Contrast betweem 'Belfast confetti' and 'No More Hiroshimas'.

Authors Avatar

CALEIGH GRAHAM

CONTRAST BETWEEN BELFAST CONFETTI AND NO MORE HIROSHIMAS 

The similarity between these poems is fairly obvious. Both of these poems are about war. The situation of the authors however, are different. Ciaran Carson, author of ‘Belfast Confetti’ makes this poem very frantic and fearful as the poem is set in the present tense when he is actually experiencing war. James Kirkup however, has set ‘No More Hiroshimas’ partly in both present and past tenses. Although, the most dramatic part of the poem is set in the past. The author is not experiencing war during the poem, but remembering how much suffering it caused and how Hiroshima is still trying to rebuild itself and the community.

The main themes in ‘No More Hiroshimas’ are sympathy and a numbing feeling of loss and emptiness. “It is right, this squat, dead place, with its left-over air.” The themes for ‘Belfast Confetti’ is however a complete contrast, including fear, confusion and chaos caused by the war. “Where am I coming from? Where am I going? A fusillade of question-marks.”

Join now!

The imagery in both poems is extremely vivid. At the start of ‘No More Hiroshimas’ the poem is describing how the city has been left nowadays: “a flimsy department-store” and “Racks of towers and neons”. This gives the city a cheap and artificial mental picture for the reader. The author contrasts pleasant images with unpleasant ones to emphasise this artificiality: “glitter frost and artificial pearls” and flatulent balloons.” The imagery towards the end of the poem becomes hard hitting: “The stopped watches, the torn shirts.” And “The twisted buttons.” This emphasises the impact and makes the reader think clearly of ...

This is a preview of the whole essay