trying to create the effect of the poem being more of a 'sob story' of how life is too short. The adjectives he does use are in the form of complaints: "...greenness..."

  2. Here is unfenced existence, from Here by Phip Larkin. Both he and Dannie Abse ...

    However, the poem immediately starts up again, with the repetition of the word 'swerving' which reinforces the sense of free movement. Now, Larkin takes us through the 'fields/too thin and thistled to be called meadows', before the poem is again interrupted by the influence of the human world where the poem halts for the 'Workmen at dawn'.

  1. Compare the ways in which Larkin and Abse talk about families

    but also from fear that they'll be forgot, thus 'add to themselves'. In direct contrast, Abse describes his son as "his chameleon", which again suggests that children are a continuation of oneself, however the positive connotations associated with the language used, "my soft diamond" suggests that Abse sees this as a extension of himself, rather than a dilution.

  2. Compare the ways in which Larkin and Abse create a sense of place in ...

    As may be expected of Larkin, he shows a disliking for consumerism, ?cheap suits?, as a critic remarked ?Larkin?s presentation of the growth of consumer culture evinces nostalgia for the innocence of the past?. Although for Larkin the countryside is depicted as ?gold? and ?shining?, as the train draws further

  1. Larkin explores the gap between romantic yearning and disillusioned pragmatism in the lives we ...

    Larkin not only makes harmless words stand out to make a comment on the falsities of reality he also does it through the use of harmless actions. ?slapped up? adds to the satirical ?make up?- this would normally be seen as careless and colloquial language but Larkin deliberately makes it

  2. Here, Whitsun Weddings and Dockery and Son are all poems written by Larkin that ...

    The ?raw estates? conjure up images of wounds roughened, sore and painful; perhaps a remnant of the war that only 15 years previously ripped the country apart. Here, Larkin?s anger comes to a head as he mockingly utilises the phrase ?pastoral? (which evokes ideas of rural idylls)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work