"The true interest of 'The Winter's Tale' lies not with Leontes but rather with the female characters - abused Hermione, faithful and tenacious Paulina and the beautiful, chaste and innocent Perdita."

Authors Avatar

Alexandra Spencer-Jones

L6C - ENGLISH LITERATURE

"The true interest of 'The Winter's Tale' lies not with Leontes but rather with the female characters - abused Hermione, faithful and tenacious Paulina and the beautiful, chaste and innocent Perdita."

To what extent do you agree with this view of the play?

In my opinion 'The Winter's Tale' is a play about human error. It is about the mistakes that people can make and how hard it is to forgive oneself for making them. Most of all it about how time can bring healing change. Leontes is the character who best exemplifies all of these themes throughout the play.

He is the character whose personality changes most and he is the one who is "resolved". However, the question asks whether the true interest of the play lies not with Leontes but rather with the leading women. It is certainly true that Hermione, Paulina and Perdita are not just predictable stereotypes of women but they are very similar to other female characters from the plays of Shakespeare. The best comparison of these is "abused" Hermione. She has a similar situation to Desdemona from 'Othello'. She is falsely accused and treated unfairly, though the obvious difference is that Hermione does not actually die whereas Desdemona does. The situation of being thought dead however does occur with Hermione. Also, Hermione can be compared to Cordelia from 'King Lear'. Cordelia is honest and true and yet bluntly abused and cast out by Lear, for no reason, throughout the majority of the play. Paulina is "faithful and tenacious" and in some ways similar to the character of Emilia from 'Othello'. She stays close to her Lady and looks after her when she is supposedly dead for sixteen years. Paulina also takes a great interest in the King and his security and sanity. Perdita (the lost child) is similar to the character of Miranda from 'The Tempest'. She is "beautiful", "chaste" and "innocent". Her identity is hidden. By making these comparisons we can see parallels between other Shakespearean characters and the women of the play.

Leontes is similar to the character of Othello. He also is driven by the mistake of morbid jealousy. They are protagonists, originally destroyed by blinding jealousy, though in the case of Leontes, redeemed by Hermione's forgiveness. The difference between these characters is what distinguishes Leontes from any other Shakespearean character and makes, in my opinion "the true interest" of the play. As Harold Bloom argues. "Leontes is the Iago to his own Othello". Unlike Othello he does not have anybody to urge on his suspicions and is entirely driven by his own jealousy and paranoia. In fact, Leontes feels as if he has to be reassured of his wife's infidelity constantly through the first section of the play. In Act 1, Scene 2 he asks Camillo, his loyal subject if he noticed his wife and her apparently unconventional behaviour, "Dids't thou note it?". The character of Leontes is so unusual as he is portrayed as having an actual illness, a mental and all consuming morbid jealousy.  The women in the play clearly provide solace for the audience during the "madness" of Leontes.

Join now!

This is not to say however that the roles of the women are not vital to the play. Each one of the women plays an important part that adds another layer to the texture of the play. Hermione is stable and warm hearted. She is the wife and mother whose virtue is only ever questioned by her husband: "I would not be a stander-by to hear my sovereign mistress clouded without my present vengeance taken," says Camillo (Act 1, Scene 2). The persuasive fluidity and tone of the language that she uses with Polixenes is very different from the language ...

This is a preview of the whole essay