• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Some critics have seen Gertrude as innocent, others as central to the evil in Hamlet - Using act 3 scene 4 as your starting point, how do you evaluate these views?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Ben Campbell Word count 1597 Some critics have seen Gertrude as innocent, others as central to the evil in Hamlet. Using act 3 scene 4 as your starting point, how do you evaluate these views? It is tempting to condemn Gertrude as evil, but it is probably more sensible to consider her as weak and inconstant. But when have tragedy plays ever been sensible? Like many of Shakespeare's women it is argued that their characters are somewhat "sketched in" rather than drawn in with detail like for example, Hamlet's. The way Shakespeare has "sketched in" Gertrude's character leads an awful lot down to the way she is played on the stage. When reading the play Gertrude's character is enigmatic. This leads a lot down to personal interpretation upon reading the play. We also have to take the culture of that period in time into consideration when examining Gertrude's character. Act 3 scene 4 emphasises this showing us two separate arguments for the portrayal of Gertrude's character. An interpretation that I would like to explore is Gertrude as an evil character in the play. There are several significant points that illuminate the evil side to her character. ...read more.

Middle

Shakespeare clearly chose this name because Gertrude isn't an innocent woman, as she likes to portray herself, but a clever powerful woman who is masterful in deceit. We see the deceitful side to Gertrude's nature when she allows Polonius to listen in on a private conversation between mother and son. Why doesn't she just let Hamlet see Polonius? Is it just to avoid confrontation? Or is it because she's holding something back from Hamlet? Another example of Gertrude's dishonesty is when she sends Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to spy on Hamlet. This behaviour is clearly not of an honest person. Hamlet sees through the superficial reason for their visit by cleverly questioning them, but why go behind Hamlet's back so frequently? Upon looking at the side of the argument for Gertrude being central to the evil in Hamlet I would now like to explore the argument for Gertrude as innocent and not a deceitful, evil character. There is a possibility that Gertrude's actions after her husband's death were prompted by self-preservation. A convenient marriage to a known protector would, after all, ensure her safety and that of her beloved son, whom she may have considered too inexperienced and vulnerable to take responsibility of ruling a threatened country. ...read more.

Conclusion

They argue that male criticism over the years has neglected and repressed female experience. Gertrude is at the hands of a male writer and male critics over the years, they too tend to adopt Hamlet's misogynistic views. Rebecca Smith [feminist critic] argues that Gertrude has been: "traditionally played as a sensual, deceitful woman...but the traditional depiction of Gertrude is a false one, because what her words and actions actually create is a soft, obedient, dependent, unimaginative woman who is caught at the centre of a struggle between two "mighty opposites". Upon looking at this secondary criticism it shows us another dimension of argument for Gertrude's innocence as a character. Gertrude's character is very equivocal in that she can be interpreted in many ways, and there be strong arguments for both sides. Gertrude's character is strongly influenced by her stage portrayal. I think Shakespeare did this intentionally to keep a certain ambiguity about the character. We know so far that Gertrude is capable of deceiving people and being sensual but also she puts up pretence that she is completely innocent and frail. Is Gertrude capable of deceiving Hamlet? Are her intentions with Claudius for her own gain? In conclusion I think that Gertrude isn't innocent and weak nor is she central to the evil but she is deceiving and illusory in her actions. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Hamlet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Hamlet essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Explore the way Shakespeare presents the relationships between Hamlet and his Mother, Gertrude, making ...

    4 star(s)

    The ghost of old Hamlet then appears, although Gertrude cannot see it. The ghost could have been another ploy from Hamlet to make his mother believe that he is mad, but I also think that the Ghost is Hamlet externalising his own thoughts, only showing them in his father's persona for the audience's point of view.

  2. Write a Critical Analysis on Hamlet Act 3 Scene 4

    Gertrude becomes confused, her heart has been divided into two and she doesn't know in which direction to turn. Hamlet tells her that she should throw away the bad part of her heart and keep the good part of it; he wants her to pretend that she is virtuous even if she isn't.

  1. Discuss these two views and consider any other response of your own, as regards ...

    This may have an act of mistaken identity, possibly believing that it was Claudius behind the curtain. But after so many opportunities to kill Claudius at an earlier time, what possessed him to attack at that moment? This irrational murder had many repercussions which again manipulated his situation.

  2. 'Hamlet has been read by critics as dramatically presenting a misfit in a politically ...

    In my reading I have observed that Hamlet expresses his father's feelings for his mother as 'love' but his mother's feelings for his father as 'appetite'. This marks significantly his new awareness of the 'grossness' of nature in general and of his mother in particular.

  1. Look back Act III, Scene 3. This scene has been seen by some critics ...

    The death of Polonius is a turning point of the change of Hamlet's attitude and the language towards Gertrude. Before the death of Polonius, they exchange odd conversation- 'Come, come, you answer with an idle tongue.' 'Go, go you question with a wicked tongue.'

  2. Commentary of Hamlet Act 3 Scene 4.

    He does this by barely acknowledging what the Queen blames him of, and merely uses her words to bounce of and twist into an accusation towards her; e.g. by changing the person who has the name "father" to him, it is as if Hamlet is correcting her words.

  1. How does Shakespeare explore the nature of evil in the play, 'Hamlet'?

    and not to use Hamlet's madness as an excuse for his words - "Lay not that madness upon your soul/That not your trespass but my madness speaks/It will but skin and film the ulcerous place/Whiles rank corruption, mining all within/Infects unseen."

  2. Criticism on Hamlet

    as have watched men only in the beaten road of their feelings. But the final - "all may be well!" is remarkable;- the degree of merit attributed by the self-flattering soul to its own struggle, though baffled, and to the indefinite half-promise, half-command, to persevere in religious duties.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work