• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

English Belonging Essay. Raimond Gaitas memoir Romulus, My Father, the 2007 ABC Compass story From Cronulla to Kokoda and the 2008 film The Black Balloon.

Extracts from this document...


English ? Belonging Essay ?The Feeling of Belonging brings about a sense of comfort and security.? The concept of Belonging can bring about a sense of comfort and security it can represent being part of a group, whether defined as social, cultural, racial, historical, political or religious. In one sense, man is a herd animal and has an innate instinct to belong to a group for security and well-being. Core and related texts reveal that the protagonists, whether due to circumstance or desire, fall outside the group. This is evident in Raimond Gaita?s memoir ?Romulus, My Father?, the 2007 ABC Compass story ?From Cronulla to Kokoda? and the 2008 film ?The Black Balloon.? Gaita?s memoir reveals how Romulus, a reluctant eastern European immigrant to Australia in the 1950?s, is caught between two diverse cultures, struggling to belong as a ?New Australian?. His sense of alienation is partly due to experiences of discrimination in Australia, ?...the authorities... chose not to utilise the many skills of the foreign workers... my father this unusually gifted man was set to work with a pick and shovel.? Here, Gaita, through contrast, reveals tones of admiration and frustration, as Romulus? talent is undermined by having to resort to basic labour. ...read more.


child growing up, ?When I was a kid growing up in Australia it was sort of weird, because I used to have different lunch to everyone else. And they?d have birthday parties and things like that, or just places they?d go different to us.? It is evident here that Ali has always struggled in Australia similar to Romulus due to their cultural heritages. Life as an outsider, due to dysfunctional families, often creates a strong urge to belong. This is exemplified in Gaita?s portrayal of Romulus, who is forced to flee his home due to domestic violence after trying ?to protect his grandfather from a beating?. This quote reveals Romulus? courage and love for his grandfather. History repeats itself when Gaita also suffers a dysfunctional childhood and both father and son are denied a sense of family, due to the instability of their wife and mother, Christine, caused by her depression, infidelities and neglect. Gaita employs assonance and symbol to describe her torment, ?A dead red gum...became for my mother a symbol of her desolation?. ...read more.


Thomas struggles to accept him, vacillating between love, understanding, embarrassment and resentment. His father responds to his conflicting emotions, ?All I know is he?s my own, and you?re weak if you don?t look after your own?. The repetition reinforces the importance of family responsibility, a value shared by Romulus. The ignorance of neighbours is apparent through dramatic irony when they complain to Family Welfare about violence when in fact lovable Charlie is simply behaving boisterously. Thomas? peers taunt him calling his brother ?a spastic? but his caring friend, Jacquie states, ?Don?t worry what those stupid boys at school think. You have to stop wishing Charlie was normal. It?s never going to change?. Like Romulus there is the painful challenge to belong to a dysfunctional family but Thomas heeds his father?s metaphorical advice, reflecting values of the Aussie battler, ?Son, s**t in one hand, wish in the other and see which one gets full fastest? finally accepting his ?lot?. The personal, cultural, social and racial relations explored in the abovementioned texts reinforce the notion that we all yearn to belong for security and well being. For those who happen to fall outside the group, belonging offers a sense of place, self-worth, refuge and consolation, vital to making life easier in our hectic world. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Criticism & Comparison section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Criticism & Comparison essays

  1. A well-known movie is Minority Report, which uses several themes from Oedipus the King.

    This leads to the second prophecy real, making his a blind beggar. While in Minority Report, John runs as well when he sees a vision of himself killing Leo Crowe. Again trying to avoid fate fails, since Leo Crowe eventually dies. This film thus proves that fate cannot be defeated.

  2. Compare and Contrast the Roles of Gender in The Yellow Wallpaper and The Bluest ...

    However Cholly the father of Percola doesn?t live up to these social expectations and instead is seen as a social outcast and a man of a degrading nature, no longer able to provide for his family.

  1. Cold War Literature - the particular ways of thinking present throughout the Cold War ...

    through the use of repeating images of children, which appear throughout the text as symbols of innocence, easily swayed by others. The manipulation of Liz in the courtroom ?like a blind child? conveys the potential control over interpretation through the suppression of context.

  2. Examine how classes have different class conditions, communities and values in both North and ...

    Working class families owned property of their own despite their low income preventing them to fully furnish their houses. Orwell also uses concrete vocabulary when describing the ?dreadful room in Wigan?. The ?packing cases? and ?barrel staves? used to build ?furniture? enables the reader to visualise how many working class home owners decorated their rooms.

  1. Compare the ways in which Philip Larkin and Carol Ann Duffy present the theme ...

    how our bodies are only perceived as vessels for our souls, and that without them, we are powerless. The witnesses, ie the children and women, show to have realised this reality. The epiphany delivered slowly in ?And sense the solving emptiness? uses the present continuous to suggest that this experience

  2. Comparing "That surprising Craig girl!" advert (Text 25), and the online news article "Why ...

    The reception of this article is also very positive since the article is very approachable to the general public ?we don?t need this? this is also done through the informality of the piece ?Beefed up? the use of the pun makes the reader more relaxed.

  1. To what extent does Oscar Wilde's "The Importance of Being Earnest" conform to the ...

    "I like you already more than I can say". However, when they find out they are both engaged to Ernest they become bitter rivals. They both produce diaries of their own seeking for the recorded date of the proposal. This is satire as they think it is a fact because they wrote it down.

  2. Our identity in a community is determined by ones own internal emotional view of ...

    Finally, Individuals must make choices between different places, communities and other people who offer them different senses of belonging. This is shown by Winton in Breath again through the persona Pikelet when he said ?Everything around me seemed so pointless and puny/ Wherever I went I felt like the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work