• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss how understanding the relationship between Brenda and Tony Last in a Handful of Dust is furthered by the reading of a Room with a View

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Discuss how understanding the relationship between Brenda and Tony Last in a Handful of Dust is furthered by the reading of a Room with a View It is clear from the start that Tony and Brenda's relationship is doomed. Brenda, a former socialite, is completely and utterly bored with her monotonous relationship, and completely and utterly bored with her equally monotonous husband, and this is best conveyed in Waugh's depiction of the couple's breakfast routine. Waugh seems to have the ambition of emphasizing his skepticism for relationships, and does so by writing the sad tale of Tony and Brenda Last. Waugh creates a sense of monotony easily and skillfully. For example, "Only four of the six churches were visible that morning". This is a perfect example of how boring Tony's character really is. One of his daily highlights is to see church spires out of Brenda's window. Everyday. The author really wants to convey to the audience that here is a man who is very much stuck in his ways. He shows no desire for change and adventure, which is exactly what Brenda desires. When Tony responds to an invitation to a party with "Not on her life!" Brenda replies with, "No, I guessed not." She is resigned to putting up with her dull life, and seems, at first at the very least, quite self-sacrificial and to be a considerate wife. ...read more.

Middle

Simply the name is an ironic choice, as it doesn't suit his character. Beavers, by nature, are industrious and hard-working animals, and John Beaver is as far removed from his namesake as could be. Waugh shows that he has absolutely no prospects of employment. By portraying him in this way, Waugh depicts to the reader how desperate and lonely Brenda really is, as she will take up any company available. This is further expressed by how quickly she warms to Beaver. At the first hint of Beaver's arrival, Brenda suggests that "he can go into Galahad, no one who sleeps there ever comes again." However, she soon changes her mind, "Next time you come again you must have a better room ... I daresay you wont ever come again, people so seldom do." She is charmed, somehow, after spending only a day with him, and is eager to spend more time in his company. This further serves to highlight Tony's naivety and his misguided trust in his wife, which he does throughout the novel. Waugh also hints at Tony's naivety continuously throughout the novel. Tony states that Brenda was 'heroic with Beaver', to which she replies that she was 'coping' with it, and she enjoyed his company, hinting at their growing intimacy. ...read more.

Conclusion

Forster, conversely, uses rounded characters who mature and adapt as A room with a View unfolds. Whereas Waugh wants to show how he doesn't want culture and society, and even people to change, Forster has a more accepting view of this. A room with a view is also lacking in Waugh's cynical satire, taking a more romantic view on relationships. Lucy, the central character, eventually ends up with George, her true love, proving that love can overcome many obstacles. However, in a Handful of dust the protagonist is left in the Amazon jungle. It is apparent from the offset that Brenda and Tony's relationship is doomed in the novel 'A handful of Dust.' Waugh makes their differences clear throughout the novel, also making clear his distaste at the relationships within the English Upper-class. Brenda's further progression into a relationship with Jock Grant-Menzies, whilst Lucy remains with George, further emphasizes Waugh and Forster's different views, with Waugh's satirical sadness contrasting with Forster's acceptance and romanticism. Despite Lucy and Cecil's relationship being doomed, she did not act as unscrupulously with George as Brenda with Beaver, and this is the key point of comparison between the two novels. A Room with a View is a tale of love, hope and morality. A handful of Dust is an account of the author's sadness as the demise of conventions in adapting upper-class society. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Authors section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Authors essays

  1. In A Passage to India the Marabar Hills and Caves possess a powerful symbolic ...

    Perhaps Forster is also suggesting that Mrs. Moore's depression, caused by the visit to the caves, is because she now has a nihilistic approach to life. As stated earlier, Forster tells us that nothing attaches to the caves. Godbole is shown as being disturbed by them.

  2. Explore the relationship between Paul Morel and his mother.

    When he feels he has hurt her he cannot bear it. The only life Paul has apart from his mother is his sexual one. By the end of the novel he finds it extremely difficult to be a 'Son and a lover', discovering at last that he must choose between his mother and his female sexual partners.

  1. Explore the way Barker portrays the relationship between doctor and patient in Regeneration showing ...

    Rivers' role is very much as a messenger for us, in that he asks patients the questions we all want answering too. Barker also adopts dialogue between doctor and patient to depict the impact of war on the soldiers. The third person omniscient narrator enables the reader to know the thoughts and feelings of each of the characters.

  2. Through a close examination of two or three passages from Scoop and consideration of ...

    When William Boot does reach London and arrives at the Megalopolitan building, he assumes he has been called to write about 'great crested grebes' and 'badgers'.

  1. How is John Hilliard's character developed, in the novel "Strange Meeting" by Susan Hill?

    Therefore, Barton?s face being hidden from Hilliard, denies Hilliard the ability to observe Barton?s thoughts and feelings, in other words, Hilliard is denied intimacy by Barton. Hilliard seeks intimacy with Barton, using an expressive understanding tone. When Barton speaks about the shame he feels because the war has hardened him,

  2. The relationship between Pelagia and Dr. Iannis is the key relationship it is very ...

    De Berniere's reinforced the strength and wilfulness Pelagia has but he also makes the point that the society do not give women status and makes it clear that it is her father?s status that has allowed her to behave like this ?the fact that her father was the doctor gave

  1. Analyse the relationship between Lally and Doris in chapters 8-10 of 'Vernon God Little'

    It also conveys that Doris thinks Vernon is trying to split them up, which she thinks is because Vernon doesn?t like Lally because he?s trying to replace his father, which although may be true to a certain extent, is not the real source of his hatred for Lally.

  2. To The Lighthouse - reading report

    Lily bristled at outspoken comments made by Charles Tansley, who suggested that women could neither paint nor write. Mr. Ramsay reacted rudely when Augustus Carmichael, a poet, asked for a second plate of soup. The joy, however, like the party itself, could not last longer and as Mrs.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work