Comparing and Contrasting ‘Disabled’ And ‘Anthem for doomed youth’

Authors Avatar

Nigel Tolentino 10A

Comparing and Contrasting

‘Disabled’

And

‘Anthem for doomed youth’

        In Wilfred Owens poetry he is trying to achieve the goal of describing the war the way it really is. As some poets glamorise the war, Owen tells it how it is. It shows how it is like going to war, when your in the middle of the actual war, and the coming home from the war. He explains and we realise that war is not what it seems, it is not all good. He points out the disadvantages of war and he puts them into a way everyone will understand. He really wants the reader to visualise what would be happening, he expresses all his pain in his poetry. Further more he writes as a disabled person and what it is to be like when you are coming home from the war, really nothing but bad things can come of writing about something like this.

        My choices of poems, ‘Anthem for doomed youth’ and ‘Disabled’ are especially suitable for this type of extended writing. This would be because they are both along the same lines, this would help me tell sort of my own story as ‘Anthem for doomed youth’ is going to war and ‘Disabled’ is when you get back. It shows the reality of war. They explain each and every detail in similes, so everyone can understand. Owen tries his hardest to destroy that image of being a glamorous soldier. The narrator Owen describes that he is in the poem, for example, in ‘Disabled’ Owen is the man in the wheel chair, we can tell because right away in the first line, he says it clearly; “he sat in a wheeled chair’. As a live human, I would not want to be disabled and I do not wish it on any one else. You become so isolated and different from how you use to be like. Owen is very good when explaining this; “before he threw away his knees”, this explains that he wishes he could turn back time and not be so foolish as to join the army thinking nothing but good can come out of it, but what did he get instead?, nothing but bad out of it, I think because of this shock to him he must have been very angry to find out he had wasted his life.

Join now!

        The different types of atmosphere Owen tries to evoke are not those far off of a funeral. Owen creates the atmosphere of loneliness and dullness. He achieves this by “And shivered in his ghastly suit of grey” grey suggests dullness as grey is known as a dull colour, lifeless. From ‘Disabled’ the atmospheres I also seem to notice are death and hopelessness. It is as if Owen is dead. Even though Owen is not dead it seems as if he is because he is disabled and the fact that he is rendered helpless because of his disability to walk. Also ...

This is a preview of the whole essay